GET https://kbin.spritesserver.nl/index.php/u/@fosforus@sopuli.xyz/top?p=4

Response
200 OK
IP
216.73.216.26
Profiled on
Token
86744c

Security

Token

There is no security token.

Firewall

main Name
Security enabled
Stateless

Configuration

Key Value
provider security.user.provider.concrete.app_user_provider
context main
entry_point App\Security\KbinAuthenticator
user_checker App\Security\UserChecker
access_denied_handler (none)
access_denied_url (none)
authenticators 
[
  "two_factor"
  "remember_me"
  "App\Security\KbinAuthenticator"
  "App\Security\FacebookAuthenticator"
  "App\Security\GoogleAuthenticator"
  "App\Security\GithubAuthenticator"
  "App\Security\KeycloakAuthenticator"
]

Listeners

Listener Duration Response 
Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\ChannelListener {#723
  -map: Symfony\Component\Security\Http\AccessMap {#722 …}
  -logger: Monolog\Logger {#783 …}
  -httpPort: 80
  -httpsPort: 443
}
 0.00 ms (none) 
Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\ContextListener {#706
  -tokenStorage: Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\TokenStorage {#1017 …}
  -sessionKey: "_security_main"
  -logger: Monolog\Logger {#783 …}
  -userProviders: Symfony\Component\DependencyInjection\Argument\RewindableGenerator {#705 …}
  -dispatcher: Symfony\Component\EventDispatcher\Debug\TraceableEventDispatcher {#747 …}
  -registered: false
  -trustResolver: Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authentication\AuthenticationTrustResolver {#780 …}
  -sessionTrackerEnabler: Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\UsageTrackingTokenStorage::enableUsageTracking(): void {#703 …}
}
 9.26 ms (none) 
Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\AuthenticatorManagerListener {#584
  -authenticatorManager: Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Authentication\AuthenticatorManager {#595 …}
}
 0.00 ms (none) 
Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Http\Firewall\TwoFactorAccessListener {#582
  -twoFactorFirewallConfig: Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\TwoFactor\TwoFactorFirewallConfig {#842 …}
  -tokenStorage: Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\UsageTrackingTokenStorage {#1018 …}
  -twoFactorAccessDecider: Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\TwoFactorAccessDecider {#581 …}
}
 0.07 ms (none) 
Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\AccessListener {#579
  -tokenStorage: Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\UsageTrackingTokenStorage {#1018 …}
  -accessDecisionManager: Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\TraceableAccessDecisionManager {#937 …}
  -map: Symfony\Component\Security\Http\AccessMap {#722 …}
}
 0.00 ms (none) 
Symfony\Component\Security\Http\Firewall\LogoutListener {#786
  -tokenStorage: Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authentication\Token\Storage\UsageTrackingTokenStorage {#1018 …}
  -options: [
    "csrf_parameter" => "_csrf_token"
    "csrf_token_id" => "logout"
    "logout_path" => "app_logout"
  ]
  -httpUtils: Symfony\Component\Security\Http\HttpUtils {#841 …}
  -csrfTokenManager: Symfony\Component\Security\Csrf\CsrfTokenManager {#1015 …}
  -eventDispatcher: Symfony\Component\EventDispatcher\Debug\TraceableEventDispatcher {#747 …}
}
 0.00 ms (none)

Authenticators

No authenticators have been recorded. Check previous profiles on your authentication endpoint.

Access Decision

affirmative Strategy
# Voter class
1 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\AuthenticatedVoter"
2 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
3 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
4 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\ExpressionVoter"
5 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
6 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
7 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
8 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
9 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
10 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
11 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
12 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
13 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
14 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"

Access decision log

# Result Attributes Object
1 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
2 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3103 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3143 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3145 …}
  +slug: "Super-secret"
  +title: "Super secret"
  +url: "https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/a71067ab-720c-4971-af40-0c172942a30b.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 3
  +favouriteCount: 37
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#3138
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3146 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3148 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3150 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3152 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3154 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3156 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "What a bitch."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#2176
        date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Facelikeapotato@lemmy.ml"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2184 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2169 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2134 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1985 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1994 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2005 …}
      -id: 221054
      -bodyTs: "'bitch':3"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4748086"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700481187 {#2174
        date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 221054
    }
  ]
  -id: 18004
  -titleTs: "'secret':2 'super':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700531359
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.ml/post/8209683"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700444959 {#3125
    date: 2023-11-20 02:49:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
3 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3103 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3143 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3145 …}
  +slug: "Super-secret"
  +title: "Super secret"
  +url: "https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/a71067ab-720c-4971-af40-0c172942a30b.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 3
  +favouriteCount: 37
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#3138
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3146 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3148 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3150 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3152 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3154 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3156 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "What a bitch."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#2176
        date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Facelikeapotato@lemmy.ml"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2184 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2169 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2134 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1985 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1994 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2005 …}
      -id: 221054
      -bodyTs: "'bitch':3"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4748086"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700481187 {#2174
        date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 221054
    }
  ]
  -id: 18004
  -titleTs: "'secret':2 'super':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700531359
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.ml/post/8209683"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700444959 {#3125
    date: 2023-11-20 02:49:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
4 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3103 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3143 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3145 …}
  +slug: "Super-secret"
  +title: "Super secret"
  +url: "https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/a71067ab-720c-4971-af40-0c172942a30b.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 3
  +favouriteCount: 37
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#3138
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3146 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3148 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3150 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3152 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3154 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3156 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "What a bitch."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#2176
        date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Facelikeapotato@lemmy.ml"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2184 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2169 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2134 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1985 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1994 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2005 …}
      -id: 221054
      -bodyTs: "'bitch':3"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4748086"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700481187 {#2174
        date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 221054
    }
  ]
  -id: 18004
  -titleTs: "'secret':2 'super':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700531359
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.ml/post/8209683"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700444959 {#3125
    date: 2023-11-20 02:49:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
5 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
6 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3103 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3143 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3145 …}
    +slug: "Super-secret"
    +title: "Super secret"
    +url: "https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/a71067ab-720c-4971-af40-0c172942a30b.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 3
    +favouriteCount: 37
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#3138
      date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3146 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3148 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3150 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3152 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3154 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3156 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178}
    ]
    -id: 18004
    -titleTs: "'secret':2 'super':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700531359
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.ml/post/8209683"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700444959 {#3125
      date: 2023-11-20 02:49:19.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "What a bitch."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#2176
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Facelikeapotato@lemmy.ml"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2184 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2169 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2134 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1985 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1994 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2005 …}
  -id: 221054
  -bodyTs: "'bitch':3"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4748086"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700481187 {#2174
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 221054
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
7 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3103 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3143 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3145 …}
    +slug: "Super-secret"
    +title: "Super secret"
    +url: "https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/a71067ab-720c-4971-af40-0c172942a30b.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 3
    +favouriteCount: 37
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#3138
      date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3146 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3148 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3150 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3152 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3154 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3156 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178}
    ]
    -id: 18004
    -titleTs: "'secret':2 'super':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700531359
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.ml/post/8209683"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700444959 {#3125
      date: 2023-11-20 02:49:19.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "What a bitch."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#2176
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Facelikeapotato@lemmy.ml"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2184 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2169 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2134 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1985 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1994 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2005 …}
  -id: 221054
  -bodyTs: "'bitch':3"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4748086"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700481187 {#2174
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 221054
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
8 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2170
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3103 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3143 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3145 …}
    +slug: "Super-secret"
    +title: "Super secret"
    +url: "https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/a71067ab-720c-4971-af40-0c172942a30b.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 3
    +favouriteCount: 37
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#3138
      date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3146 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3148 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3150 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3152 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3154 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3156 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2178}
    ]
    -id: 18004
    -titleTs: "'secret':2 'super':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700531359
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.ml/post/8209683"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700444959 {#3125
      date: 2023-11-20 02:49:19.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2183 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "What a bitch."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700481187 {#2176
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Facelikeapotato@lemmy.ml"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2184 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2169 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2134 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1985 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1994 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2005 …}
  -id: 221054
  -bodyTs: "'bitch':3"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4748086"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700481187 {#2174
    date: 2023-11-20 12:53:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 221054
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
9 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
10 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3067 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3105 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "I-didn-t-plan-this-far-ahead"
  +title: "I didn’t plan this far ahead"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3d3743ef-5800-4490-9803-a7f5c851bdc7.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 126
  +favouriteCount: 1288
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701143489 {#3100
    date: 2023-11-28 04:51:29.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3107 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3109 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3111 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3113 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3115 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3117 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
      +body: "ok"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700727941 {#2334
        date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@kismattic@lemmy.world"
        "@MystikIncarnate@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2343 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2335 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2338 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2143 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2136 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2073 …}
      -id: 153858
      -bodyTs: "'ok':1"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4836195"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700727941 {#2340
        date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 153858
    }
  ]
  -id: 15546
  -titleTs: "'ahead':7 'didn':2 'far':6 'plan':4"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700764754
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8614526"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700678354 {#3087
    date: 2023-11-22 19:39:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
11 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3067 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3105 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "I-didn-t-plan-this-far-ahead"
  +title: "I didn’t plan this far ahead"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3d3743ef-5800-4490-9803-a7f5c851bdc7.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 126
  +favouriteCount: 1288
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701143489 {#3100
    date: 2023-11-28 04:51:29.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3107 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3109 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3111 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3113 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3115 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3117 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
      +body: "ok"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700727941 {#2334
        date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@kismattic@lemmy.world"
        "@MystikIncarnate@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2343 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2335 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2338 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2143 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2136 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2073 …}
      -id: 153858
      -bodyTs: "'ok':1"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4836195"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700727941 {#2340
        date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 153858
    }
  ]
  -id: 15546
  -titleTs: "'ahead':7 'didn':2 'far':6 'plan':4"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700764754
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8614526"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700678354 {#3087
    date: 2023-11-22 19:39:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
12 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3067 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3105 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "I-didn-t-plan-this-far-ahead"
  +title: "I didn’t plan this far ahead"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3d3743ef-5800-4490-9803-a7f5c851bdc7.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 126
  +favouriteCount: 1288
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701143489 {#3100
    date: 2023-11-28 04:51:29.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3107 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3109 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3111 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3113 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3115 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3117 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
      +body: "ok"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700727941 {#2334
        date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@kismattic@lemmy.world"
        "@MystikIncarnate@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2343 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2335 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2338 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2143 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2136 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2073 …}
      -id: 153858
      -bodyTs: "'ok':1"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4836195"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700727941 {#2340
        date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 153858
    }
  ]
  -id: 15546
  -titleTs: "'ahead':7 'didn':2 'far':6 'plan':4"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700764754
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8614526"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700678354 {#3087
    date: 2023-11-22 19:39:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
13 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
14 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3067 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3105 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "I-didn-t-plan-this-far-ahead"
    +title: "I didn’t plan this far ahead"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3d3743ef-5800-4490-9803-a7f5c851bdc7.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 126
    +favouriteCount: 1288
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701143489 {#3100
      date: 2023-11-28 04:51:29.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3107 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3109 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3111 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3113 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3115 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3117 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341}
    ]
    -id: 15546
    -titleTs: "'ahead':7 'didn':2 'far':6 'plan':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700764754
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8614526"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700678354 {#3087
      date: 2023-11-22 19:39:14.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
  +body: "ok"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700727941 {#2334
    date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@kismattic@lemmy.world"
    "@MystikIncarnate@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2343 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2335 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2338 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2143 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2136 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2073 …}
  -id: 153858
  -bodyTs: "'ok':1"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4836195"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700727941 {#2340
    date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 153858
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
15 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3067 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3105 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "I-didn-t-plan-this-far-ahead"
    +title: "I didn’t plan this far ahead"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3d3743ef-5800-4490-9803-a7f5c851bdc7.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 126
    +favouriteCount: 1288
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701143489 {#3100
      date: 2023-11-28 04:51:29.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3107 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3109 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3111 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3113 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3115 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3117 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341}
    ]
    -id: 15546
    -titleTs: "'ahead':7 'didn':2 'far':6 'plan':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700764754
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8614526"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700678354 {#3087
      date: 2023-11-22 19:39:14.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
  +body: "ok"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700727941 {#2334
    date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@kismattic@lemmy.world"
    "@MystikIncarnate@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2343 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2335 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2338 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2143 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2136 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2073 …}
  -id: 153858
  -bodyTs: "'ok':1"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4836195"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700727941 {#2340
    date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 153858
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
16 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2342
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3067 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3105 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "I-didn-t-plan-this-far-ahead"
    +title: "I didn’t plan this far ahead"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3d3743ef-5800-4490-9803-a7f5c851bdc7.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 126
    +favouriteCount: 1288
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701143489 {#3100
      date: 2023-11-28 04:51:29.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3107 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3109 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3111 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3113 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3115 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3117 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2341}
    ]
    -id: 15546
    -titleTs: "'ahead':7 'didn':2 'far':6 'plan':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700764754
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8614526"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700678354 {#3087
      date: 2023-11-22 19:39:14.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2337 …}
  +body: "ok"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700727941 {#2334
    date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@kismattic@lemmy.world"
    "@MystikIncarnate@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2343 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2335 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2338 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2143 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2136 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2073 …}
  -id: 153858
  -bodyTs: "'ok':1"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4836195"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700727941 {#2340
    date: 2023-11-23 09:25:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 153858
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
17 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
18 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
  +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
  +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
  +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 71
  +favouriteCount: 634
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
    date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
  +children: [
    1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
      +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: null
        +root: null
        +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
          date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
        -id: 154222
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
          date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
          date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 154222
      }
      +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
        date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
      -id: 157489
      -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
        date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 157489
    }
    0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
  ]
  -id: 15533
  -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700762585
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
    date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
19 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
  +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
  +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
  +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 71
  +favouriteCount: 634
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
    date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
  +children: [
    1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
      +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: null
        +root: null
        +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
          date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
        -id: 154222
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
          date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
          date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 154222
      }
      +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
        date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
      -id: 157489
      -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
        date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 157489
    }
    0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
  ]
  -id: 15533
  -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700762585
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
    date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
20 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
  +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
  +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
  +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 71
  +favouriteCount: 634
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
    date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
  +children: [
    1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
      +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: null
        +root: null
        +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
          date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
        -id: 154222
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
          date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
          date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 154222
      }
      +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
        date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
      -id: 157489
      -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
        date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 157489
    }
    0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
  ]
  -id: 15533
  -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700762585
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
    date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
21 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
22 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
    +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
    +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
    +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 71
    +favouriteCount: 634
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
      date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
    +children: [
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052}
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: null
        +root: null
        +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
          date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
        -id: 154222
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
          date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
          date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 154222
      }
    ]
    -id: 15533
    -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700762585
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
      date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
  +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
  +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
    date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
  -id: 157489
  -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
    date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 157489
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
23 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
    +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
    +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
    +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 71
    +favouriteCount: 634
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
      date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
    +children: [
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052}
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: null
        +root: null
        +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
          date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
        -id: 154222
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
          date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
          date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 154222
      }
    ]
    -id: 15533
    -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700762585
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
      date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
  +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
  +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
    date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
  -id: 157489
  -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
    date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 157489
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
24 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
    +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
    +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
    +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 71
    +favouriteCount: 634
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
      date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
    +children: [
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052}
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: null
        +root: null
        +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
          date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
        -id: 154222
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
          date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
          date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 154222
      }
    ]
    -id: 15533
    -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700762585
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
      date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
  +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
  +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
    date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
  -id: 157489
  -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
    date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 157489
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
25 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
26 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
    +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
    +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
    +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 71
    +favouriteCount: 634
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
      date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
    +children: [
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
        +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
        +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 0
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
          date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
        -id: 157489
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
          date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 157489
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
    ]
    -id: 15533
    -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700762585
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
      date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
    date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
  -id: 154222
  -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
    date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
    date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 154222
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
27 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
    +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
    +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
    +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 71
    +favouriteCount: 634
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
      date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
    +children: [
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
        +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
        +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 0
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
          date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
        -id: 157489
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
          date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 157489
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
    ]
    -id: 15533
    -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700762585
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
      date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
    date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
  -id: 154222
  -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
    date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
    date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 154222
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
28 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3084 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3124 …}
    +slug: "Banksy-on-Advertising-Zen-Pencils"
    +title: "Banksy on Advertising [Zen Pencils]"
    +url: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/pictrs/image/5a38e085-a10a-4a6f-9b9e-5587eae659ed.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 71
    +favouriteCount: 634
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701124412 {#3119
      date: 2023-11-27 23:33:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3126 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3128 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3130 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3132 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3134 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3136 …}
    +children: [
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2052
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2066 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2054 …}
        +root: App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
        +body: "By kinda agreeing with some of the sentiment there?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 0
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1700804008 {#2050
          date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@AI_toothbrush@lemmy.zip"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2058 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2125 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2041 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2100 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2105 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2111 …}
        -id: 157489
        -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'kinda':2 'sentiment':8"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4857979"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700804008 {#2055
          date: 2023-11-24 06:33:28.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 157489
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2074}
    ]
    -id: 15533
    -titleTs: "'advertis':3 'banksi':1 'pencil':5 'zen':4"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700762585
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/8058041"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700676185 {#3106
      date: 2023-11-22 19:03:05.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "I kinda agree with some of the sentiment here, but if you hate the city, is it necessary to live there? I think it’s usually even more expensive than outside the city so you cannot explain it with money."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701322995 {#2072
    date: 2023-11-30 06:43:15.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@seitanic@lemmy.sdf.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2071 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2070 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2048 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2056 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2046 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2045 …}
  -id: 154222
  -bodyTs: "'agre':3 'cannot':36 'citi':15,33 'even':27 'expens':29 'explain':37 'hate':13 'kinda':2 'live':20 'money':40 'necessari':18 'outsid':31 'sentiment':8 'think':23 'usual':26"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4838860"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701233477 {#2069
    date: 2023-11-29 05:51:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700739603 {#2065
    date: 2023-11-23 12:40:03.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 154222
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
29 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
30 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
  +slug: "U-S-President-Biden-says-Gaza-and-the-West-Bank-should"
  +title: "U.S. President Biden says "Gaza and the West Bank should be reunited under single government" and "extremist violence against Palestinians in the West Bank must stop""
  +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5830159"
  +body: """
    Cross-posted from: [feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)\n
    \n
    Original link: [1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.c…](https://1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fopinions%2F2023%2F11%2F18%2Fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2F)
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 13
  +favouriteCount: 65
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700443132 {#3064
    date: 2023-11-20 02:18:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3028 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3071 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3073 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3075 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3077 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3079 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2131 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2132 …}
      +body: """
        > Netanyahu has gone on record saying he has helped prop Hamas up in order to sow division between Gaza and the West Bank.\n
        \n
        Do you have a source for this? I couldn’t find it, although this was pretty close: [timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-…](https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 5
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700425319 {#2241
        date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@0x815@feddit.de"
        "@lnxtx@feddit.nl"
        "@jargoggles@kbin.social"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2138 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2345 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2330 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2346 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2347 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2344 …}
      -id: 140791
      -bodyTs: "'/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':43 '/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':46 'although':36 'bank':23 'close':40 'couldn':32 'divis':17 'find':34 'gaza':19 'gone':3 'hama':11 'help':9 'netanyahu':1 'order':14 'pretti':39 'prop':10 'record':5 'say':6 'sourc':28 'sow':16 'timesofisrael.com':42 'timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':41 'west':22 'www.timesofisrael.com':45 'www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':44"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4733435"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700799869 {#2140
        date: 2023-11-24 05:24:29.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700425319 {#2130
        date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 140791
    }
  ]
  -id: 14449
  -titleTs: "'bank':9,24 'biden':3 'extremist':17 'gaza':5 'govern':15 'must':25 'palestinian':20 'presid':2 'reunit':12 'say':4 'singl':14 'stop':26 'u.s':1 'violenc':18 'west':8,23"
  -bodyTs: "'/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':7 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':12 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':15 '1ft.io':11,14 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':10 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':13 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700498755
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5830163"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700412355 {#3051
    date: 2023-11-19 17:45:55.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
31 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
  +slug: "U-S-President-Biden-says-Gaza-and-the-West-Bank-should"
  +title: "U.S. President Biden says "Gaza and the West Bank should be reunited under single government" and "extremist violence against Palestinians in the West Bank must stop""
  +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5830159"
  +body: """
    Cross-posted from: [feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)\n
    \n
    Original link: [1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.c…](https://1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fopinions%2F2023%2F11%2F18%2Fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2F)
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 13
  +favouriteCount: 65
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700443132 {#3064
    date: 2023-11-20 02:18:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3028 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3071 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3073 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3075 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3077 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3079 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2131 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2132 …}
      +body: """
        > Netanyahu has gone on record saying he has helped prop Hamas up in order to sow division between Gaza and the West Bank.\n
        \n
        Do you have a source for this? I couldn’t find it, although this was pretty close: [timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-…](https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 5
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700425319 {#2241
        date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@0x815@feddit.de"
        "@lnxtx@feddit.nl"
        "@jargoggles@kbin.social"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2138 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2345 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2330 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2346 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2347 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2344 …}
      -id: 140791
      -bodyTs: "'/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':43 '/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':46 'although':36 'bank':23 'close':40 'couldn':32 'divis':17 'find':34 'gaza':19 'gone':3 'hama':11 'help':9 'netanyahu':1 'order':14 'pretti':39 'prop':10 'record':5 'say':6 'sourc':28 'sow':16 'timesofisrael.com':42 'timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':41 'west':22 'www.timesofisrael.com':45 'www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':44"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4733435"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700799869 {#2140
        date: 2023-11-24 05:24:29.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700425319 {#2130
        date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 140791
    }
  ]
  -id: 14449
  -titleTs: "'bank':9,24 'biden':3 'extremist':17 'gaza':5 'govern':15 'must':25 'palestinian':20 'presid':2 'reunit':12 'say':4 'singl':14 'stop':26 'u.s':1 'violenc':18 'west':8,23"
  -bodyTs: "'/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':7 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':12 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':15 '1ft.io':11,14 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':10 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':13 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700498755
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5830163"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700412355 {#3051
    date: 2023-11-19 17:45:55.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
32 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
  +slug: "U-S-President-Biden-says-Gaza-and-the-West-Bank-should"
  +title: "U.S. President Biden says "Gaza and the West Bank should be reunited under single government" and "extremist violence against Palestinians in the West Bank must stop""
  +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5830159"
  +body: """
    Cross-posted from: [feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)\n
    \n
    Original link: [1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.c…](https://1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fopinions%2F2023%2F11%2F18%2Fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2F)
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 13
  +favouriteCount: 65
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700443132 {#3064
    date: 2023-11-20 02:18:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3028 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3071 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3073 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3075 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3077 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3079 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2131 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2132 …}
      +body: """
        > Netanyahu has gone on record saying he has helped prop Hamas up in order to sow division between Gaza and the West Bank.\n
        \n
        Do you have a source for this? I couldn’t find it, although this was pretty close: [timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-…](https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 5
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700425319 {#2241
        date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@0x815@feddit.de"
        "@lnxtx@feddit.nl"
        "@jargoggles@kbin.social"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2138 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2345 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2330 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2346 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2347 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2344 …}
      -id: 140791
      -bodyTs: "'/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':43 '/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':46 'although':36 'bank':23 'close':40 'couldn':32 'divis':17 'find':34 'gaza':19 'gone':3 'hama':11 'help':9 'netanyahu':1 'order':14 'pretti':39 'prop':10 'record':5 'say':6 'sourc':28 'sow':16 'timesofisrael.com':42 'timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':41 'west':22 'www.timesofisrael.com':45 'www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':44"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4733435"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700799869 {#2140
        date: 2023-11-24 05:24:29.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700425319 {#2130
        date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 140791
    }
  ]
  -id: 14449
  -titleTs: "'bank':9,24 'biden':3 'extremist':17 'gaza':5 'govern':15 'must':25 'palestinian':20 'presid':2 'reunit':12 'say':4 'singl':14 'stop':26 'u.s':1 'violenc':18 'west':8,23"
  -bodyTs: "'/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':7 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':12 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':15 '1ft.io':11,14 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':10 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':13 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700498755
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5830163"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700412355 {#3051
    date: 2023-11-19 17:45:55.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
33 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
34 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
    +slug: "U-S-President-Biden-says-Gaza-and-the-West-Bank-should"
    +title: "U.S. President Biden says "Gaza and the West Bank should be reunited under single government" and "extremist violence against Palestinians in the West Bank must stop""
    +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5830159"
    +body: """
      Cross-posted from: [feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)\n
      \n
      Original link: [1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.c…](https://1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fopinions%2F2023%2F11%2F18%2Fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2F)
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 13
    +favouriteCount: 65
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700443132 {#3064
      date: 2023-11-20 02:18:52.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3028 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3071 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3073 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3075 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3077 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3079 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133}
    ]
    -id: 14449
    -titleTs: "'bank':9,24 'biden':3 'extremist':17 'gaza':5 'govern':15 'must':25 'palestinian':20 'presid':2 'reunit':12 'say':4 'singl':14 'stop':26 'u.s':1 'violenc':18 'west':8,23"
    -bodyTs: "'/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':7 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':12 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':15 '1ft.io':11,14 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':10 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':13 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700498755
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5830163"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700412355 {#3051
      date: 2023-11-19 17:45:55.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2131 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2132 …}
  +body: """
    > Netanyahu has gone on record saying he has helped prop Hamas up in order to sow division between Gaza and the West Bank.\n
    \n
    Do you have a source for this? I couldn’t find it, although this was pretty close: [timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-…](https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 5
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700425319 {#2241
    date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@0x815@feddit.de"
    "@lnxtx@feddit.nl"
    "@jargoggles@kbin.social"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2138 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2345 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2330 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2346 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2347 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2344 …}
  -id: 140791
  -bodyTs: "'/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':43 '/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':46 'although':36 'bank':23 'close':40 'couldn':32 'divis':17 'find':34 'gaza':19 'gone':3 'hama':11 'help':9 'netanyahu':1 'order':14 'pretti':39 'prop':10 'record':5 'say':6 'sourc':28 'sow':16 'timesofisrael.com':42 'timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':41 'west':22 'www.timesofisrael.com':45 'www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':44"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4733435"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700799869 {#2140
    date: 2023-11-24 05:24:29.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700425319 {#2130
    date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 140791
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
35 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
    +slug: "U-S-President-Biden-says-Gaza-and-the-West-Bank-should"
    +title: "U.S. President Biden says "Gaza and the West Bank should be reunited under single government" and "extremist violence against Palestinians in the West Bank must stop""
    +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5830159"
    +body: """
      Cross-posted from: [feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)\n
      \n
      Original link: [1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.c…](https://1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fopinions%2F2023%2F11%2F18%2Fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2F)
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 13
    +favouriteCount: 65
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700443132 {#3064
      date: 2023-11-20 02:18:52.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3028 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3071 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3073 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3075 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3077 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3079 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133}
    ]
    -id: 14449
    -titleTs: "'bank':9,24 'biden':3 'extremist':17 'gaza':5 'govern':15 'must':25 'palestinian':20 'presid':2 'reunit':12 'say':4 'singl':14 'stop':26 'u.s':1 'violenc':18 'west':8,23"
    -bodyTs: "'/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':7 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':12 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':15 '1ft.io':11,14 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':10 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':13 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700498755
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5830163"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700412355 {#3051
      date: 2023-11-19 17:45:55.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2131 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2132 …}
  +body: """
    > Netanyahu has gone on record saying he has helped prop Hamas up in order to sow division between Gaza and the West Bank.\n
    \n
    Do you have a source for this? I couldn’t find it, although this was pretty close: [timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-…](https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 5
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700425319 {#2241
    date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@0x815@feddit.de"
    "@lnxtx@feddit.nl"
    "@jargoggles@kbin.social"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2138 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2345 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2330 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2346 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2347 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2344 …}
  -id: 140791
  -bodyTs: "'/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':43 '/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':46 'although':36 'bank':23 'close':40 'couldn':32 'divis':17 'find':34 'gaza':19 'gone':3 'hama':11 'help':9 'netanyahu':1 'order':14 'pretti':39 'prop':10 'record':5 'say':6 'sourc':28 'sow':16 'timesofisrael.com':42 'timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':41 'west':22 'www.timesofisrael.com':45 'www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':44"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4733435"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700799869 {#2140
    date: 2023-11-24 05:24:29.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700425319 {#2130
    date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 140791
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
36 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2129
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
    +slug: "U-S-President-Biden-says-Gaza-and-the-West-Bank-should"
    +title: "U.S. President Biden says "Gaza and the West Bank should be reunited under single government" and "extremist violence against Palestinians in the West Bank must stop""
    +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5830159"
    +body: """
      Cross-posted from: [feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)\n
      \n
      Original link: [1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.c…](https://1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fopinions%2F2023%2F11%2F18%2Fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2F)
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 13
    +favouriteCount: 65
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700443132 {#3064
      date: 2023-11-20 02:18:52.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3028 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3071 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3073 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3075 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3077 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3079 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2133}
    ]
    -id: 14449
    -titleTs: "'bank':9,24 'biden':3 'extremist':17 'gaza':5 'govern':15 'must':25 'palestinian':20 'presid':2 'reunit':12 'say':4 'singl':14 'stop':26 'u.s':1 'violenc':18 'west':8,23"
    -bodyTs: "'/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':7 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':12 '/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':15 '1ft.io':11,14 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.c':10 '1ft.io/proxy?q=https%3a%2f%2fwww.washingtonpost.com%2fopinions%2f2023%2f11%2f18%2fjoe-biden-gaza-hamas-putin%2f)':13 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5830159](https://feddit.de/post/5830159)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700498755
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5830163"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700412355 {#3051
      date: 2023-11-19 17:45:55.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2131 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2132 …}
  +body: """
    > Netanyahu has gone on record saying he has helped prop Hamas up in order to sow division between Gaza and the West Bank.\n
    \n
    Do you have a source for this? I couldn’t find it, although this was pretty close: [timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-…](https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 5
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700425319 {#2241
    date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@0x815@feddit.de"
    "@lnxtx@feddit.nl"
    "@jargoggles@kbin.social"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2138 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2345 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2330 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2346 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2347 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2344 …}
  -id: 140791
  -bodyTs: "'/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':43 '/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':46 'although':36 'bank':23 'close':40 'couldn':32 'divis':17 'find':34 'gaza':19 'gone':3 'hama':11 'help':9 'netanyahu':1 'order':14 'pretti':39 'prop':10 'record':5 'say':6 'sourc':28 'sow':16 'timesofisrael.com':42 'timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-':41 'west':22 'www.timesofisrael.com':45 'www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/)':44"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4733435"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700799869 {#2140
    date: 2023-11-24 05:24:29.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700425319 {#2130
    date: 2023-11-19 21:21:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 140791
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
37 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
38 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3048 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3086 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "Coins"
  +title: "Coins"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a588739e-ac18-40d4-abc5-09b35985cd11.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 63
  +favouriteCount: 346
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#3081
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3088 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3090 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3092 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3094 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3096 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3098 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "This comic brings me hope. That some day, if I work really hard, I might be a web comic artist as well."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#2042
        date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@GrimSheeper@lemmy.world"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2314 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2328 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2191 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2327 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2333 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2324 …}
      -id: 141020
      -bodyTs: "'artist':20 'bring':3 'comic':2,19 'day':8 'hard':13 'hope':5 'might':15 'realli':12 'web':18 'well':22 'work':11"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4734963"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700808528 {#2141
        date: 2023-11-24 07:48:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700429680 {#2060
        date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 141020
    }
  ]
  -id: 13781
  -titleTs: "'coin':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700286795
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8367402"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700200395 {#3070
    date: 2023-11-17 06:53:15.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
39 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3048 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3086 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "Coins"
  +title: "Coins"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a588739e-ac18-40d4-abc5-09b35985cd11.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 63
  +favouriteCount: 346
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#3081
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3088 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3090 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3092 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3094 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3096 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3098 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "This comic brings me hope. That some day, if I work really hard, I might be a web comic artist as well."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#2042
        date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@GrimSheeper@lemmy.world"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2314 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2328 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2191 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2327 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2333 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2324 …}
      -id: 141020
      -bodyTs: "'artist':20 'bring':3 'comic':2,19 'day':8 'hard':13 'hope':5 'might':15 'realli':12 'web':18 'well':22 'work':11"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4734963"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700808528 {#2141
        date: 2023-11-24 07:48:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700429680 {#2060
        date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 141020
    }
  ]
  -id: 13781
  -titleTs: "'coin':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700286795
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8367402"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700200395 {#3070
    date: 2023-11-17 06:53:15.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
40 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3048 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3086 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "Coins"
  +title: "Coins"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a588739e-ac18-40d4-abc5-09b35985cd11.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 63
  +favouriteCount: 346
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#3081
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3088 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3090 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3092 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3094 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3096 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3098 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "This comic brings me hope. That some day, if I work really hard, I might be a web comic artist as well."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#2042
        date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@GrimSheeper@lemmy.world"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2314 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2328 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2191 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2327 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2333 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2324 …}
      -id: 141020
      -bodyTs: "'artist':20 'bring':3 'comic':2,19 'day':8 'hard':13 'hope':5 'might':15 'realli':12 'web':18 'well':22 'work':11"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4734963"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700808528 {#2141
        date: 2023-11-24 07:48:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700429680 {#2060
        date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 141020
    }
  ]
  -id: 13781
  -titleTs: "'coin':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700286795
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8367402"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700200395 {#3070
    date: 2023-11-17 06:53:15.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
41 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
42 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3048 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3086 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "Coins"
    +title: "Coins"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a588739e-ac18-40d4-abc5-09b35985cd11.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 63
    +favouriteCount: 346
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#3081
      date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3088 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3090 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3092 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3094 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3096 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3098 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164}
    ]
    -id: 13781
    -titleTs: "'coin':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700286795
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8367402"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700200395 {#3070
      date: 2023-11-17 06:53:15.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "This comic brings me hope. That some day, if I work really hard, I might be a web comic artist as well."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#2042
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@GrimSheeper@lemmy.world"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2314 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2328 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2191 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2327 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2333 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2324 …}
  -id: 141020
  -bodyTs: "'artist':20 'bring':3 'comic':2,19 'day':8 'hard':13 'hope':5 'might':15 'realli':12 'web':18 'well':22 'work':11"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4734963"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700808528 {#2141
    date: 2023-11-24 07:48:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700429680 {#2060
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 141020
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
43 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3048 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3086 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "Coins"
    +title: "Coins"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a588739e-ac18-40d4-abc5-09b35985cd11.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 63
    +favouriteCount: 346
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#3081
      date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3088 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3090 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3092 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3094 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3096 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3098 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164}
    ]
    -id: 13781
    -titleTs: "'coin':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700286795
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8367402"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700200395 {#3070
      date: 2023-11-17 06:53:15.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "This comic brings me hope. That some day, if I work really hard, I might be a web comic artist as well."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#2042
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@GrimSheeper@lemmy.world"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2314 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2328 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2191 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2327 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2333 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2324 …}
  -id: 141020
  -bodyTs: "'artist':20 'bring':3 'comic':2,19 'day':8 'hard':13 'hope':5 'might':15 'realli':12 'web':18 'well':22 'work':11"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4734963"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700808528 {#2141
    date: 2023-11-24 07:48:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700429680 {#2060
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 141020
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
44 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2331
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3048 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3086 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "Coins"
    +title: "Coins"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a588739e-ac18-40d4-abc5-09b35985cd11.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 63
    +favouriteCount: 346
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#3081
      date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3088 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3090 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3092 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3094 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3096 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3098 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2164}
    ]
    -id: 13781
    -titleTs: "'coin':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700286795
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8367402"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700200395 {#3070
      date: 2023-11-17 06:53:15.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "This comic brings me hope. That some day, if I work really hard, I might be a web comic artist as well."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700429680 {#2042
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@GrimSheeper@lemmy.world"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2314 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2328 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2191 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2327 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2333 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2324 …}
  -id: 141020
  -bodyTs: "'artist':20 'bring':3 'comic':2,19 'day':8 'hard':13 'hope':5 'might':15 'realli':12 'web':18 'well':22 'work':11"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4734963"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700808528 {#2141
    date: 2023-11-24 07:48:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700429680 {#2060
    date: 2023-11-19 22:34:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 141020
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
45 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
46 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3030 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
  +slug: "WhatsApp-s-AI-shows-gun-wielding-children-when-prompted-with-Palestine"
  +title: "WhatsApp’s AI shows gun-wielding children when prompted with ‘Palestine’"
  +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5357539"
  +body: """
    Cross-posted from : [feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)\n
    \n
    Original link: [theguardian.com/…/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun…](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 33
  +favouriteCount: 120
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699354500 {#3025
    date: 2023-11-07 11:55:00.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3033 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3035 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3037 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3039 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3041 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3043 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2462 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2458 …}
      +body: """
        Why would you demand a negative thing for another group to counter a negative thing for one group? That makes no sense.\n
        \n
        But also, “American children” has plenty of cultural material to build an image from. Probably some of it is obese and filled with junk food, but a good portion is most probably something else. In contrast, the only public photo material of palestinian children is either from adults carrying them away from some atrocity or adults giving them assault rifles and parading them for the cameras. In short, they seem to only exist as propaganda material.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 8
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699276968 {#1722
        date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@0x815@feddit.de"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@taanegl@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2456 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2453 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2457 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2455 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1410 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2448 …}
      -id: 95024
      -bodyTs: "'adult':70,78 'also':24 'american':25 'anoth':9 'assault':81 'atroc':76 'away':73 'build':33 'camera':88 'carri':71 'children':26,66 'contrast':58 'counter':12 'cultur':30 'demand':4 'either':68 'els':56 'exist':95 'fill':44 'food':47 'give':79 'good':50 'group':10,18 'imag':35 'junk':46 'make':20 'materi':31,63,98 'negat':6,14 'obes':42 'one':17 'palestinian':65 'parad':84 'photo':62 'plenti':28 'portion':51 'probabl':37,54 'propaganda':97 'public':61 'rifl':82 'seem':92 'sens':22 'short':90 'someth':55 'thing':7,15 'would':2"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355147"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298313 {#1736
        date: 2023-11-06 20:18:33.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699276968 {#1726
        date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 95024
    }
  ]
  -id: 10463
  -titleTs: "'ai':3 'children':8 'gun':6 'gun-wield':5 'palestin':12 'prompt':10 'show':4 'whatsapp':1 'wield':7"
  -bodyTs: "'/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':7 '/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':14 '/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun':11 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3 'theguardian.com':10 'www.theguardian.com':13 'www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':12"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699358075
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5357550"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699271675 {#3010
    date: 2023-11-06 12:54:35.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
47 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3030 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
  +slug: "WhatsApp-s-AI-shows-gun-wielding-children-when-prompted-with-Palestine"
  +title: "WhatsApp’s AI shows gun-wielding children when prompted with ‘Palestine’"
  +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5357539"
  +body: """
    Cross-posted from : [feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)\n
    \n
    Original link: [theguardian.com/…/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun…](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 33
  +favouriteCount: 120
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699354500 {#3025
    date: 2023-11-07 11:55:00.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3033 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3035 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3037 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3039 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3041 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3043 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2462 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2458 …}
      +body: """
        Why would you demand a negative thing for another group to counter a negative thing for one group? That makes no sense.\n
        \n
        But also, “American children” has plenty of cultural material to build an image from. Probably some of it is obese and filled with junk food, but a good portion is most probably something else. In contrast, the only public photo material of palestinian children is either from adults carrying them away from some atrocity or adults giving them assault rifles and parading them for the cameras. In short, they seem to only exist as propaganda material.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 8
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699276968 {#1722
        date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@0x815@feddit.de"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@taanegl@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2456 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2453 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2457 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2455 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1410 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2448 …}
      -id: 95024
      -bodyTs: "'adult':70,78 'also':24 'american':25 'anoth':9 'assault':81 'atroc':76 'away':73 'build':33 'camera':88 'carri':71 'children':26,66 'contrast':58 'counter':12 'cultur':30 'demand':4 'either':68 'els':56 'exist':95 'fill':44 'food':47 'give':79 'good':50 'group':10,18 'imag':35 'junk':46 'make':20 'materi':31,63,98 'negat':6,14 'obes':42 'one':17 'palestinian':65 'parad':84 'photo':62 'plenti':28 'portion':51 'probabl':37,54 'propaganda':97 'public':61 'rifl':82 'seem':92 'sens':22 'short':90 'someth':55 'thing':7,15 'would':2"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355147"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298313 {#1736
        date: 2023-11-06 20:18:33.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699276968 {#1726
        date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 95024
    }
  ]
  -id: 10463
  -titleTs: "'ai':3 'children':8 'gun':6 'gun-wield':5 'palestin':12 'prompt':10 'show':4 'whatsapp':1 'wield':7"
  -bodyTs: "'/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':7 '/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':14 '/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun':11 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3 'theguardian.com':10 'www.theguardian.com':13 'www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':12"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699358075
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5357550"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699271675 {#3010
    date: 2023-11-06 12:54:35.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
48 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3030 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
  +slug: "WhatsApp-s-AI-shows-gun-wielding-children-when-prompted-with-Palestine"
  +title: "WhatsApp’s AI shows gun-wielding children when prompted with ‘Palestine’"
  +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5357539"
  +body: """
    Cross-posted from : [feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)\n
    \n
    Original link: [theguardian.com/…/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun…](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 33
  +favouriteCount: 120
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699354500 {#3025
    date: 2023-11-07 11:55:00.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3033 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3035 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3037 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3039 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3041 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3043 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2462 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2458 …}
      +body: """
        Why would you demand a negative thing for another group to counter a negative thing for one group? That makes no sense.\n
        \n
        But also, “American children” has plenty of cultural material to build an image from. Probably some of it is obese and filled with junk food, but a good portion is most probably something else. In contrast, the only public photo material of palestinian children is either from adults carrying them away from some atrocity or adults giving them assault rifles and parading them for the cameras. In short, they seem to only exist as propaganda material.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 8
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699276968 {#1722
        date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@0x815@feddit.de"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@taanegl@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2456 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2453 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2457 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2455 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1410 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2448 …}
      -id: 95024
      -bodyTs: "'adult':70,78 'also':24 'american':25 'anoth':9 'assault':81 'atroc':76 'away':73 'build':33 'camera':88 'carri':71 'children':26,66 'contrast':58 'counter':12 'cultur':30 'demand':4 'either':68 'els':56 'exist':95 'fill':44 'food':47 'give':79 'good':50 'group':10,18 'imag':35 'junk':46 'make':20 'materi':31,63,98 'negat':6,14 'obes':42 'one':17 'palestinian':65 'parad':84 'photo':62 'plenti':28 'portion':51 'probabl':37,54 'propaganda':97 'public':61 'rifl':82 'seem':92 'sens':22 'short':90 'someth':55 'thing':7,15 'would':2"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355147"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298313 {#1736
        date: 2023-11-06 20:18:33.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699276968 {#1726
        date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 95024
    }
  ]
  -id: 10463
  -titleTs: "'ai':3 'children':8 'gun':6 'gun-wield':5 'palestin':12 'prompt':10 'show':4 'whatsapp':1 'wield':7"
  -bodyTs: "'/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':7 '/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':14 '/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun':11 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3 'theguardian.com':10 'www.theguardian.com':13 'www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':12"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699358075
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5357550"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699271675 {#3010
    date: 2023-11-06 12:54:35.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
49 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
50 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3030 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
    +slug: "WhatsApp-s-AI-shows-gun-wielding-children-when-prompted-with-Palestine"
    +title: "WhatsApp’s AI shows gun-wielding children when prompted with ‘Palestine’"
    +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5357539"
    +body: """
      Cross-posted from : [feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)\n
      \n
      Original link: [theguardian.com/…/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun…](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 33
    +favouriteCount: 120
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1699354500 {#3025
      date: 2023-11-07 11:55:00.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3033 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3035 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3037 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3039 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3041 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3043 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739}
    ]
    -id: 10463
    -titleTs: "'ai':3 'children':8 'gun':6 'gun-wield':5 'palestin':12 'prompt':10 'show':4 'whatsapp':1 'wield':7"
    -bodyTs: "'/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':7 '/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':14 '/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun':11 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3 'theguardian.com':10 'www.theguardian.com':13 'www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':12"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699358075
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5357550"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699271675 {#3010
      date: 2023-11-06 12:54:35.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2462 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2458 …}
  +body: """
    Why would you demand a negative thing for another group to counter a negative thing for one group? That makes no sense.\n
    \n
    But also, “American children” has plenty of cultural material to build an image from. Probably some of it is obese and filled with junk food, but a good portion is most probably something else. In contrast, the only public photo material of palestinian children is either from adults carrying them away from some atrocity or adults giving them assault rifles and parading them for the cameras. In short, they seem to only exist as propaganda material.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 8
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699276968 {#1722
    date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@0x815@feddit.de"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@taanegl@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2456 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2453 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2457 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2455 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1410 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2448 …}
  -id: 95024
  -bodyTs: "'adult':70,78 'also':24 'american':25 'anoth':9 'assault':81 'atroc':76 'away':73 'build':33 'camera':88 'carri':71 'children':26,66 'contrast':58 'counter':12 'cultur':30 'demand':4 'either':68 'els':56 'exist':95 'fill':44 'food':47 'give':79 'good':50 'group':10,18 'imag':35 'junk':46 'make':20 'materi':31,63,98 'negat':6,14 'obes':42 'one':17 'palestinian':65 'parad':84 'photo':62 'plenti':28 'portion':51 'probabl':37,54 'propaganda':97 'public':61 'rifl':82 'seem':92 'sens':22 'short':90 'someth':55 'thing':7,15 'would':2"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355147"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298313 {#1736
    date: 2023-11-06 20:18:33.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699276968 {#1726
    date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 95024
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
51 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3030 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
    +slug: "WhatsApp-s-AI-shows-gun-wielding-children-when-prompted-with-Palestine"
    +title: "WhatsApp’s AI shows gun-wielding children when prompted with ‘Palestine’"
    +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5357539"
    +body: """
      Cross-posted from : [feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)\n
      \n
      Original link: [theguardian.com/…/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun…](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 33
    +favouriteCount: 120
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1699354500 {#3025
      date: 2023-11-07 11:55:00.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3033 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3035 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3037 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3039 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3041 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3043 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739}
    ]
    -id: 10463
    -titleTs: "'ai':3 'children':8 'gun':6 'gun-wield':5 'palestin':12 'prompt':10 'show':4 'whatsapp':1 'wield':7"
    -bodyTs: "'/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':7 '/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':14 '/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun':11 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3 'theguardian.com':10 'www.theguardian.com':13 'www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':12"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699358075
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5357550"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699271675 {#3010
      date: 2023-11-06 12:54:35.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2462 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2458 …}
  +body: """
    Why would you demand a negative thing for another group to counter a negative thing for one group? That makes no sense.\n
    \n
    But also, “American children” has plenty of cultural material to build an image from. Probably some of it is obese and filled with junk food, but a good portion is most probably something else. In contrast, the only public photo material of palestinian children is either from adults carrying them away from some atrocity or adults giving them assault rifles and parading them for the cameras. In short, they seem to only exist as propaganda material.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 8
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699276968 {#1722
    date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@0x815@feddit.de"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@taanegl@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2456 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2453 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2457 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2455 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1410 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2448 …}
  -id: 95024
  -bodyTs: "'adult':70,78 'also':24 'american':25 'anoth':9 'assault':81 'atroc':76 'away':73 'build':33 'camera':88 'carri':71 'children':26,66 'contrast':58 'counter':12 'cultur':30 'demand':4 'either':68 'els':56 'exist':95 'fill':44 'food':47 'give':79 'good':50 'group':10,18 'imag':35 'junk':46 'make':20 'materi':31,63,98 'negat':6,14 'obes':42 'one':17 'palestinian':65 'parad':84 'photo':62 'plenti':28 'portion':51 'probabl':37,54 'propaganda':97 'public':61 'rifl':82 'seem':92 'sens':22 'short':90 'someth':55 'thing':7,15 'would':2"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355147"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298313 {#1736
    date: 2023-11-06 20:18:33.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699276968 {#1726
    date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 95024
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
52 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1708
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2988 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3030 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3032 …}
    +slug: "WhatsApp-s-AI-shows-gun-wielding-children-when-prompted-with-Palestine"
    +title: "WhatsApp’s AI shows gun-wielding children when prompted with ‘Palestine’"
    +url: "https://feddit.de/post/5357539"
    +body: """
      Cross-posted from : [feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)\n
      \n
      Original link: [theguardian.com/…/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun…](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 33
    +favouriteCount: 120
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1699354500 {#3025
      date: 2023-11-07 11:55:00.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3033 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3035 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3037 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3039 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3041 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3043 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#1739}
    ]
    -id: 10463
    -titleTs: "'ai':3 'children':8 'gun':6 'gun-wield':5 'palestin':12 'prompt':10 'show':4 'whatsapp':1 'wield':7"
    -bodyTs: "'/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':7 '/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':14 '/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun':11 'cross':2 'cross-post':1 'feddit.de':6 'feddit.de/post/5357539](https://feddit.de/post/5357539)':5 'link':9 'origin':8 'post':3 'theguardian.com':10 'www.theguardian.com':13 'www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/02/whatsapps-ai-palestine-kids-gun-gaza-bias-israel)':12"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699358075
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://feddit.de/post/5357550"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699271675 {#3010
      date: 2023-11-06 12:54:35.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2462 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2458 …}
  +body: """
    Why would you demand a negative thing for another group to counter a negative thing for one group? That makes no sense.\n
    \n
    But also, “American children” has plenty of cultural material to build an image from. Probably some of it is obese and filled with junk food, but a good portion is most probably something else. In contrast, the only public photo material of palestinian children is either from adults carrying them away from some atrocity or adults giving them assault rifles and parading them for the cameras. In short, they seem to only exist as propaganda material.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 8
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699276968 {#1722
    date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@0x815@feddit.de"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@taanegl@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2456 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2453 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2457 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2455 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1410 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2448 …}
  -id: 95024
  -bodyTs: "'adult':70,78 'also':24 'american':25 'anoth':9 'assault':81 'atroc':76 'away':73 'build':33 'camera':88 'carri':71 'children':26,66 'contrast':58 'counter':12 'cultur':30 'demand':4 'either':68 'els':56 'exist':95 'fill':44 'food':47 'give':79 'good':50 'group':10,18 'imag':35 'junk':46 'make':20 'materi':31,63,98 'negat':6,14 'obes':42 'one':17 'palestinian':65 'parad':84 'photo':62 'plenti':28 'portion':51 'probabl':37,54 'propaganda':97 'public':61 'rifl':82 'seem':92 'sens':22 'short':90 'someth':55 'thing':7,15 'would':2"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355147"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298313 {#1736
    date: 2023-11-06 20:18:33.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699276968 {#1726
    date: 2023-11-06 14:22:48.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 95024
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
53 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
54 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3007 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3050 …}
  +slug: "Thanksgiving-by-TheOtherEnd"
  +title: ""Thanksgiving" by TheOtherEnd"
  +url: "https://i0.wp.com/www.kohney.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Thanksgiving-2023-SITE-scaled.jpg"
  +body: "- Source: [Website](https://www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/) - [RSS](https://www.kohney.com/feed/)"
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 57
  +favouriteCount: 520
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701085867 {#3045
    date: 2023-11-27 12:51:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3052 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3054 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3056 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3058 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3060 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3062 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "This is the best comic I’ve seen this year."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701083899 {#2214
        date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sag@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2231 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2229 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2252 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2189 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2311 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2293 …}
      -id: 169660
      -bodyTs: "'best':4 'comic':5 'seen':8 've':7 'year':10"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4938262"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701083899 {#2213
        date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 169660
    }
  ]
  -id: 16697
  -titleTs: "'thanksgiv':1 'theotherend':3"
  -bodyTs: "'/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':5 '/feed/)':9 'rss':6 'sourc':1 'websit':2 'www.kohney.com':4,8 'www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':3 'www.kohney.com/feed/)':7"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701012098
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15986330"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700925698 {#3031
    date: 2023-11-25 16:21:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
55 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3007 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3050 …}
  +slug: "Thanksgiving-by-TheOtherEnd"
  +title: ""Thanksgiving" by TheOtherEnd"
  +url: "https://i0.wp.com/www.kohney.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Thanksgiving-2023-SITE-scaled.jpg"
  +body: "- Source: [Website](https://www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/) - [RSS](https://www.kohney.com/feed/)"
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 57
  +favouriteCount: 520
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701085867 {#3045
    date: 2023-11-27 12:51:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3052 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3054 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3056 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3058 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3060 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3062 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "This is the best comic I’ve seen this year."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701083899 {#2214
        date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sag@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2231 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2229 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2252 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2189 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2311 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2293 …}
      -id: 169660
      -bodyTs: "'best':4 'comic':5 'seen':8 've':7 'year':10"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4938262"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701083899 {#2213
        date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 169660
    }
  ]
  -id: 16697
  -titleTs: "'thanksgiv':1 'theotherend':3"
  -bodyTs: "'/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':5 '/feed/)':9 'rss':6 'sourc':1 'websit':2 'www.kohney.com':4,8 'www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':3 'www.kohney.com/feed/)':7"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701012098
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15986330"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700925698 {#3031
    date: 2023-11-25 16:21:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
56 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3007 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3050 …}
  +slug: "Thanksgiving-by-TheOtherEnd"
  +title: ""Thanksgiving" by TheOtherEnd"
  +url: "https://i0.wp.com/www.kohney.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Thanksgiving-2023-SITE-scaled.jpg"
  +body: "- Source: [Website](https://www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/) - [RSS](https://www.kohney.com/feed/)"
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 57
  +favouriteCount: 520
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701085867 {#3045
    date: 2023-11-27 12:51:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3052 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3054 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3056 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3058 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3060 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3062 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: "This is the best comic I’ve seen this year."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 0
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701083899 {#2214
        date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sag@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2231 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2229 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2252 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2189 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2311 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2293 …}
      -id: 169660
      -bodyTs: "'best':4 'comic':5 'seen':8 've':7 'year':10"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4938262"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701083899 {#2213
        date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 169660
    }
  ]
  -id: 16697
  -titleTs: "'thanksgiv':1 'theotherend':3"
  -bodyTs: "'/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':5 '/feed/)':9 'rss':6 'sourc':1 'websit':2 'www.kohney.com':4,8 'www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':3 'www.kohney.com/feed/)':7"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701012098
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15986330"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700925698 {#3031
    date: 2023-11-25 16:21:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
57 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
58 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3007 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3050 …}
    +slug: "Thanksgiving-by-TheOtherEnd"
    +title: ""Thanksgiving" by TheOtherEnd"
    +url: "https://i0.wp.com/www.kohney.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Thanksgiving-2023-SITE-scaled.jpg"
    +body: "- Source: [Website](https://www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/) - [RSS](https://www.kohney.com/feed/)"
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 57
    +favouriteCount: 520
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701085867 {#3045
      date: 2023-11-27 12:51:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3052 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3054 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3056 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3058 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3060 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3062 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225}
    ]
    -id: 16697
    -titleTs: "'thanksgiv':1 'theotherend':3"
    -bodyTs: "'/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':5 '/feed/)':9 'rss':6 'sourc':1 'websit':2 'www.kohney.com':4,8 'www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':3 'www.kohney.com/feed/)':7"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701012098
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15986330"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700925698 {#3031
      date: 2023-11-25 16:21:38.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "This is the best comic I’ve seen this year."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701083899 {#2214
    date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sag@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2231 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2229 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2252 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2189 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2311 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2293 …}
  -id: 169660
  -bodyTs: "'best':4 'comic':5 'seen':8 've':7 'year':10"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4938262"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701083899 {#2213
    date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 169660
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
59 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3007 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3050 …}
    +slug: "Thanksgiving-by-TheOtherEnd"
    +title: ""Thanksgiving" by TheOtherEnd"
    +url: "https://i0.wp.com/www.kohney.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Thanksgiving-2023-SITE-scaled.jpg"
    +body: "- Source: [Website](https://www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/) - [RSS](https://www.kohney.com/feed/)"
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 57
    +favouriteCount: 520
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701085867 {#3045
      date: 2023-11-27 12:51:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3052 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3054 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3056 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3058 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3060 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3062 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225}
    ]
    -id: 16697
    -titleTs: "'thanksgiv':1 'theotherend':3"
    -bodyTs: "'/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':5 '/feed/)':9 'rss':6 'sourc':1 'websit':2 'www.kohney.com':4,8 'www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':3 'www.kohney.com/feed/)':7"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701012098
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15986330"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700925698 {#3031
      date: 2023-11-25 16:21:38.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "This is the best comic I’ve seen this year."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701083899 {#2214
    date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sag@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2231 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2229 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2252 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2189 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2311 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2293 …}
  -id: 169660
  -bodyTs: "'best':4 'comic':5 'seen':8 've':7 'year':10"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4938262"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701083899 {#2213
    date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 169660
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
60 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2230
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3007 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3050 …}
    +slug: "Thanksgiving-by-TheOtherEnd"
    +title: ""Thanksgiving" by TheOtherEnd"
    +url: "https://i0.wp.com/www.kohney.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Thanksgiving-2023-SITE-scaled.jpg"
    +body: "- Source: [Website](https://www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/) - [RSS](https://www.kohney.com/feed/)"
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 57
    +favouriteCount: 520
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701085867 {#3045
      date: 2023-11-27 12:51:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3052 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3054 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3056 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3058 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3060 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3062 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2225}
    ]
    -id: 16697
    -titleTs: "'thanksgiv':1 'theotherend':3"
    -bodyTs: "'/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':5 '/feed/)':9 'rss':6 'sourc':1 'websit':2 'www.kohney.com':4,8 'www.kohney.com/comic/thanksgiving-2023/)':3 'www.kohney.com/feed/)':7"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701012098
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15986330"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700925698 {#3031
      date: 2023-11-25 16:21:38.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: "This is the best comic I’ve seen this year."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 0
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701083899 {#2214
    date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sag@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2231 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2229 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2252 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2189 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2311 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2293 …}
  -id: 169660
  -bodyTs: "'best':4 'comic':5 'seen':8 've':7 'year':10"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4938262"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701083899 {#2213
    date: 2023-11-27 12:18:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 169660
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
61 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
62 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2949 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2990 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "So-timeshift-or-NixOS"
  +title: "So, timeshift or NixOS?"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/89ee21ea-7352-4859-94e0-85d5240fa69f.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 102
  +favouriteCount: 1025
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701537399 {#2985
    date: 2023-12-02 18:16:39.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2992 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2994 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2996 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2998 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3000 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3002 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
      +body: "Because I made it unbootable by doing something dumb or one of its tools was horribly broken and made my system unbootable? :) This was years ago, though, it’s probably more stable these days."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699775512 {#2020
        date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Geert@lemmy.world"
        "@barsoap@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2144 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2061 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2084 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2076 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2083 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2085 …}
      -id: 114657
      -bodyTs: "'ago':26 'broken':17 'day':34 'dumb':9 'horribl':16 'made':3,19 'one':11 'probabl':30 'someth':8 'stabl':32 'system':21 'though':27 'tool':14 'unboot':5,22 'year':25"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4521240"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699905421 {#2013
        date: 2023-11-13 20:57:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699775512 {#2027
        date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 114657
    }
  ]
  -id: 11981
  -titleTs: "'nixo':4 'timeshift':2"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699793101
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8108587"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699706701 {#2971
    date: 2023-11-11 13:45:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
63 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2949 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2990 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "So-timeshift-or-NixOS"
  +title: "So, timeshift or NixOS?"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/89ee21ea-7352-4859-94e0-85d5240fa69f.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 102
  +favouriteCount: 1025
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701537399 {#2985
    date: 2023-12-02 18:16:39.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2992 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2994 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2996 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2998 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3000 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3002 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
      +body: "Because I made it unbootable by doing something dumb or one of its tools was horribly broken and made my system unbootable? :) This was years ago, though, it’s probably more stable these days."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699775512 {#2020
        date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Geert@lemmy.world"
        "@barsoap@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2144 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2061 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2084 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2076 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2083 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2085 …}
      -id: 114657
      -bodyTs: "'ago':26 'broken':17 'day':34 'dumb':9 'horribl':16 'made':3,19 'one':11 'probabl':30 'someth':8 'stabl':32 'system':21 'though':27 'tool':14 'unboot':5,22 'year':25"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4521240"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699905421 {#2013
        date: 2023-11-13 20:57:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699775512 {#2027
        date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 114657
    }
  ]
  -id: 11981
  -titleTs: "'nixo':4 'timeshift':2"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699793101
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8108587"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699706701 {#2971
    date: 2023-11-11 13:45:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
64 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2949 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2990 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "So-timeshift-or-NixOS"
  +title: "So, timeshift or NixOS?"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/89ee21ea-7352-4859-94e0-85d5240fa69f.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 102
  +favouriteCount: 1025
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701537399 {#2985
    date: 2023-12-02 18:16:39.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2992 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2994 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2996 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2998 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3000 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3002 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
      +body: "Because I made it unbootable by doing something dumb or one of its tools was horribly broken and made my system unbootable? :) This was years ago, though, it’s probably more stable these days."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699775512 {#2020
        date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Geert@lemmy.world"
        "@barsoap@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2144 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2061 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2084 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2076 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2083 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2085 …}
      -id: 114657
      -bodyTs: "'ago':26 'broken':17 'day':34 'dumb':9 'horribl':16 'made':3,19 'one':11 'probabl':30 'someth':8 'stabl':32 'system':21 'though':27 'tool':14 'unboot':5,22 'year':25"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4521240"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699905421 {#2013
        date: 2023-11-13 20:57:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699775512 {#2027
        date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 114657
    }
  ]
  -id: 11981
  -titleTs: "'nixo':4 'timeshift':2"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699793101
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8108587"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699706701 {#2971
    date: 2023-11-11 13:45:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
65 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
66 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2949 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2990 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "So-timeshift-or-NixOS"
    +title: "So, timeshift or NixOS?"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/89ee21ea-7352-4859-94e0-85d5240fa69f.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 102
    +favouriteCount: 1025
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701537399 {#2985
      date: 2023-12-02 18:16:39.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2992 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2994 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2996 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2998 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3000 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3002 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035}
    ]
    -id: 11981
    -titleTs: "'nixo':4 'timeshift':2"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699793101
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8108587"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699706701 {#2971
      date: 2023-11-11 13:45:01.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
  +body: "Because I made it unbootable by doing something dumb or one of its tools was horribly broken and made my system unbootable? :) This was years ago, though, it’s probably more stable these days."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699775512 {#2020
    date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Geert@lemmy.world"
    "@barsoap@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2144 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2061 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2084 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2076 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2083 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2085 …}
  -id: 114657
  -bodyTs: "'ago':26 'broken':17 'day':34 'dumb':9 'horribl':16 'made':3,19 'one':11 'probabl':30 'someth':8 'stabl':32 'system':21 'though':27 'tool':14 'unboot':5,22 'year':25"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4521240"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699905421 {#2013
    date: 2023-11-13 20:57:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699775512 {#2027
    date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 114657
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
67 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2949 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2990 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "So-timeshift-or-NixOS"
    +title: "So, timeshift or NixOS?"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/89ee21ea-7352-4859-94e0-85d5240fa69f.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 102
    +favouriteCount: 1025
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701537399 {#2985
      date: 2023-12-02 18:16:39.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2992 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2994 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2996 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2998 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3000 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3002 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035}
    ]
    -id: 11981
    -titleTs: "'nixo':4 'timeshift':2"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699793101
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8108587"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699706701 {#2971
      date: 2023-11-11 13:45:01.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
  +body: "Because I made it unbootable by doing something dumb or one of its tools was horribly broken and made my system unbootable? :) This was years ago, though, it’s probably more stable these days."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699775512 {#2020
    date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Geert@lemmy.world"
    "@barsoap@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2144 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2061 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2084 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2076 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2083 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2085 …}
  -id: 114657
  -bodyTs: "'ago':26 'broken':17 'day':34 'dumb':9 'horribl':16 'made':3,19 'one':11 'probabl':30 'someth':8 'stabl':32 'system':21 'though':27 'tool':14 'unboot':5,22 'year':25"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4521240"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699905421 {#2013
    date: 2023-11-13 20:57:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699775512 {#2027
    date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 114657
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
68 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2031
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2949 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2990 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "So-timeshift-or-NixOS"
    +title: "So, timeshift or NixOS?"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/89ee21ea-7352-4859-94e0-85d5240fa69f.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 102
    +favouriteCount: 1025
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701537399 {#2985
      date: 2023-12-02 18:16:39.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2992 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2994 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2996 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2998 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3000 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3002 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2035}
    ]
    -id: 11981
    -titleTs: "'nixo':4 'timeshift':2"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699793101
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8108587"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699706701 {#2971
      date: 2023-11-11 13:45:01.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2037 …}
  +body: "Because I made it unbootable by doing something dumb or one of its tools was horribly broken and made my system unbootable? :) This was years ago, though, it’s probably more stable these days."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699775512 {#2020
    date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Geert@lemmy.world"
    "@barsoap@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2144 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2061 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2084 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2076 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2083 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2085 …}
  -id: 114657
  -bodyTs: "'ago':26 'broken':17 'day':34 'dumb':9 'horribl':16 'made':3,19 'one':11 'probabl':30 'someth':8 'stabl':32 'system':21 'though':27 'tool':14 'unboot':5,22 'year':25"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4521240"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699905421 {#2013
    date: 2023-11-13 20:57:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699775512 {#2027
    date: 2023-11-12 08:51:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 114657
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
69 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
70 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3009 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3011 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3012 …}
  +slug: "WAIT-Extra-Fabulous"
  +title: "WAIT [Extra Fabulous]"
  +url: "https://startrek.website/pictrs/image/84795a9b-fb22-4009-b139-6d787fa3aec5.png"
  +body: """
    Extra Fabulous Source Links:\n
    \n
    - [Website](https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)\n
    - [Xhitter](https://twitter.com/extrafabulous)\n
    - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)\n
    - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/ExtraFabulousComics/)
    """
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 11
  +favouriteCount: 722
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#3004
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3013 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3015 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3017 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3019 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3021 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3023 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: """
        Instead of the hammer, she should’ve given him a petri dish full of diabetes.\n
        \n
        (Yes, I know that’s not a thing)
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#2379
        date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Stamets@startrek.website"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2389 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2393 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1381 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1402 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1385 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1401 …}
      -id: 95061
      -bodyTs: "'diabet':15 'dish':12 'full':13 'given':8 'hammer':4 'instead':1 'know':18 'petri':11 'thing':23 've':7 'yes':16"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355451"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298501 {#2392
        date: 2023-11-06 20:21:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699277985 {#2394
        date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 95061
    }
  ]
  -id: 10243
  -titleTs: "'extra':2 'fabul':3 'wait':1"
  -bodyTs: "'/)':8 '/extrafabulous)':12 '/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':16 '/extrafabulouscomics/)':20 'extra':1 'fabul':2 'facebook':17 'instagram':13 'link':4 'sourc':3 'twitter.com':11 'twitter.com/extrafabulous)':10 'websit':5 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com':7 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)':6 'www.facebook.com':19 'www.facebook.com/extrafabulouscomics/)':18 'www.instagram.com':15 'www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':14 'xhitter':9"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699297284
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://startrek.website/post/3404556"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699227335 {#2991
    date: 2023-11-06 00:35:35.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699210884 {#2968
    date: 2023-11-05 20:01:24.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
71 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3009 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3011 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3012 …}
  +slug: "WAIT-Extra-Fabulous"
  +title: "WAIT [Extra Fabulous]"
  +url: "https://startrek.website/pictrs/image/84795a9b-fb22-4009-b139-6d787fa3aec5.png"
  +body: """
    Extra Fabulous Source Links:\n
    \n
    - [Website](https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)\n
    - [Xhitter](https://twitter.com/extrafabulous)\n
    - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)\n
    - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/ExtraFabulousComics/)
    """
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 11
  +favouriteCount: 722
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#3004
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3013 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3015 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3017 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3019 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3021 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3023 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: """
        Instead of the hammer, she should’ve given him a petri dish full of diabetes.\n
        \n
        (Yes, I know that’s not a thing)
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#2379
        date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Stamets@startrek.website"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2389 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2393 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1381 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1402 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1385 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1401 …}
      -id: 95061
      -bodyTs: "'diabet':15 'dish':12 'full':13 'given':8 'hammer':4 'instead':1 'know':18 'petri':11 'thing':23 've':7 'yes':16"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355451"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298501 {#2392
        date: 2023-11-06 20:21:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699277985 {#2394
        date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 95061
    }
  ]
  -id: 10243
  -titleTs: "'extra':2 'fabul':3 'wait':1"
  -bodyTs: "'/)':8 '/extrafabulous)':12 '/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':16 '/extrafabulouscomics/)':20 'extra':1 'fabul':2 'facebook':17 'instagram':13 'link':4 'sourc':3 'twitter.com':11 'twitter.com/extrafabulous)':10 'websit':5 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com':7 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)':6 'www.facebook.com':19 'www.facebook.com/extrafabulouscomics/)':18 'www.instagram.com':15 'www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':14 'xhitter':9"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699297284
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://startrek.website/post/3404556"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699227335 {#2991
    date: 2023-11-06 00:35:35.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699210884 {#2968
    date: 2023-11-05 20:01:24.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
72 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3009 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3011 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3012 …}
  +slug: "WAIT-Extra-Fabulous"
  +title: "WAIT [Extra Fabulous]"
  +url: "https://startrek.website/pictrs/image/84795a9b-fb22-4009-b139-6d787fa3aec5.png"
  +body: """
    Extra Fabulous Source Links:\n
    \n
    - [Website](https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)\n
    - [Xhitter](https://twitter.com/extrafabulous)\n
    - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)\n
    - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/ExtraFabulousComics/)
    """
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 11
  +favouriteCount: 722
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#3004
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3013 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3015 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3017 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3019 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3021 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3023 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: """
        Instead of the hammer, she should’ve given him a petri dish full of diabetes.\n
        \n
        (Yes, I know that’s not a thing)
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#2379
        date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Stamets@startrek.website"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2389 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2393 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1381 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1402 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1385 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1401 …}
      -id: 95061
      -bodyTs: "'diabet':15 'dish':12 'full':13 'given':8 'hammer':4 'instead':1 'know':18 'petri':11 'thing':23 've':7 'yes':16"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355451"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298501 {#2392
        date: 2023-11-06 20:21:41.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699277985 {#2394
        date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 95061
    }
  ]
  -id: 10243
  -titleTs: "'extra':2 'fabul':3 'wait':1"
  -bodyTs: "'/)':8 '/extrafabulous)':12 '/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':16 '/extrafabulouscomics/)':20 'extra':1 'fabul':2 'facebook':17 'instagram':13 'link':4 'sourc':3 'twitter.com':11 'twitter.com/extrafabulous)':10 'websit':5 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com':7 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)':6 'www.facebook.com':19 'www.facebook.com/extrafabulouscomics/)':18 'www.instagram.com':15 'www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':14 'xhitter':9"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699297284
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://startrek.website/post/3404556"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699227335 {#2991
    date: 2023-11-06 00:35:35.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699210884 {#2968
    date: 2023-11-05 20:01:24.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
73 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
74 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3009 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3011 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3012 …}
    +slug: "WAIT-Extra-Fabulous"
    +title: "WAIT [Extra Fabulous]"
    +url: "https://startrek.website/pictrs/image/84795a9b-fb22-4009-b139-6d787fa3aec5.png"
    +body: """
      Extra Fabulous Source Links:\n
      \n
      - [Website](https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)\n
      - [Xhitter](https://twitter.com/extrafabulous)\n
      - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)\n
      - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/ExtraFabulousComics/)
      """
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 11
    +favouriteCount: 722
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#3004
      date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3013 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3015 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3017 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3019 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3021 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3023 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387}
    ]
    -id: 10243
    -titleTs: "'extra':2 'fabul':3 'wait':1"
    -bodyTs: "'/)':8 '/extrafabulous)':12 '/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':16 '/extrafabulouscomics/)':20 'extra':1 'fabul':2 'facebook':17 'instagram':13 'link':4 'sourc':3 'twitter.com':11 'twitter.com/extrafabulous)':10 'websit':5 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com':7 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)':6 'www.facebook.com':19 'www.facebook.com/extrafabulouscomics/)':18 'www.instagram.com':15 'www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':14 'xhitter':9"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699297284
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://startrek.website/post/3404556"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699227335 {#2991
      date: 2023-11-06 00:35:35.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699210884 {#2968
      date: 2023-11-05 20:01:24.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: """
    Instead of the hammer, she should’ve given him a petri dish full of diabetes.\n
    \n
    (Yes, I know that’s not a thing)
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#2379
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Stamets@startrek.website"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2389 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2393 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1381 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1402 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1385 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1401 …}
  -id: 95061
  -bodyTs: "'diabet':15 'dish':12 'full':13 'given':8 'hammer':4 'instead':1 'know':18 'petri':11 'thing':23 've':7 'yes':16"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355451"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298501 {#2392
    date: 2023-11-06 20:21:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699277985 {#2394
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 95061
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
75 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3009 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3011 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3012 …}
    +slug: "WAIT-Extra-Fabulous"
    +title: "WAIT [Extra Fabulous]"
    +url: "https://startrek.website/pictrs/image/84795a9b-fb22-4009-b139-6d787fa3aec5.png"
    +body: """
      Extra Fabulous Source Links:\n
      \n
      - [Website](https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)\n
      - [Xhitter](https://twitter.com/extrafabulous)\n
      - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)\n
      - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/ExtraFabulousComics/)
      """
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 11
    +favouriteCount: 722
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#3004
      date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3013 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3015 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3017 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3019 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3021 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3023 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387}
    ]
    -id: 10243
    -titleTs: "'extra':2 'fabul':3 'wait':1"
    -bodyTs: "'/)':8 '/extrafabulous)':12 '/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':16 '/extrafabulouscomics/)':20 'extra':1 'fabul':2 'facebook':17 'instagram':13 'link':4 'sourc':3 'twitter.com':11 'twitter.com/extrafabulous)':10 'websit':5 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com':7 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)':6 'www.facebook.com':19 'www.facebook.com/extrafabulouscomics/)':18 'www.instagram.com':15 'www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':14 'xhitter':9"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699297284
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://startrek.website/post/3404556"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699227335 {#2991
      date: 2023-11-06 00:35:35.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699210884 {#2968
      date: 2023-11-05 20:01:24.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: """
    Instead of the hammer, she should’ve given him a petri dish full of diabetes.\n
    \n
    (Yes, I know that’s not a thing)
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#2379
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Stamets@startrek.website"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2389 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2393 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1381 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1402 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1385 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1401 …}
  -id: 95061
  -bodyTs: "'diabet':15 'dish':12 'full':13 'given':8 'hammer':4 'instead':1 'know':18 'petri':11 'thing':23 've':7 'yes':16"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355451"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298501 {#2392
    date: 2023-11-06 20:21:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699277985 {#2394
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 95061
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
76 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2391
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#3009 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#3011 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#3012 …}
    +slug: "WAIT-Extra-Fabulous"
    +title: "WAIT [Extra Fabulous]"
    +url: "https://startrek.website/pictrs/image/84795a9b-fb22-4009-b139-6d787fa3aec5.png"
    +body: """
      Extra Fabulous Source Links:\n
      \n
      - [Website](https://www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)\n
      - [Xhitter](https://twitter.com/extrafabulous)\n
      - [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)\n
      - [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/ExtraFabulousComics/)
      """
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 11
    +favouriteCount: 722
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#3004
      date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3013 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3015 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3017 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3019 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3021 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#3023 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2387}
    ]
    -id: 10243
    -titleTs: "'extra':2 'fabul':3 'wait':1"
    -bodyTs: "'/)':8 '/extrafabulous)':12 '/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':16 '/extrafabulouscomics/)':20 'extra':1 'fabul':2 'facebook':17 'instagram':13 'link':4 'sourc':3 'twitter.com':11 'twitter.com/extrafabulous)':10 'websit':5 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com':7 'www.extrafabulouscomics.com/)':6 'www.facebook.com':19 'www.facebook.com/extrafabulouscomics/)':18 'www.instagram.com':15 'www.instagram.com/extrafabulous_comics/?hl=en)':14 'xhitter':9"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699297284
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://startrek.website/post/3404556"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699227335 {#2991
      date: 2023-11-06 00:35:35.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699210884 {#2968
      date: 2023-11-05 20:01:24.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: """
    Instead of the hammer, she should’ve given him a petri dish full of diabetes.\n
    \n
    (Yes, I know that’s not a thing)
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699277985 {#2379
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Stamets@startrek.website"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2389 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2393 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1381 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1402 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1385 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1401 …}
  -id: 95061
  -bodyTs: "'diabet':15 'dish':12 'full':13 'given':8 'hammer':4 'instead':1 'know':18 'petri':11 'thing':23 've':7 'yes':16"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4355451"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699298501 {#2392
    date: 2023-11-06 20:21:41.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699277985 {#2394
    date: 2023-11-06 14:39:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 95061
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
77 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
78 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
  +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
  +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
  +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
  +body: """
    Paywall bypass:\n
    \n
    You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
    ============================================\n
    \n
    **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
    \n
    The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
    \n
    I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
    \n
    Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
    \n
    People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
    \n
    They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
    \n
    Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
    \n
    The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
    \n
    What does Hamas want?\n
    =====================\n
    \n
    Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
    \n
    The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
    \n
    Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
    \n
    > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
    \n
    Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
    \n
    Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
    \n
    Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
    \n
    > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
    \n
    **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
    \n
    Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
    \n
    In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
    \n
    Multipolarity is chaos\n
    ======================\n
    \n
    Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
    \n
    There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
    \n
    In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
    \n
    But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
    \n
    Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
    ======================================================\n
    \n
    I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
    \n
    Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
    \n
    But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
    \n
    Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
    \n
    In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
    \n
    So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
    ==========================================================================================================================\n
    \n
    As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
    \n
    That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
    \n
    Danger of miscalculation\n
    ========================\n
    \n
    Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
    \n
    The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
    \n
    The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
    \n
    There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
    \n
    So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
    ==============================================================================================================\n
    \n
    But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
    \n
    Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
    \n
    The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
    \n
    If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
    \n
    The BRICS+ ideology\n
    ===================\n
    \n
    The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
    \n
    It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
    \n
    Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
    \n
    And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
    \n
    Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
    \n
    For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
    \n
    What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
    \n
    I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
    \n
    That Harvard statement…\n
    =======================\n
    \n
    A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
    \n
    The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
    \n
    The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
    \n
    > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
    \n
    From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
    \n
    > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
    \n
    This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
    \n
    The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
    \n
    It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
    \n
    The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
    \n
    For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
    \n
    Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
    \n
    But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
    \n
    > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
    \n
    In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
    \n
    And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
    \n
    This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
    \n
    Two irreconcileable lefts\n
    =========================\n
    \n
    There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
    \n
    One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
    \n
    Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
    \n
    And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
    \n
    Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
    \n
    Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
    \n
    Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 27
  +favouriteCount: 26
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
    date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
  +children: [
    7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 1
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
        date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        "@livus@kbin.social"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
      -id: 173504
      -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
        date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 173504
    }
    5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
        \n
        This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
        \n
        > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
        \n
        So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
        \n
        > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
        \n
        Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
        \n
        Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
        \n
        > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
        \n
        Why?
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 5
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
        date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
      -id: 172929
      -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
        date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
        date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172929
    }
    6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > What about … examples\n
        \n
        Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
        \n
        > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
        \n
        To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
        date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@iain@feddit.nl"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
      -id: 172947
      -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
        date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
        date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172947
    }
    4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
        \n
        A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
        \n
        Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
        \n
        Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
        \n
        And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
        \n
        (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
        \n
        And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 22
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
        date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
      -id: 172717
      -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
        date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
        date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172717
    }
    3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
        \n
        But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
        date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
      -id: 172916
      -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
        date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
        date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172916
    }
    2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
        date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
      -id: 172948
      -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
        date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
        date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172948
    }
    1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
        date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
      -id: 172942
      -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
        date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172942
    }
    0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
        \n
        He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
        \n
        Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 1
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
        date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@iain@feddit.nl"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
      -id: 173517
      -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
        date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
        date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 173517
    }
  ]
  -id: 17703
  -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
  -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701236300
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
    date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
    date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
79 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
  +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
  +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
  +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
  +body: """
    Paywall bypass:\n
    \n
    You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
    ============================================\n
    \n
    **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
    \n
    The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
    \n
    I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
    \n
    Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
    \n
    People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
    \n
    They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
    \n
    Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
    \n
    The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
    \n
    What does Hamas want?\n
    =====================\n
    \n
    Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
    \n
    The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
    \n
    Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
    \n
    > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
    \n
    Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
    \n
    Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
    \n
    Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
    \n
    > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
    \n
    **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
    \n
    Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
    \n
    In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
    \n
    Multipolarity is chaos\n
    ======================\n
    \n
    Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
    \n
    There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
    \n
    In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
    \n
    But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
    \n
    Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
    ======================================================\n
    \n
    I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
    \n
    Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
    \n
    But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
    \n
    Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
    \n
    In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
    \n
    So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
    ==========================================================================================================================\n
    \n
    As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
    \n
    That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
    \n
    Danger of miscalculation\n
    ========================\n
    \n
    Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
    \n
    The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
    \n
    The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
    \n
    There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
    \n
    So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
    ==============================================================================================================\n
    \n
    But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
    \n
    Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
    \n
    The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
    \n
    If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
    \n
    The BRICS+ ideology\n
    ===================\n
    \n
    The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
    \n
    It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
    \n
    Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
    \n
    And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
    \n
    Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
    \n
    For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
    \n
    What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
    \n
    I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
    \n
    That Harvard statement…\n
    =======================\n
    \n
    A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
    \n
    The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
    \n
    The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
    \n
    > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
    \n
    From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
    \n
    > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
    \n
    This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
    \n
    The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
    \n
    It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
    \n
    The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
    \n
    For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
    \n
    Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
    \n
    But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
    \n
    > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
    \n
    In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
    \n
    And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
    \n
    This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
    \n
    Two irreconcileable lefts\n
    =========================\n
    \n
    There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
    \n
    One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
    \n
    Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
    \n
    And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
    \n
    Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
    \n
    Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
    \n
    Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 27
  +favouriteCount: 26
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
    date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
  +children: [
    7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 1
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
        date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        "@livus@kbin.social"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
      -id: 173504
      -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
        date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 173504
    }
    5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
        \n
        This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
        \n
        > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
        \n
        So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
        \n
        > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
        \n
        Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
        \n
        Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
        \n
        > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
        \n
        Why?
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 5
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
        date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
      -id: 172929
      -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
        date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
        date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172929
    }
    6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > What about … examples\n
        \n
        Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
        \n
        > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
        \n
        To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
        date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@iain@feddit.nl"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
      -id: 172947
      -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
        date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
        date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172947
    }
    4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
        \n
        A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
        \n
        Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
        \n
        Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
        \n
        And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
        \n
        (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
        \n
        And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 22
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
        date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
      -id: 172717
      -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
        date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
        date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172717
    }
    3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
        \n
        But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
        date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
      -id: 172916
      -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
        date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
        date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172916
    }
    2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
        date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
      -id: 172948
      -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
        date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
        date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172948
    }
    1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
        date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
      -id: 172942
      -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
        date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172942
    }
    0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
        \n
        He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
        \n
        Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 1
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
        date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@iain@feddit.nl"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
      -id: 173517
      -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
        date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
        date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 173517
    }
  ]
  -id: 17703
  -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
  -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701236300
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
    date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
    date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
80 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
  +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
  +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
  +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
  +body: """
    Paywall bypass:\n
    \n
    You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
    ============================================\n
    \n
    **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
    \n
    The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
    \n
    I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
    \n
    Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
    \n
    People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
    \n
    They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
    \n
    Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
    \n
    The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
    \n
    What does Hamas want?\n
    =====================\n
    \n
    Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
    \n
    The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
    \n
    Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
    \n
    > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
    \n
    Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
    \n
    Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
    \n
    Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
    \n
    > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
    \n
    **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
    \n
    Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
    \n
    In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
    \n
    Multipolarity is chaos\n
    ======================\n
    \n
    Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
    \n
    There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
    \n
    In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
    \n
    But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
    \n
    Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
    ======================================================\n
    \n
    I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
    \n
    Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
    \n
    But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
    \n
    Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
    \n
    In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
    \n
    So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
    ==========================================================================================================================\n
    \n
    As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
    \n
    That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
    \n
    Danger of miscalculation\n
    ========================\n
    \n
    Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
    \n
    The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
    \n
    The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
    \n
    There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
    \n
    So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
    ==============================================================================================================\n
    \n
    But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
    \n
    Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
    \n
    The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
    \n
    If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
    \n
    The BRICS+ ideology\n
    ===================\n
    \n
    The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
    \n
    It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
    \n
    Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
    \n
    And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
    \n
    Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
    \n
    For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
    \n
    What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
    \n
    I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
    \n
    That Harvard statement…\n
    =======================\n
    \n
    A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
    \n
    The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
    \n
    The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
    \n
    > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
    \n
    From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
    \n
    > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
    \n
    This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
    \n
    The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
    \n
    It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
    \n
    The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
    \n
    For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
    \n
    Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
    \n
    But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
    \n
    > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
    \n
    In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
    \n
    And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
    \n
    This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
    \n
    Two irreconcileable lefts\n
    =========================\n
    \n
    There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
    \n
    One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
    \n
    Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
    \n
    And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
    \n
    Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
    \n
    Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
    \n
    Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
    """
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 27
  +favouriteCount: 26
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
    date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
  +children: [
    7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 1
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
        date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        "@livus@kbin.social"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
      -id: 173504
      -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
        date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 173504
    }
    5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
        \n
        This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
        \n
        > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
        \n
        So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
        \n
        > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
        \n
        Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
        \n
        Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
        \n
        > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
        \n
        Why?
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 5
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
        date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
      -id: 172929
      -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
        date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
        date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172929
    }
    6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > What about … examples\n
        \n
        Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
        \n
        > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
        \n
        To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
        date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@iain@feddit.nl"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
      -id: 172947
      -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
        date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
        date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172947
    }
    4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
        \n
        A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
        \n
        Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
        \n
        Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
        \n
        And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
        \n
        (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
        \n
        And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 22
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
        date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
      -id: 172717
      -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
        date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
        date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172717
    }
    3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
        \n
        But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
        date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
      -id: 172916
      -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
        date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
        date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172916
    }
    2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 3
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
        date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
      -id: 172948
      -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
        date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
        date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172948
    }
    1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 2
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
        date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
      -id: 172942
      -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
        date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 172942
    }
    0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
      +body: """
        > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
        \n
        He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
        \n
        Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 1
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
        date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
        "@millie@beehaw.org"
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@iain@feddit.nl"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
      -id: 173517
      -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
        date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
        date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 173517
    }
  ]
  -id: 17703
  -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
  -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701236300
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
    date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
    date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
81 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
82 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287}
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 1
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
    date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
    "@livus@kbin.social"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
  -id: 173504
  -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
    date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 173504
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
83 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287}
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 1
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
    date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
    "@livus@kbin.social"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
  -id: 173504
  -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
    date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 173504
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
84 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287}
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 1
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
    date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
    "@livus@kbin.social"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
  -id: 173504
  -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
    date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 173504
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
85 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
86 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222}
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
    \n
    This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
    \n
    > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
    \n
    So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
    \n
    > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
    \n
    Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
    \n
    Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
    \n
    > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
    \n
    Why?
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 5
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
    date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
  -id: 172929
  -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
    date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
    date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172929
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
87 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222}
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
    \n
    This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
    \n
    > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
    \n
    So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
    \n
    > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
    \n
    Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
    \n
    Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
    \n
    > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
    \n
    Why?
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 5
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
    date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
  -id: 172929
  -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
    date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
    date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172929
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
88 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222}
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
    \n
    This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
    \n
    > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
    \n
    So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
    \n
    > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
    \n
    Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
    \n
    Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
    \n
    > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
    \n
    Why?
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 5
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
    date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
  -id: 172929
  -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
    date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
    date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172929
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
89 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
90 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253}
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > What about … examples\n
    \n
    Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
    \n
    > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
    \n
    To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
    date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@iain@feddit.nl"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
  -id: 172947
  -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
    date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
    date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172947
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
91 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253}
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > What about … examples\n
    \n
    Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
    \n
    > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
    \n
    To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
    date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@iain@feddit.nl"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
  -id: 172947
  -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
    date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
    date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172947
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
92 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253}
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > What about … examples\n
    \n
    Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
    \n
    > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
    \n
    To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
    date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@iain@feddit.nl"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
  -id: 172947
  -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
    date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
    date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172947
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
93 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
94 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297}
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
    \n
    A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
    \n
    Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
    \n
    Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
    \n
    And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
    \n
    (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
    \n
    And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 22
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
    date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
  -id: 172717
  -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
    date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
    date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172717
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
95 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297}
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
    \n
    A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
    \n
    Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
    \n
    Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
    \n
    And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
    \n
    (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
    \n
    And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 22
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
    date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
  -id: 172717
  -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
    date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
    date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172717
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
96 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297}
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
    \n
    A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
    \n
    Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
    \n
    Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
    \n
    And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
    \n
    (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
    \n
    And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 22
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
    date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
  -id: 172717
  -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
    date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
    date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172717
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
97 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
98 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292}
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
    \n
    But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
    date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
  -id: 172916
  -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
    date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
    date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172916
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
99 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292}
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
    \n
    But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
    date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
  -id: 172916
  -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
    date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
    date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172916
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
100 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292}
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
    \n
    But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
    date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
  -id: 172916
  -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
    date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
    date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172916
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
101 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
102 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259}
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
    date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
  -id: 172948
  -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
    date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
    date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172948
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
103 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259}
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
    date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
  -id: 172948
  -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
    date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
    date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172948
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
104 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259}
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 3
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
    date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
  -id: 172948
  -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
    date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
    date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172948
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
105 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
106 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207}
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
    date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
  -id: 172942
  -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
    date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172942
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
107 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207}
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
    date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
  -id: 172942
  -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
    date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172942
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
108 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207}
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
          \n
          He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
          \n
          Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
        -id: 173517
        -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
          date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
          date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173517
      }
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 2
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
    date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
    "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
  -id: 172942
  -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
    date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 172942
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
109 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
110 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149}
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
    \n
    He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
    \n
    Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 1
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
    date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@iain@feddit.nl"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
  -id: 173517
  -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
    date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
    date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 173517
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
111 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149}
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
    \n
    He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
    \n
    Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 1
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
    date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@iain@feddit.nl"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
  -id: 173517
  -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
    date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
    date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 173517
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
112 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2819 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
    +image: null
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2951 …}
    +slug: "You-wanted-a-multipolar-world-You-got-chaos-Edit-Do"
    +title: "You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos. [Edit: Do Hamas represent Palestinians?]"
    +url: "https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09"
    +body: """
      Paywall bypass:\n
      \n
      You wanted a multipolar world? You got chaos\n
      ============================================\n
      \n
      **Hamas terror attack was aimed squarely at the global order**By Paul Mason 12 Oct 2023 for medium.com […medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got…](https://paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)\n
      \n
      The Hamas terror attack has triggered war in Gaza, a geopolitical crisis and now — from Sydney to New York City — outbursts of street-level anti-Semitism in the West. Unless it de-escalates quickly, it looks like a strategic turning point both for Palestinian nationalism and Israel.\n
      \n
      I covered the 2014 war both from [inside Gaza](https://www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot) and on the streets with the Israeli peace movement. I’ve interviewed Hamas and seen how they operate up close. So, though I am no expert on the region, I can throw some concreteness into the current battle of abstractions.\n
      \n
      Let’s start with the obvious: **Israel has a right to defend itself, rescue the hostages, arrest and prosecute Hamas and engage in lawful armed combat with its enemy**. But the international community has a right to demand proportionality, restraint, respect for international law, and condemn breaches of it. President Biden last night was right to emphasise the need for lawfulness.\n
      \n
      People claiming the Hamas attack is the “violence of the oppressed” are deluded. Hamas rules Gaza like a mafia state: its operatives walk around neighbourhoods in twos, dressed in dark suits, prying into people’s business. They run the place on a mixture of terror, public service provision and the kudos of their fighters.\n
      \n
      They are feared but there is widespread disrespect for them, especially among secular and nationalist sections of the population.\n
      \n
      Paradoxically, the Western “anti-imperialists” trying to apologise for the terror attack, and the Israeli right calling for retribution against civilians, both need to identify Hamas with the Palestinian population of Gaza in order to justify violence. **But there is no basis for doing so**.\n
      \n
      The fact that a violent action takes place in the context of a wider oppression does not make it either (a) just (b) lawful under international law or © effective in pursuit of social justice. In this case, Hamas’ act of terror looks set to achieve the opposite.\n
      \n
      What does Hamas want?\n
      =====================\n
      \n
      Hamas has offered a truce and asked for negotiations, stating that it has “achieved its objective”. If so, it’s logical conclude that the immediate objective was to demonstrate proof-of-concept of an unstoppable pogromist terror. Do as we ask or we do this again, might be a fair summary.\n
      \n
      The wider aim, according to numerous [experts](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=The%20Iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.), is to force Hamas and Iran back into the power-broking process in the Middle East region, paralysing Saudi-Israeli rapprochement.\n
      \n
      Iran’s leader Imam Khamenei, in a [speech](https://english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/The-usurper-Zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end) to the made International Islamic Unity Conference on 3 October, gave what now sounds like an early warning:\n
      \n
      > *“The firm view of the Islamic Republic is that the governments that are gambling on normalizing relations with the Zionist regime will suffer losses. Defeat awaits them…Today, the situation of the Zionist regime is not a situation that encourages closeness to it. They [other governments] should not make this mistake. The usurper [Zionist] regime is coming to an end.”*\n
      \n
      Hamas could only achieve the aim of ending Saudi-Israeli rapprochement with an attack designed to trigger massive retribution, risking a regional all-out war. So why, despite its formal [turn](https://digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551) in 2017 to “anti-Zionism”, ditching the [1988 Covenant](https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp) and its violently anti-Semitic language, did the attack take the form of a deliberate and extreme slaughter of Jewish civilians?\n
      \n
      Here Zeev Sternhell’s rule applies: the [pioneering historian of fascism](https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000) taught us to “take fascists at their word”.\n
      \n
      Both Hamas and the Islamic Republic of Iran have stated their aims of destroying the state of Israel often enough. But there’s a line in Khamenei’s 03.10.23 speech that, in retrospect looks explanatory:\n
      \n
      > *“Thus, [the Zionists] are filled with grudge. They are filled with anger! Of course, the Quran exclaims: “Say, ‘die of your rage!’” (3:119). That’s right. Be angry, and die of your rage. And this will happen. They are dying. With God’s help, this matter of ‘die of your rage’ is happening now as regards the Zionist regime.”*\n
      \n
      **“Die of your rage” might actually be a good summary of what Hamas intends Israel to now do.**\n
      \n
      Enraged by the barbarity of the attacks, Israel unleashes unprecedented collective punishment against Gaza, triggering both Hezbollah and West Bank militants to join in the fight; this in turn prompts a wave of anti-Semitic demonstrations in Western cities, and draws the USA into a regional quagmire, testing the limits of American support for Israel. Meanwhile combat losses, and retribution over the complete failure of Netanyahu’s strategy of “managing” the conflict, raise political divisions in Israeli society to the point where its democracy fails.\n
      \n
      In a context where both Russia and China have complex hybrid destabilisation operations going on in Western democracies, and where the BRICS+ project is pursuing the active decomposition of the rules-based order, **this objective does not look as mad as at first sight.**\n
      \n
      Multipolarity is chaos\n
      ======================\n
      \n
      Contrary to the [homilies](https://mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/) of the pro-China influence networks aimed at the global south, the “multipolar world” turns out not to be one of peaceful coexistence, but characterised by **extreme conflicts and genocide.**\n
      \n
      There’s another 2000 words. I will publish the whole thing on my Medium site in the next 24 hours. To read the whole article now please subscribe …\n
      \n
      In pursuit of systemic competition Beijing and Moscow are scraping at every open wound in the body geopolitic. Mass ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh; a Serbian provocation in Kosovo designed to trigger ethnic conflict; genocidal actions and rhetoric by Russia in its war against Ukraine; the genocide of the Uighur people and culture; the genocide of Rohingya in Myanmar; the Sahel’s descent into warlordism, terrorism and military rule — that is a heck of a lot of genocidal activity to happen in a short space of time.\n
      \n
      But it’s what you get when you purposefully dismantle an international order based on treaties and explicit rules. And where elites in Russia, the USA, Brasil and parts of Europe are openly experimenting with ethno-nationalist politics.\n
      \n
      Chaos, then, is a feature of multipolarity, not a bug.\n
      ======================================================\n
      \n
      I doubt Netanyahu, and his project of replacing Israeli democracy with an oligarchic far-right autocracy, can survive this shock long-term. His project of tolerating Hamas, to play it off against Fatah, has failed. So in framing the response of the international community, we are also attempting to frame the response of any stable Israeli government that emerges from the current crisis.\n
      \n
      Israel has signalled its military objective is to destroy Hamas. From my experience in Gaza I would say: *that is possible.*\n
      \n
      But be in no doubt. It will need a sustained urban combat operation, a long-term military occupation, massive loss of civilian life, an existential refugee crisis in Sinai, and the diversion of US-supplied ammunition and resources from Ukraine. Attempting it with a largely conscript/reservist army, full of recently mobilised and enraged soldiers? Again it’s worth remembering Khamenei’s exhortation to Israelis to “Die of your rage”.\n
      \n
      Typically, from my experience, combat in Gaza takes the following form. There is a street with children playing at one end; in the middle it is eerily deserted; at the other end is the IDF and above is an IDF drone. **But there is no front line.** The *mujahedeen* are in tunnels, popping up to take sniper shots or lay IEDs at night, and only committing ATGMs once a vehicle comes into view. **The only front line is, for most of the time, between the IDF and Palestinian civilians.** That’s what makes it a lethal environment for the latter. They can’t effectively shelter: and Hamas instructs them not to leave. There is no reason to believe that it will break from this modus operandi now.\n
      \n
      In addition, the civilian population cannot flee — without the creation of formal safe routes south and a corridor into Egypt; and many will not move because as stateless people they believe they will never be allowed to return, nor to claim asylum elsewhere.\n
      \n
      So if Israel launches any significant attempt to seize, hold and pacify Gaza, there will be massive civilian loss of life.\n
      ==========================================================================================================================\n
      \n
      As someone who’s been there during a war, and seen extensive civilian deaths happening right at my feet, I am appalled at the prospect of something qualitatively worse. If in addition the attack is prosecuted using the kind of collective punishment we’re seeing now — “damage instead of accuracy”, the deprivation of water and electricity to the whole population etc — not only will liberal sympathy for Israel evaporate, but the Muslim minorities in some Western countries will be radicalised.\n
      \n
      That is what gives the international community legitimate right to demand Israeli response is *necessary, proportional and legal.*\n
      \n
      Danger of miscalculation\n
      ========================\n
      \n
      Both sides risk miscalculating. Hamas does not care what happens to Palestinian civilians in Gaza, many of whom hate Hamas. A chilling [Channel 4 News](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeuNRaNGQr8) report from inside Gaza shows Palestinian civilians frantically searching for medical help for their kids, where there is none. What happens to their minds after a month under bombardment of this severity would be uncharted territory for the people of the strip.\n
      \n
      The thought-patterns I remember from 2014 were these: people in Gaza knew that the resistance had launched rockets, or staged incursions, in order to extract some tactical concessions from Israel, and that the bombing would at some point stop. There were regular ceasefires and continuous mediation. There was food, for those who could afford it, and a continuous 3G signal for people’s cellphones. I also remember the vehemence with which in 2014, for example, Fatah sympathisers would quote Mohammed Deif’s claim that “Hamas only attacks the IDF, not civilians”.\n
      \n
      The panic depicted on Channel 4 News suggests it has dawned on some people that these assumptions no longer hold. People fear they will be either massacred or forcibly expelled into Egypt, with the option of living in an Israeli occupied wasteland as the only alternative.\n
      \n
      There may be no ceasefires, no foreign medical teams, no electricity or water. As I write, the rapid deterioration of medical care, and large numbers of child victims of Israeli bombing, already show a marked change compared to conditions at this stage of the 2014 conflict.\n
      \n
      So Hamas now either cements the loyalty of the population or its support collapses as a consequence of defeat.\n
      ==============================================================================================================\n
      \n
      But there is a danger of miscalculation for Israel too. Netanyahu’s far-right government completely missed the threat, actively stoked tensions in the West Bank and Al Aqsa, and could easily now double down on a self-destructive course.\n
      \n
      Ultimately, you cannot hold two million people in an open air prison without a gaoler to keep order. If Hamas can’t do it, the IDF will have to be a permanent occupation force, or it will have to install the PA, or the UN will have to send a stabilisation force.\n
      \n
      The very impossibility of all these outcomes shows why we need an internationally mediated peace, alongside a functional two-state solution, which allows the people of Gaza to live in peace, exercise democracy and travel across borders.\n
      \n
      If Netanyahu’s endgame is a revenge fantasy of flattening Gaza and pushing its inhabitants into the desert, that’s not an endgame at all — only the casus bellifor a regional war.\n
      \n
      The BRICS+ ideology\n
      ===================\n
      \n
      The Gaza crisis is the latest example of how the Russian/Chinese “multipolar world” project works in practice. It doesn’t matter whether there is a chain of command that goes Moscow→Tehran→Hamas. There is a *chain of understanding* — seize every opportunity to militarise all conflict; exploit every unexpected breakthrough; make all violence symbolic; weaponise the information space and push conflict into the heartlands of “imperialism”.\n
      \n
      It’s the information-era version of Tukachevsky’s [maxim](https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/): assault the enemy throughout the depths of his formation.\n
      \n
      Both Russian and pro-China proxy networks have created media outlets, money, content and social media amplification systems for the BRICS+ ideology. Its central tenets are that a multipolar world is better than the Charter system; that universalism and international law are over; that the West no longer has the right to use the structures of international governance to normalise concepts like democracy or human rights; and that everything that disorganises the rules-based order is progressive, even when carried out by reactionary political forces.\n
      \n
      And that explains what’s happened in the West over the past five days: Palestinian solidarity movements that which were generally aligned with Fatah suddenly moving in the direction of overtly celebrating Hamas terror.\n
      \n
      Arab nationalism no longer looks like the dominant ideology on the demonstrations we’ve seen in Sydney, London and NYC. Alongside it there’s a mixture of Islamism plus the “decolonisation” agenda of postmodernist academia. That’s why we’re seeing the phenomenon of left-wing politicians haplessly turning up to events where the crowd, as in Sydney, chants “Gas The Jews” or, as in NYC, wave images of Swastikas on their iPhones, or where as in Brighton speakers hail the murder of 1200+ Israelis as “beautiful”.\n
      \n
      For the past two years, during the Ukraine war, this incipient red-brown ideology has been mostly contained: see the bedraggled Stop The War demos here, the pathetic rallies staged jointly by Sara Wagenknecht and the AfD, the failure of Zoe Konstantopoulou’s left nationalist party in Greece.\n
      \n
      What they were missing were the masses. But with this conflict there is now a danger that the masses turn up, and are corralled into this emergent fusion of far-left/far-right politics.\n
      \n
      I’ve spent the period post-2016 trying to equip the democratic left to defeat this ideology. It’s not about being “anti-woke”, or apologising for colonialism: it means teaching people that a cocktail of anti-humanism, anti-universalism and anti-rationality is a route to excusing the totalitarian states in Russia and China, and — now — the genocidal actions of their proxies.\n
      \n
      That Harvard statement…\n
      =======================\n
      \n
      A case study of this is the [statement](https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370) issued by 31 Harvard student groups saying they “hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence” — just hours after the Hamas attack began. They have been condemned by elderly conservative alumni, but I think it’s better to engage them.\n
      \n
      The logic of the statement is pretty simple. It makes no mention of the *actual terrorist attack*, the calculated killing of civilians, the hostage taking or use of disgusting imagery to instil terror. Its title refers simply to the “Situation in Palestine”.\n
      \n
      The only concrete reference to what is happening comes in the line:\n
      \n
      > *“The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.”*\n
      \n
      From this implicit premise — the non-existence of Israeli victims, or Hamas war crimes or genocidal intent — flows the conclusion:\n
      \n
      > *“The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years.”*\n
      \n
      This, of course, is a direct echo of pro-Kremlin propaganda over Ukraine, where “NATO aggression” is the only thing to blame for Russia’s criminal aggression.\n
      \n
      The logic is that Israel is responsible for everything Hamas does *because* its violence has “structured every aspect of Palestinian existence” since the Nakba.\n
      \n
      It is a ridiculous assertion. By the same logic Israel was also “to blame” for the Black September movement, Leila Khaled, Yasser Arafat, the Oslo accords, and the two Intifadas.\n
      \n
      The logical implication is that Palestinians have no agency whatsoever. That Hamas murders civilians because Israel has “structured” Palestinian reality to make that inevitable.\n
      \n
      For people presumably wedded to “decolonising” the curriculum, it is a shockingly colonialist premise.\n
      \n
      Our task — on the democratic and internationalist left — is to offer the signatories of this statement a route out of this. Learning to use formal logic might be a start. Accepting, as Marx says, that “history is nothing but people pursuing their aims” regardless of how oppression structures their behaviour, might be a second. Reference to some basic shared ethical principles might be a third.\n
      \n
      But we need to understand how closely this hyper-deterministic and anti-universal world view maps onto the ideology presented, for example, by Putin at [Valdai](http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444) last week. For Putin there is no single human civilisation, only civilisations, which must be rooted in ethnicity establish their co-existence through the survival of the fittest:\n
      \n
      > *“There are many civilisations, and none is superior or inferior to another. They are equal since each civilisation represents a unique expression of its own culture, traditions, and the aspirations of its people.”*\n
      \n
      In a way, what Putin preaches is an “intersectionality of the peoples”: identity politics raised from the level of the individual to the level of the ethnic group.\n
      \n
      And it turns out anti-Enlightenment leftism makes it pretty easy to converge with that view. The common assumptions are disdain for universalism, scorn for international law and human rights, repudiation of the Enlightenment (and thus liberalism, social democracy, humanistic Marxism and anarchism) and worship of any totalitarian government that delivers economic development.\n
      \n
      This is the modern incarnation of Stalinism, and — to the surprise of nobody who has studied actual Stalinism — it has no problem seeing fascists like Hamas as the “agent of progress”.\n
      \n
      Two irreconcileable lefts\n
      =========================\n
      \n
      There’s much [soul searching today](https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html), especially in the US media, about why so many on the left, and in academia, have thoughtlessly cheered on mass murder. The answer is that, first over Ukraine, and now over Hamas, the global left is rapidly splitting into irreconcileable camps — as Edward Thompson [recognised](https://www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm) it would, under the influence of post-structuralism in the 1970s.\n
      \n
      One camp, he said, is a theology. The other a tradition of active reason. The first repudiates liberalism and universalism. The second recognises its debt to liberalism and wants to make universalism consistent. The first claims international law is a sham; the second knows that, though the institutions of the rules-based order are flawed, they are better than chaos.\n
      \n
      Today, the first is on the side of Putin, Khamenei and Assad. The second knows that you can stand with the Israeli people under attack while simultaneously standing up for the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.\n
      \n
      And here’s the ultimate irony. The entire Palestinian project of a state has, since 1967, relied on [resolutions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine#:~:text=Resolution%20681) passed at the United Nations and on international law. In short, on the multilateral rules based order.\n
      \n
      Those who advocate a multipolar world without treaties, laws and norms of state behaviour need to understand how perilous such a world would be for the people of Gaza.\n
      \n
      Those flaunting their joy at the murder of Israeli civilians need to understand the licence this creates in the minds of rightwing ethno-nationalists in our own society. What Hamas did to the kids of Kfar Azar, the far right wants to do to you.\n
      \n
      Solidarity to all my friends in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.
      """
    +type: "link"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: false
    +commentCount: 27
    +favouriteCount: 26
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701193880 {#2946
      date: 2023-11-28 18:51:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2953 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2955 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2957 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2959 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2961 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2963 …}
    +children: [
      7 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2287
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2188 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "Yes, my apologies. School bullying is a serious problem."
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 1
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701177986 {#2285
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
          "@livus@kbin.social"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2142 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2039 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2155 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2158 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2151 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2145 …}
        -id: 173504
        -bodyTs: "'apolog':3 'bulli':5 'problem':9 'school':4 'serious':8 'yes':1"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967314"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701177986 {#2286
          date: 2023-11-28 14:26:26.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 173504
      }
      5 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2222
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2221 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > If you’re looking for a thoughtful legal analysis, you should check this out: [thenation.com/…/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge…](https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)\n
          \n
          This seemed like a high quality analysis by a respectable academic, then the **very** **first** **source** I checked out turned out to be an amazing exaggeration. The article states\n
          \n
          > Tens of thousands are injured, and over 45% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed.\n
          \n
          So I check the source, which is a paywalled WSJ article. Already the title of the article is\n
          \n
          > At Least 45% of Housing Units Destroyed or Damaged in Gaza\n
          \n
          Destroyed **or** **damaged**. Should I check the other sources for similar “mistakes”? Perhaps I just got lucky and found the only bullshit reference from this article written by a Harvard Law School PhD graduate?\n
          \n
          Or perhaps Harvard Law Review was onto something when they didn’t publish it and I would be wasting my time looking through all of them instead of just trusting them on this.\n
          \n
          > I’m very comfortable calling the campaign against Gaza in the last few weeks genocide\n
          \n
          Why?
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 5
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160780 {#2261
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@andrewrgross@slrpnk.net"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2219 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2196 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2194 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2193 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2205 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2202 …}
        -id: 172929
        -bodyTs: "'/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':19 '/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-ge':16 '45':56,84 'academ':30 'alreadi':75 'amaz':44 'analysi':9,26 'articl':47,74,80,118 'bullshit':114 'call':164 'campaign':166 'check':12,37,66,98 'comfort':163 'damag':90,95 'destroy':63,88,93 'didn':137 'exagger':45 'first':34 'found':111 'gaza':60,92,168 'genocid':174 'got':108 'graduat':126 'harvard':122,129 'high':24 'home':58 'hous':86 'injur':53 'instead':153 'last':171 'law':123,130 'least':83 'legal':8 'like':22 'look':4,148 'lucki':109 'm':161 'mistak':104 'onto':133 'paywal':72 'perhap':105,128 'phd':125 'publish':139 'qualiti':25 're':3 'refer':115 'respect':29 'review':131 'school':124 'seem':21 'similar':103 'someth':134 'sourc':35,68,101 'state':48 'ten':49 'thenation.com':15 'thought':7 'thousand':51 'time':147 'titl':77 'trust':156 'turn':39 'unit':87 'wast':145 'week':173 'would':143 'written':119 'wsj':73 'www.thenation.com':18 'www.thenation.com/article/archive/harvard-law-review-gaza-israel-genocide/)':17"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963377"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701922459 {#2220
          date: 2023-12-07 05:14:19.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160780 {#2218
          date: 2023-11-28 09:39:40.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172929
      }
      6 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2253
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2265 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          > What about … examples\n
          \n
          Sure, many of these happened in a time where communism was still more like a theory (or not even that yet) than anything tried in practice. People who called themselves communist did a **lot** of these in a single century, most of them after WW2.\n
          \n
          > Besides, Pol Pot wasn’t much of a communist\n
          \n
          To be fair, I said people “who call themselves communist”.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161399 {#2274
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@iain@feddit.nl"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2262 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2264 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2242 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2240 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2233 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2234 …}
        -id: 172947
        -bodyTs: "'anyth':26 'besid':49 'call':32,65 'centuri':43 'communism':13 'communist':34,57,67 'even':22 'exampl':3 'fair':60 'happen':8 'like':17 'lot':37 'mani':5 'much':54 'peopl':30,63 'pol':50 'pot':51 'practic':29 'said':62 'singl':42 'still':15 'sure':4 'theori':19 'time':11 'tri':27 'wasn':52 'ww2':48 'yet':24"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963587"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701923390 {#2272
          date: 2023-12-07 05:29:50.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161399 {#2190
          date: 2023-11-28 09:49:59.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172947
      }
      4 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2297
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          I mean it’s not great what they’ve done in Gaza, but just to recalibrate your senses a bit, this is what happens when a nation actually commits genocide against a weaker people inside its borders: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide)\n
          \n
          A significant metric to look at is population growth. Gaza strip is one of the densest population areas in the world, and it has been growing rapidly. This is, incidentally, the reason why most of their population is under-age. In Uyghur areas, in contrast, population has been diminishing in growing rates.\n
          \n
          Of course, you shouldn’t also ignore the forced labor, political indoctrination, forced sterilization, forced contraception, forced abortion. I don’t think Israel has done any of these? Israel has destroyed some mosques in their attacks, whereas China has razed or damaged 16 **thousand** mosques in Uyghur areas. Granted, the area is much larger, so there are probably more mosques in there also. But you should note that China is not at war against Uyghurs, and hasn’t been attacked by them – they’re just destroying them.\n
          \n
          Here’s another: [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)\n
          \n
          And [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide)\n
          \n
          (Why is it almost always the people who call themselves communists?)\n
          \n
          And of course there’s the Holocaust, but I suppose it’s not classy to refer to that in this case.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 22
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701152198 {#2309
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2322 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2312 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2307 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2308 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2304 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2319 …}
        -id: 172717
        -bodyTs: "'/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':190 '/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':186 '/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':40 '16':136 'abort':111 'actual':28 'age':81 'almost':194 'also':99,156 'alway':195 'anoth':183 'area':58,84,141,144 'attack':129,173 'bit':20 'border':37 'call':199 'case':222 'china':131,162 'classi':215 'commit':29 'communist':201 'contracept':109 'contrast':86 'cours':95,204 'damag':135 'densest':56 'destroy':124,179 'diminish':90 'done':10,118 'en.wikipedia.org':39,185,189 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/cambodian_genocide)':188 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/holodomor)':184 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/uyghur_genocide)':38 'forc':102,106,108,110 'gaza':12,50 'genocid':30 'grant':142 'great':6 'grow':66,92 'growth':49 'happen':24 'hasn':170 'holocaust':208 'ignor':100 'incident':70 'indoctrin':105 'insid':35 'israel':116,122 'labor':103 'larger':147 'look':45 'mean':2 'metric':43 'mosqu':126,138,153 'much':146 'nation':27 'note':160 'one':53 'peopl':34,197 'polit':104 'popul':48,57,77,87 'probabl':151 'rapid':67 'rate':93 'raze':133 're':177 'reason':72 'recalibr':16 'refer':217 'sens':18 'shouldn':97 'signific':42 'steril':107 'strip':51 'suppos':211 'think':115 'thousand':137 'under-ag':79 'uyghur':83,140,168 've':9 'war':166 'weaker':33 'wherea':130 'world':61"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4961574"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701911034 {#2301
          date: 2023-12-07 02:03:54.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701152198 {#2302
          date: 2023-11-28 07:16:38.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172717
      }
      3 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2292
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2294 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: """
          Perhaps all the people who would downvote me have already blocked me ;-)\n
          \n
          But seriously, this is not whataboutism. It’s an appeal to recalibrate and come to senses, and most importantly, not dilute an important and serious concept like genocide. Even what happened/is happening in Ukraine is probably not a genocide even though I’m happily 100% against Russia.
          """
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701160257 {#2318
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2290 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2295 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2283 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2282 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2276 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2275 …}
        -id: 172916
        -bodyTs: "'100':57 'alreadi':10 'appeal':22 'block':11 'come':26 'concept':38 'dilut':33 'downvot':7 'even':41,52 'genocid':40,51 'happen':44 'happened/is':43 'happili':56 'import':31,35 'like':39 'm':55 'peopl':4 'perhap':1 'probabl':48 'recalibr':24 'russia':59 'sens':28 'serious':14,37 'though':53 'ukrain':46 'whatabout':18 'would':6"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963221"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701970930 {#2313
          date: 2023-12-07 18:42:10.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701160257 {#2316
          date: 2023-11-28 09:30:57.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172916
      }
      2 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2259
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2260 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "You looked at my reply to your comment and thought I was being serious?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 3
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161456 {#2237
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2244 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2250 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2245 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2243 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2255 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2251 …}
        -id: 172948
        -bodyTs: "'comment':8 'look':2 'repli':5 'serious':14 'thought':10"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963596"
        +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701937101 {#2249
          date: 2023-12-07 09:18:21.0 +01:00
        }
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161456 {#2258
          date: 2023-11-28 09:50:56.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172948
      }
      1 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2207
        +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
        +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2320 …2}
        +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
        +image: null
        +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2212 …}
        +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
        +body: "What if somebody bullies me at school and I genocide him a little bit?"
        +lang: "en"
        +isAdult: false
        +favouriteCount: 2
        +score: 0
        +lastActive: DateTime @1701161169 {#2210
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +ip: null
        +tags: null
        +mentions: [
          "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
          "@millie@beehaw.org"
          "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
          "@Stormyfemme@beehaw.org"
          "@streetfestival@lemmy.ca"
        ]
        +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2208 …}
        +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2204 …}
        +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2211 …}
        +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2266 …}
        +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2268 …}
        +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2273 …}
        -id: 172942
        -bodyTs: "'bit':14 'bulli':4 'genocid':10 'littl':13 'school':7 'somebodi':3"
        +ranking: 0
        +commentCount: 0
        +upVotes: 0
        +downVotes: 0
        +visibility: "visible             "
        +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4963537"
        +editedAt: null
        +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701161169 {#2203
          date: 2023-11-28 09:46:09.0 +01:00
        }
        +"title": 172942
      }
      0 => App\Entity\EntryComment {#2149}
    ]
    -id: 17703
    -titleTs: "'chao':8 'edit':9 'got':7 'hama':11 'multipolar':4 'palestinian':13 'repres':12 'want':2 'world':5"
    -bodyTs: "'-2016':2362 '/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':888 '/20th_century/hamas.asp)':590 '/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3053 '/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':429 '/en/node/1654370)':2436 '/events/president/news/72444)':2818 '/far-right':2354 '/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3005 '/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2054 '/jps/fulltext/214551)':577 '/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':463 '/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':96 '/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':626 '/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1561 '/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3187 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':31 '/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':34 '03.10.23':663 '119':693 '12':24 '1200':2269 '1967':3181 '1970s':3065 '1988':586 '2000':923 '2014':88,1611,1678,1787 '2017':579 '2023':26 '24':938 '3':472,692 '31':2439 '3g':1664 '4':1557,1702 '75':2601 'abstract':136 'academia':2219,3020 'accept':2753 'accord':423,2680 'accuraci':1482 'achiev':361,381,545 'across':1938 'act':355 'action':322,984,2419,2553 'activ':860,1027,1828,3078 'actual':735,2494,2979 'addit':1370,1464 'advoc':3207 'afd':2310 'afford':1659 'agenc':2693 'agenda':2216 'agent':2991 'aggress':2619,2630 'aim':15,422,547,646,896,2765 'air':1860 'al':1836 'align':2172 'all-out':565 'allow':1404,1925 'alongsid':1917,2205 'alreadi':1774 'also':1133,1671,2666 'altern':1742 'alumni':2470 'american':800 'ammunit':1208 'among':263 'amplif':2081 'anarch':2952 'anger':681 'angri':698 'annihil':2558 'anoth':922,2859 'answer':3028 'anti':61,275,582,595,782,2379,2394,2397,2401,2801,2914 'anti-enlighten':2913 'anti-human':2393 'anti-imperialist':274 'anti-r':2400 'anti-semit':60,594,781 'anti-univers':2396,2800 'anti-wok':2378 'anti-zion':581 'apartheid':2583 'apologis':279,2382 'appal':1454 'appli':618 'aqsa':1837 'arab':2185 'arafat':2677 'arm':161 'armi':1219 'around':221 'arrest':153 'articl':944 'ask':374,409 'aspect':2596,2648 'aspir':2877 'assad':3138 'assault':2055 'assert':2659 'assumpt':1713,2928 'asylum':1410 'atgm':1308 'attack':13,38,202,283,556,600,754,1466,1692,2461,2496,3151 'attempt':1134,1213,1418 'autocraci':1101 'avalon.law.yale.edu':589 'avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp)':588 'await':507 'azar':3271 'b':339 'back':436 'bank':767,1834,3291 'barbar':751 'base':866,1049,2139,3118,3203 'basi':313 'basic':2780 'battl':134 'beauti':2272 'bedraggl':2294 'began':2462 'behaviour':2772,3218 'beij':953 'believ':1359,1399 'bellifor':1968 'better':2096,2476,3124 'biden':187 'black':2671 'blame':2590,2625,2668 'bodi':964 'bomb':1639,1773 'bombard':1590 'border':1939 'brasil':1062 'breach':183 'break':1363 'breakthrough':2024 'bric':855,1973,2085 'brighton':2263 'broke':441 'brown':2286 'bug':1084 'busi':233 'bypass':2 'calcul':2498 'call':288,2546 'camp':3046,3067 'cannot':1374,1852 'care':1541,1764 'carri':2145 'case':353,2427 'casus':1967 'ceasefir':1648,1747 'celebr':2182 'cellphon':1669 'cement':1793 'central':2088 'chain':2000,2011 'chang':1778 'channel':1556,1701 'chant':2244 'chao':10,881,1075,3126 'characteris':914 'charter':2099 'cheer':3023 'child':1769 'children':1258 'chill':1555 'china':841,893,2069,2414 'citi':54,787 'civilian':292,612,1193,1330,1372,1429,1445,1546,1568,1696,2501,2698,3243 'civilis':2828,2830,2851,2865 'claim':199,1409,1688,3101 'cleans':968 'close':116,522,2794 'co':2840 'co-exist':2839 'cocktail':2391 'coexist':912 'collaps':1802 'collect':758,1473 'coloni':2384,2543 'colonialist':2721 'combat':162,805,1182,1246 'come':538,1312,2530,2535 'command':2002 'commit':1307 'common':2927 'communiti':169,1130,1519,2550 'compar':1779 'competit':952 'complet':811,1824 'complex':843 'concept':400,2125 'concess':1633 'conclud':389 'conclus':2581 'concret':130,2524 'condemn':182,2466 'condit':1781 'confer':470 'conflict':820,917,982,1788,2020,2035,2332 'conscript/reservist':1218 'consequ':1805 'conserv':2469 'consist':3098 'contain':2291 'content':2077 'context':327,836 'continu':1650,1663 'contrari':882 'converg':2922 'corral':2345 'corridor':1386 'could':543,1658,1839 'countri':1509 'cours':683,1849,2605 'coven':587 'cover':86 'creat':2073,3250 'creation':1378 'crime':2575 'crimin':2629 'crisi':46,1149,1198,1977 'crowd':2240 'cultur':1001,2873 'current':133,1148 'curriculum':2716 'damag':1479 'danger':1531,1812,2337 'dark':227 'dawn':1707 'day':2164,2536 'de':69 'de-escal':68 'death':1446 'debt':3090 'decolonis':2215,2714 'decomposit':861 'defeat':506,1807,2370 'defend':148 'deif':1686 'deliber':606 'deliv':2960 'delud':210 'demand':174,1523 'demo':2298 'democraci':832,851,1094,1935,2127,2948 'democrat':2367,2727 'demonstr':396,784,2196 'depict':1699 'depriv':1484 'depth':2060 'descent':1011 'desert':1269,1957 'design':557,978 'despit':571 'destabilis':845 'destroy':648,1158 'destruct':1848 'deterior':1761 'determin':3165 'determinist':2798 'develop':2962 'die':688,700,710,718,730,1238 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org':576 'digitalprojects.palestine-studies.org/jps/fulltext/214551)':575 'direct':2179,2608 'disdain':2930 'disgust':2508 'dismantl':1045 'disorganis':2135 'disrespect':259 'ditch':584 'divers':1203 'divis':823 'doesn':1993 'domin':2192 'doubl':1842 'doubt':1086,1175 'draw':789 'dress':225 'drone':1282 'earli':480 'easi':2920 'easili':1840 'east':446 'echo':2609 'econom':2961 'edward':3048 'eerili':1268 'effect':345,1345 'egypt':1388,1728 'either':336,1722,1792 'elder':2468 'electr':1488,1753 'elit':1057 'elsewher':1411 'emerg':1145,2348 'emphasis':193 'en.kremlin.ru':2817 'en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72444)':2816 'en.wikipedia.org':3186 'en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list_of_united_nations_resolutions_concerning_palestine#:~:text=resolution%20681)':3185 'encourag':521 'end':541,549,1262,1273 'endgam':1943,1962 'enemi':165,2057 'engag':158,2478 'english.khamenei.ir':462 'english.khamenei.ir/news/10146/the-usurper-zionist-regime-is-coming-to-an-end)':461 'enlighten':2915,2943 'enough':654 'enrag':748,1225 'entir':2449,3173 'environ':1338 'equal':2862 'equip':2365 'era':2046 'escal':70 'especi':262,3006 'establish':2837 'etc':1493 'ethic':2782 'ethnic':967,981,2836,2907 'ethno':1072,3257 'ethno-nationalist':1071,3256 'europ':1066 'evapor':1501 'even':2143 'event':2237 'everi':959,2015,2022,2595,2647 'everyth':2133,2639 'exampl':1680,1981,2811 'exclaim':686 'excus':2407 'exercis':1934 'exhort':1234 'exist':2568,2599,2651,2841 'existenti':1196 'expel':1726 'experi':1069,1162,1245 'expert':122,426 'explain':2153 'explanatori':669 'explicit':1053 'exploit':2021 'express':2869 'extens':1444 'extract':1630 'extrem':608,916 'fact':318 'fail':833,1121 'failur':812,2312 'fair':418 'fantasi':1947 'far':1099,1821,2352,3273 'far-left':2351 'far-right':1098,1820 'fascism':623 'fascist':631,2986 'fatah':1119,1681,2174 'fear':254,1718 'featur':1079 'feet':1451 'fight':773 'fighter':251 'fill':674,679 'firm':483,2540 'first':877,3031,3081,3100,3129 'fittest':2847 'five':2163 'flatten':1949 'flaunt':3235 'flaw':3121 'flee':1375 'flow':2579 'follow':1251 'food':1654 'forc':432,1883,1901,2150 'forcibl':1725 'foreign':1749 'form':603,1252 'formal':573,1380,2747 'format':2063 'frame':1124,1136 'frantic':1569 'friend':3284 'front':1287,1317 'full':1220 'function':1919 'fusion':2349 'gambl':495 'gaoler':1864 'gas':2245 'gave':474 'gaza':43,93,213,303,761,1164,1248,1424,1548,1565,1616,1929,1950,1976,3233,3287 'general':2171 'genocid':919,983,995,1003,1026,2418,2577 'geopolit':45,965 'get':1041 'give':1516 'global':19,899,3039 'go':847 'god':712 'goe':2004 'good':738 'got':9 'govern':492,527,1143,1823,2122,2958 'greec':2321 'group':2442,2908 'grudg':676 'hail':2265 'hama':11,36,109,156,201,211,297,354,366,368,433,542,636,742,1113,1159,1348,1538,1553,1690,1790,1869,2007,2183,2460,2573,2640,2696,2988,3037,3264 'hapless':2233 'happen':707,723,1029,1447,1543,1582,2156,2529 'harvard':2424,2440,2549 'hate':1552 'heartland':2038 'heck':1021 'help':714,1573 'hezbollah':764 'histori':2758 'historian':621 'hold':1421,1716,1853,2445 'homili':885 'hostag':152,2503 'hour':939,2457 'human':2129,2395,2827,2938 'humanist':2949 'hybrid':844 'hyper':2797 'hyper-determinist':2796 'i':1302 'ident':2893 'identifi':296 'ideolog':1974,2086,2193,2287,2372,2808 'idf':1276,1281,1327,1694,1875 'imag':2253 'imageri':2509 'imam':456 'immedi':392 'imperi':2040 'imperialist':276 'implic':2687 'implicit':2563 'imposs':1904 'incarn':2967 'incipi':2283 'incurs':1626 'individu':2901 'inevit':2708 'inferior':2857 'influenc':894,3058 'inform':2031,2045 'information-era':2044 'inhabit':1954 'insid':92,1564 'instal':1889 'instead':1480 'instil':2511 'institut':3113 'instruct':1349 'intend':743 'intent':2578 'intern':168,179,342,467,1047,1129,1518,1914,2104,2121,2935,3102,3195 'internationalist':2729 'intersect':2889 'interview':108 'intifada':2684 'iphon':2258 'iran':435,453,642 'ironi':3171 'irreconcil':2995,3045 'islam':468,487,639,2212 'isra':103,286,451,552,825,1093,1142,1236,1524,1736,1772,2270,2447,2570,2591,3148,3242 'israel':84,143,652,744,755,803,1150,1414,1500,1635,1816,2635,2664,2700,3286 'issu':2437 'jew':2247 'jewish':611 'join':770 'joint':2304 'joy':3237 'justic':350 'justifi':307 'karabakh':972 'keep':1866 'kfar':3270 'khale':2675 'khamenei':457,661,1232,3136 'kid':1576,3268 'kill':2499 'kind':1471 'knew':1617 'know':3109,3141 'konstantopoulou':2315 'kosovo':977 'kremlin':2613 'kudo':248 'languag':597 'larg':1217,1766 'last':188,2819 'latest':1980 'latter':1341 'launch':1415,1622 'law':160,180,197,340,343,2105,2936,3103,3196,3213 'lay':1301 'leader':455 'learn':2744 'leav':1353 'left':2230,2317,2353,2368,2730,2996,3017,3040 'left-w':2229 'leftism':2916 'legal':1530 'legitim':1520 'leila':2674 'let':137 'lethal':1337 'level':59,2898,2904 'liber':1497,2946,3083,3092 'licenc':3248 'life':1194,1432 'like':74,214,478,2126,2190,2987 'limit':798 'line':659,1288,1318,2533 'live':1733,1931 'logic':388,2481,2632,2663,2686,2748 'london':2202 'long':1107,1186 'long-term':1106,1185 'longer':1715,2112,2188 'look':73,358,668,872,2189 'loss':505,806,1191,1430 'lot':1024 'loyalti':1795 'mad':874 'made':466 'mafia':216 'make':334,530,1334,2025,2489,2706,2917,3096 'manag':818 'mani':1390,1549,2850,3014 'map':2805 'mark':1777 'marx':2755 'marxism':2950 'mason':23 'mass':966,2328,2340,3025 'massacr':1723 'massiv':560,1190,1428 'matter':716,1995 'maxim':2051 'may':1744 'mean':2386 'meanwhil':804 'media':2074,2080,3010 'mediat':1651,1915 'medic':1572,1750,1763 'medium':933 'medium.com':28,30 'medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got':29 'mention':2491 'middl':445,1265 'might':415,734,2749,2773,2784 'milit':768 'militari':1016,1154,1188 'militaris':2018 'million':1855 'mind':1585,3253 'minor':1505 'miscalcul':1533,1537,1814 'miss':1825,2325 'mistak':532 'mixtur':240,2210 'mobilis':1223 'modern':2966 'modus':1366 'moham':1685 'money':2076 'month':1588 'moscow':955,2005 'most':2290 'move':1393,2176 'movement':105,2167,2673 'mronline.org':887 'mronline.org/2021/10/28/is-a-multipolar-world-the-answer-to-u-s-imperialism/)':886 'much':2999 'mujahedeen':1290 'multilater':3201 'multipolar':6,879,902,1081,1986,2093,3209 'murder':2267,2697,3026,3240 'muslim':1504 'must':2832 'myanmar':1007 'nagorno':971 'nagorno-karabakh':970 'nakba':2654 'nation':82,2186,3192 'nationalist':266,1073,2318,3258 'nato':2618 'necessari':1527 'need':195,294,1178,1912,2790,3219,3244 'negoti':376 'neighbourhood':222 'netanyahu':814,1087,1818,1941 'network':895,2071 'never':1402 'new':52 'news':1558,1703 'next':937 'night':189,1304 'nobodi':2975 'non':2567 'non-exist':2566 'none':1580,2853 'norm':3215 'normal':497 'normalis':2124 'noth':2760 'number':1767 'numer':425 'nyc':2204,2251 'nymag.com':3004 'nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/10/a-left-that-refuses-to-condemn-mass-murder-is-doomed.html),':3003 'object':383,393,869,1155 'obvious':142 'occup':1189,1882 'occupi':1737 'oct':25 'octob':473 'offer':370,2733 'often':653 'oligarch':1097 'one':909,1261,2588,3066 'ongo':2557 'onto':2806 'open':960,1068,1859 'oper':114,219,846,1183 'operandi':1367 'opportun':2016 'opposit':363 'oppress':208,331,2769 'option':1731 'order':20,305,867,1048,1628,1867,2140,3119,3204 'oslo':2679 'outburst':55 'outcom':1908 'outlet':2075 'overt':2181 'pa':1891 'pacifi':1423 'palestin':2521 'palestinian':81,300,1329,1545,1567,2165,2560,2598,2650,2690,2703,3158,3174 'panic':1698 'paradox':271 'paralys':448 'part':1064 'parti':2319 'pass':3188 'past':2162,2275 'pathet':2301 'pattern':1607 'paul':22 'paulmasonnews.medium.com':33 'paulmasonnews.medium.com/you-wanted-a-multipolar-world-you-got-chaos-5b8f3ea48e09)':32 'paywal':1 'peac':104,911,1916,1933 'peopl':198,231,999,1397,1600,1614,1667,1710,1717,1856,1927,2388,2710,2762,2880,2892,3149,3159,3231 'peril':3223 'period':2360 'perman':1881 'phenomenon':2227 'pioneer':620 'place':237,324 'play':1115,1259 'pleas':946 'plus':2213 'pogromist':404 'point':78,829,1643 'polit':822,1074,2149,2355,2894 'politician':2232 'pop':1294 'popul':270,301,1373,1492,1798 'possibl':1170 'post':2361,3061 'post-structur':3060 'postmodernist':2218 'power':440 'power-brok':439 'practic':1991 'preach':2886 'premis':2564,2722 'present':2809 'presid':186 'presum':2711 'pretti':2486,2919 'pri':229 'principl':2783 'prison':1861 'pro':892,2068,2612 'pro-china':891,2067 'pro-kremlin':2611 'problem':2984 'process':442 'progress':2142,2993 'project':856,1090,1110,1988,3175 'prompt':777 'proof':398 'proof-of-concept':397 'propaganda':2614 'proport':175,1528 'prosecut':155,1468 'prospect':1457 'provis':245 'provoc':975 'proxi':2070,2422 'public':243 'publish':927 'punish':759,1474 'purpos':1044 'pursu':858,2763 'pursuit':347,949 'push':1952,2034 'putin':2813,2822,2885,3135 'quagmir':795 'qualit':1460 'quick':71 'quot':1684 'quran':685 'radicalis':1512 'rage':691,703,721,733,1241 'rais':821,2895 'ralli':2302 'rapid':1760,3042 'rapproch':452,553 'ration':2402 're':1476,2224 'reactionari':2148 'read':941 'realiti':2704 'reason':1357,3079 'recent':1222 'recognis':3050,3088 'red':2285 'red-brown':2284 'refer':2515,2525,2777 'refuge':1197 'regard':726 'regardless':2766 'regim':502,515,536,729,2448,2584 'region':125,447,564,794,1970 'regular':1647 'relat':498 'reli':3182 'rememb':1231,1609,1672 'replac':1092 'report':1562 'repres':2866 'republ':488,640 'repudi':2940,3082 'requir':2538 'rescu':150 'resist':1620 'resolut':3184 'resourc':1210 'respect':177 'respons':1126,1138,1525,2450,2637 'restraint':176 'retali':2544 'retribut':290,561,808 'retrospect':667 'return':1406 'reveng':1946 'rhetor':986 'ridicul':2658 'right':146,172,191,287,696,1100,1448,1521,1822,2115,2130,2939,3161,3274 'rightw':3255 'risk':562,1536 'rocket':1623 'rohingya':1005 'root':2834 'rout':1382,2405,2740 'rule':212,617,865,1017,1054,2138,3117,3202 'rules-bas':864,2137,3116 'run':235 'russia':839,988,1059,2412,2627 'russian':2065 'russian/chinese':1985 'safe':1381 'sahel':1009 'said':3069 'sara':2306 'saudi':450,551 'saudi-isra':449,550 'say':687,1167,2443,2756 'scorn':2933 'scrape':957 'search':1570,3001 'second':2776,3087,3108,3140 'section':267 'secular':264 'see':1477,2225,2292,2985 'seen':111,1443,2199 'seiz':1420,2014 'self':1847,3164 'self-destruct':1846 'self-determin':3163 'semit':62,596,783 'send':1898 'septemb':2672 'serbian':974 'servic':244 'set':359 'sever':1593 'sham':3106 'share':2781 'shelter':1346 'shock':1105,2720 'short':1032,3198 'shot':1299 'show':1566,1775,1909 'side':1535,3133 'sight':878 'signal':1152,1665 'signatori':2735 'signific':1417 'simpl':2487 'simpli':2516 'simultan':3153 'sinai':1200 'sinc':2652,2863,3180 'singl':2826 'site':934 'situat':511,519,2519 'slaughter':609 'sniper':1298 'social':349,2079,2947 'societi':826,3262 'soldier':1226 'solidar':2166,3280 'solut':1923 'someon':1434 'someth':1459 'soul':3000 'sound':477 'south':900,1383 'space':1033,2032 'speaker':2264 'speech':460,664 'spent':2358 'split':3043 'squar':16 'stabilis':1900 'stabl':1141 'stage':1625,1784,2303 'stalin':2969,2980 'stand':2541,3145,3154 'start':139,2752 'state':217,377,644,650,1922,2410,3178,3217 'stateless':1396 'statement':2425,2433,2484,2738 'sternhel':615 'stoke':1829 'stop':1644,2295,2555 'strateg':76 'strategi':816 'street':58,100,1256 'street-level':57 'strip':1603 'structur':2119,2594,2646,2702,2770,3062 'student':2441 'studi':2428,2978 'subscrib':947 'sudden':2175 'suffer':504 'suggest':1704 'suit':228 'summari':419,739 'superior':2855 'suppli':1207 'support':801,1801 'surpris':2973 'surviv':1103,2844 'sustain':1180 'swastika':2255 'sydney':50,2201,2243 'symbol':2028 'sympathi':1498 'sympathis':1682 'system':951,2082,2100 'tactic':1632 'take':323,601,630,1249,1297,2504,2552 'task':2724 'taught':627 'teach':2387 'team':1751 'tehran':2006 'tenet':2089 'tension':1830 'term':1108,1187 'territori':1597 'terror':12,37,242,282,357,405,1014,2184,2512 'terrorist':2495 'test':796 'theolog':3072 'thing':930,2623 'think':2473 'third':2787 'thompson':3049 'though':118,3111 'thought':1606 'thought-pattern':1605 'thoughtless':3022 'threat':1827 'throughout':2058 'throw':128 'thus':670,2945 'time':1035,1324 'titl':2514 'today':509,3002,3127 'toler':1112 'totalitarian':2409,2957 'tradit':2874,3076 'travel':1937 'treati':1051,3212 'tri':277,2363 'trigger':40,559,762,980 'truce':372 'tukachevski':2049 'tunnel':1293 'turn':77,574,776,904,2234,2341,2911 'two':1854,1921,2276,2683,2994 'two-stat':1920 'twos':224 'typic':1242 'uighur':998 'ukrain':993,1212,2280,2616,3033 'ultim':1850,3170 'un':1894 'unchart':1596 'understand':2013,2792,3221,3246 'unexpect':2023 'unfold':2454 'uniqu':2868 'unit':3191 'uniti':469 'univers':2102,2398,2802,2932,3085,3097 'unleash':756 'unless':66 'unpreced':757 'unstopp':403 'urban':1181 'us':628,1206,3009 'us-suppli':1205 'usa':791,1061 'use':1469,2117,2506,2746 'usurp':534 'valdai':2815 've':107,2198,2357 'vehem':1674 'vehicl':1311 'version':2047 'victim':1770,2571 'view':484,1314,2804,2925 'violenc':205,308,2027,2455,2592,2644 'violent':321,593 'wagenknecht':2307 'walk':220 'want':4,367,3094,3275 'war':41,89,568,991,1441,1971,2281,2297,2574 'warlord':1013 'warn':481 'wasteland':1738 'water':1486,1755 'wave':779,2252 'way':2883 'weaponis':2029 'wed':2712 'week':2820 'west':65,766,1833,2110,2159,3290 'western':273,786,850,1508 'whatsoev':2694 'whether':1996 'whole':929,943,1491 'wider':330,421 'widespread':258 'wing':2231 'without':1376,1862,3211 'woke':2380 'word':634,924 'work':1989 'world':7,903,1987,2094,2803,3210,3226 'wors':1461 'worship':2954 'worth':1230 'would':1166,1594,1640,1683,3055,3227 'wound':961 'write':1758 'www.armyupress.army.mil':2053 'www.armyupress.army.mil/journals/military-review/english-edition-archives/november-december-2018/blythe-operational-art/):':2052 'www.channel4.com':95 'www.channel4.com/news/by/paul-mason/blogs/brit-gaza-fault-line-heard-lot)':94 'www.haaretz.com':625 'www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2020-06-22/ty-article-opinion/zeev-sternhell-the-oracle-of-anti-fascism/0000017f-f4ec-d460-afff-ffeeb27a0000)':624 'www.marxists.org':3052 'www.marxists.org/archive/thompson-ep/1978/pot/essay.htm)':3051 'www.palestine-studies.org':2435 'www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1654370)':2434 'www.wilsoncenter.org':428 'www.wilsoncenter.org/article/hamas-and-israel-irans-role#:~:text=the%20iranian%20role%20in%20the,by%20training%20is%20well%20known.),':427 'www.youtube.com':1560 'www.youtube.com/watch?v=peunrangqr8)':1559 'yasser':2676 'year':2277,2602 'york':53 'zeev':614 'zionism':583 'zionist':501,514,535,672,728 'zoe':2314"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701236300
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://beehaw.org/post/9914541"
    +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701964772 {#2932
      date: 2023-12-07 16:59:32.0 +01:00
    }
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701149900 {#2914
      date: 2023-11-28 06:38:20.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2146 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2315 …}
  +body: """
    > Pol Pot pretended to be a communist, until it no longer suited him and he had them killed.\n
    \n
    He was the leader of the Communist Party of Kampuchea from 1963-1981, at which point it was rebranded as the Party of Democratic Kampuchea, which he lead until 1985. Also that new party was communist. The Cambodian genocide was roughly 1975-1979.\n
    \n
    Are you just defining people who are absolutely horrible not communists even though they call themselves communist, are allied with other governments who call themselves communist, and execute similar policies as them? I mean I get the impulse, I also get plenty of negative feelings when I think about pro-free market, pro-freedom politicians who commit atrocities or say stupid shit and would rather that those people don’t exist. Sadly, real world doesn’t always like us.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 1
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701178274 {#2152
    date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sqgl@beehaw.org"
    "@millie@beehaw.org"
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@iain@feddit.nl"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2185 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2179 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2182 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2172 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2173 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2175 …}
  -id: 173517
  -bodyTs: "'-1979':61 '-1981':31 '1963':30 '1975':60 '1985':48 'absolut':69 'alli':80 'also':49,101 'alway':140 'atroc':121 'call':76,85 'cambodian':56 'commit':120 'communist':7,25,54,72,78,87 'defin':65 'democrat':42 'doesn':138 'even':73 'execut':89 'exist':134 'feel':106 'free':113 'freedom':117 'genocid':57 'get':97,102 'govern':83 'horribl':70 'impuls':99 'kampuchea':28,43 'kill':18 'lead':46 'leader':22 'like':141 'longer':11 'market':114 'mean':95 'negat':105 'new':51 'parti':26,40,52 'peopl':66,131 'plenti':103 'point':34 'pol':1 'polici':91 'politician':118 'pot':2 'pretend':3 'pro':112,116 'pro-fre':111 'pro-freedom':115 'rather':128 'real':136 'rebrand':37 'rough':59 'sad':135 'say':123 'shit':125 'similar':90 'stupid':124 'suit':12 'think':109 'though':74 'us':142 'world':137 'would':127"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4967368"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701957652 {#2153
    date: 2023-12-07 15:00:52.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701178274 {#2148
    date: 2023-11-28 14:31:14.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 173517
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
113 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
114 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2929 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2970 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "Aaaaaand-it-s-over"
  +title: "Aaaaaand it's over"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e63ccb9c-3c65-466a-8b6f-03df91dd19a9.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 309
  +favouriteCount: 1529
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701039409 {#2965
    date: 2023-11-26 23:56:49.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2973 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2975 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2977 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2979 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2981 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2983 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2023 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2030 …}
      +body: "Believe it or not, straight to jail."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 23
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699605481 {#1363
        date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Stamets@lemmy.world"
        "@Arfman@aussie.zone"
        "@Lifter@discuss.tchncs.de"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2032 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2024 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2018 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2011 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2021 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2029 …}
      -id: 106999
      -bodyTs: "'believ':1 'jail':7 'straight':5"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4462138"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699605481 {#1361
        date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 106999
    }
  ]
  -id: 11500
  -titleTs: "'aaaaaand':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699635330
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8023192"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699548930 {#2952
    date: 2023-11-09 17:55:30.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
115 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2929 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2970 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "Aaaaaand-it-s-over"
  +title: "Aaaaaand it's over"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e63ccb9c-3c65-466a-8b6f-03df91dd19a9.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 309
  +favouriteCount: 1529
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701039409 {#2965
    date: 2023-11-26 23:56:49.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2973 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2975 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2977 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2979 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2981 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2983 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2023 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2030 …}
      +body: "Believe it or not, straight to jail."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 23
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699605481 {#1363
        date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Stamets@lemmy.world"
        "@Arfman@aussie.zone"
        "@Lifter@discuss.tchncs.de"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2032 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2024 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2018 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2011 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2021 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2029 …}
      -id: 106999
      -bodyTs: "'believ':1 'jail':7 'straight':5"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4462138"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699605481 {#1361
        date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 106999
    }
  ]
  -id: 11500
  -titleTs: "'aaaaaand':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699635330
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8023192"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699548930 {#2952
    date: 2023-11-09 17:55:30.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
116 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2929 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2970 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
  +slug: "Aaaaaand-it-s-over"
  +title: "Aaaaaand it's over"
  +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e63ccb9c-3c65-466a-8b6f-03df91dd19a9.jpeg"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 309
  +favouriteCount: 1529
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701039409 {#2965
    date: 2023-11-26 23:56:49.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2973 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2975 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2977 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2979 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2981 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2983 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2023 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2030 …}
      +body: "Believe it or not, straight to jail."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 23
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1699605481 {#1363
        date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Stamets@lemmy.world"
        "@Arfman@aussie.zone"
        "@Lifter@discuss.tchncs.de"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2032 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2024 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2018 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2011 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2021 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2029 …}
      -id: 106999
      -bodyTs: "'believ':1 'jail':7 'straight':5"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4462138"
      +editedAt: null
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699605481 {#1361
        date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 106999
    }
  ]
  -id: 11500
  -titleTs: "'aaaaaand':1"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1699635330
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8023192"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699548930 {#2952
    date: 2023-11-09 17:55:30.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
117 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
118 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2929 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2970 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "Aaaaaand-it-s-over"
    +title: "Aaaaaand it's over"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e63ccb9c-3c65-466a-8b6f-03df91dd19a9.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 309
    +favouriteCount: 1529
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701039409 {#2965
      date: 2023-11-26 23:56:49.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2973 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2975 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2977 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2979 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2981 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2983 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362}
    ]
    -id: 11500
    -titleTs: "'aaaaaand':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699635330
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8023192"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699548930 {#2952
      date: 2023-11-09 17:55:30.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2023 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2030 …}
  +body: "Believe it or not, straight to jail."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 23
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699605481 {#1363
    date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Stamets@lemmy.world"
    "@Arfman@aussie.zone"
    "@Lifter@discuss.tchncs.de"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2032 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2024 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2018 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2011 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2021 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2029 …}
  -id: 106999
  -bodyTs: "'believ':1 'jail':7 'straight':5"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4462138"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699605481 {#1361
    date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 106999
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
119 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2929 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2970 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "Aaaaaand-it-s-over"
    +title: "Aaaaaand it's over"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e63ccb9c-3c65-466a-8b6f-03df91dd19a9.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 309
    +favouriteCount: 1529
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701039409 {#2965
      date: 2023-11-26 23:56:49.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2973 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2975 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2977 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2979 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2981 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2983 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362}
    ]
    -id: 11500
    -titleTs: "'aaaaaand':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699635330
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8023192"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699548930 {#2952
      date: 2023-11-09 17:55:30.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2023 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2030 …}
  +body: "Believe it or not, straight to jail."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 23
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699605481 {#1363
    date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Stamets@lemmy.world"
    "@Arfman@aussie.zone"
    "@Lifter@discuss.tchncs.de"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2032 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2024 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2018 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2011 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2021 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2029 …}
  -id: 106999
  -bodyTs: "'believ':1 'jail':7 'straight':5"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4462138"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699605481 {#1361
    date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 106999
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
120 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#1403
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2929 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2970 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2972 …}
    +slug: "Aaaaaand-it-s-over"
    +title: "Aaaaaand it's over"
    +url: "https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/e63ccb9c-3c65-466a-8b6f-03df91dd19a9.jpeg"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 309
    +favouriteCount: 1529
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701039409 {#2965
      date: 2023-11-26 23:56:49.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2973 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2975 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2977 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2979 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2981 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2983 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#1362}
    ]
    -id: 11500
    -titleTs: "'aaaaaand':1"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1699635330
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemmy.world/post/8023192"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699548930 {#2952
      date: 2023-11-09 17:55:30.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2019 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2023 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2030 …}
  +body: "Believe it or not, straight to jail."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 23
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1699605481 {#1363
    date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Stamets@lemmy.world"
    "@Arfman@aussie.zone"
    "@Lifter@discuss.tchncs.de"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2032 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2024 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2018 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2011 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2021 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2029 …}
  -id: 106999
  -bodyTs: "'believ':1 'jail':7 'straight':5"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4462138"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1699605481 {#1361
    date: 2023-11-10 09:38:01.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 106999
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
121 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
122 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2775 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2931 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2933 …}
  +slug: "A-repost-from-r-linuxmemes-Because-I-saw-the-original-comic"
  +title: "A repost from r/linuxmemes - Because I saw the original comic"
  +url: "https://thelemmy.club/pictrs/image/2be05e7d-01c3-423d-84de-75e91c740f6e.png"
  +body: """
    *Luigi (with Linux Mint logo) and Mario (Ubuntu logo) come in*\n
    \n
    Mother: It’s-a the Ubuntu Bros!\n
    \n
    Linux Mint (Luigi): Mama why-a you never remember my name?\n
    \n
    Mother: I’m-a sorry Green Ubuntu
    """
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 134
  +favouriteCount: 1466
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701540175 {#2926
    date: 2023-12-02 19:02:55.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2934 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2936 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2938 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2940 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2942 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2944 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
      +body: """
        > Why does anybody use ubuntu etc when they could use debian?\n
        \n
        Debian is good, but people working on polishing a thing from 9 to 5, 5 days a week can do a lot.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 6
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700988966 {#2116
        date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Octopus1348@thelemmy.club"
        "@cameron_vale@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2044 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2127 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2043 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2215 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2198 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2227 …}
      -id: 165419
      -bodyTs: "'5':25,26 '9':23 'anybodi':3 'could':9 'day':27 'debian':11,12 'etc':6 'good':14 'lot':33 'peopl':16 'polish':19 'thing':21 'ubuntu':5 'use':4,10 'week':29 'work':17"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4910575"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701643033 {#2120
        date: 2023-12-03 23:37:13.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700988966 {#2161
        date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 165419
    }
  ]
  -id: 16703
  -titleTs: "'comic':10 'origin':9 'r/linuxmemes':4 'repost':2 'saw':7"
  -bodyTs: "'bros':19 'come':10 'green':38 'linux':3,20 'logo':5,9 'luigi':1,22 'm':35 'm-a':34 'mama':23 'mario':7 'mint':4,21 'mother':12,32 'name':31 'never':28 'rememb':29 's-a':14 'sorri':37 'ubuntu':8,18,39 'why-a':24"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701013878
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://thelemmy.club/post/5307159"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700927478 {#2920
    date: 2023-11-25 16:51:18.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
123 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2775 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2931 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2933 …}
  +slug: "A-repost-from-r-linuxmemes-Because-I-saw-the-original-comic"
  +title: "A repost from r/linuxmemes - Because I saw the original comic"
  +url: "https://thelemmy.club/pictrs/image/2be05e7d-01c3-423d-84de-75e91c740f6e.png"
  +body: """
    *Luigi (with Linux Mint logo) and Mario (Ubuntu logo) come in*\n
    \n
    Mother: It’s-a the Ubuntu Bros!\n
    \n
    Linux Mint (Luigi): Mama why-a you never remember my name?\n
    \n
    Mother: I’m-a sorry Green Ubuntu
    """
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 134
  +favouriteCount: 1466
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701540175 {#2926
    date: 2023-12-02 19:02:55.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2934 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2936 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2938 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2940 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2942 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2944 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
      +body: """
        > Why does anybody use ubuntu etc when they could use debian?\n
        \n
        Debian is good, but people working on polishing a thing from 9 to 5, 5 days a week can do a lot.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 6
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700988966 {#2116
        date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Octopus1348@thelemmy.club"
        "@cameron_vale@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2044 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2127 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2043 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2215 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2198 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2227 …}
      -id: 165419
      -bodyTs: "'5':25,26 '9':23 'anybodi':3 'could':9 'day':27 'debian':11,12 'etc':6 'good':14 'lot':33 'peopl':16 'polish':19 'thing':21 'ubuntu':5 'use':4,10 'week':29 'work':17"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4910575"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701643033 {#2120
        date: 2023-12-03 23:37:13.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700988966 {#2161
        date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 165419
    }
  ]
  -id: 16703
  -titleTs: "'comic':10 'origin':9 'r/linuxmemes':4 'repost':2 'saw':7"
  -bodyTs: "'bros':19 'come':10 'green':38 'linux':3,20 'logo':5,9 'luigi':1,22 'm':35 'm-a':34 'mama':23 'mario':7 'mint':4,21 'mother':12,32 'name':31 'never':28 'rememb':29 's-a':14 'sorri':37 'ubuntu':8,18,39 'why-a':24"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701013878
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://thelemmy.club/post/5307159"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700927478 {#2920
    date: 2023-11-25 16:51:18.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
124 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2775 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2931 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2933 …}
  +slug: "A-repost-from-r-linuxmemes-Because-I-saw-the-original-comic"
  +title: "A repost from r/linuxmemes - Because I saw the original comic"
  +url: "https://thelemmy.club/pictrs/image/2be05e7d-01c3-423d-84de-75e91c740f6e.png"
  +body: """
    *Luigi (with Linux Mint logo) and Mario (Ubuntu logo) come in*\n
    \n
    Mother: It’s-a the Ubuntu Bros!\n
    \n
    Linux Mint (Luigi): Mama why-a you never remember my name?\n
    \n
    Mother: I’m-a sorry Green Ubuntu
    """
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 134
  +favouriteCount: 1466
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701540175 {#2926
    date: 2023-12-02 19:02:55.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2934 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2936 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2938 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2940 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2942 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2944 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
      +body: """
        > Why does anybody use ubuntu etc when they could use debian?\n
        \n
        Debian is good, but people working on polishing a thing from 9 to 5, 5 days a week can do a lot.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 6
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700988966 {#2116
        date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@Octopus1348@thelemmy.club"
        "@cameron_vale@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2044 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2127 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2043 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2215 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2198 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2227 …}
      -id: 165419
      -bodyTs: "'5':25,26 '9':23 'anybodi':3 'could':9 'day':27 'debian':11,12 'etc':6 'good':14 'lot':33 'peopl':16 'polish':19 'thing':21 'ubuntu':5 'use':4,10 'week':29 'work':17"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4910575"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701643033 {#2120
        date: 2023-12-03 23:37:13.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700988966 {#2161
        date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 165419
    }
  ]
  -id: 16703
  -titleTs: "'comic':10 'origin':9 'r/linuxmemes':4 'repost':2 'saw':7"
  -bodyTs: "'bros':19 'come':10 'green':38 'linux':3,20 'logo':5,9 'luigi':1,22 'm':35 'm-a':34 'mama':23 'mario':7 'mint':4,21 'mother':12,32 'name':31 'never':28 'rememb':29 's-a':14 'sorri':37 'ubuntu':8,18,39 'why-a':24"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701013878
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://thelemmy.club/post/5307159"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700927478 {#2920
    date: 2023-11-25 16:51:18.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
125 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
126 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2775 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2931 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2933 …}
    +slug: "A-repost-from-r-linuxmemes-Because-I-saw-the-original-comic"
    +title: "A repost from r/linuxmemes - Because I saw the original comic"
    +url: "https://thelemmy.club/pictrs/image/2be05e7d-01c3-423d-84de-75e91c740f6e.png"
    +body: """
      *Luigi (with Linux Mint logo) and Mario (Ubuntu logo) come in*\n
      \n
      Mother: It’s-a the Ubuntu Bros!\n
      \n
      Linux Mint (Luigi): Mama why-a you never remember my name?\n
      \n
      Mother: I’m-a sorry Green Ubuntu
      """
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 134
    +favouriteCount: 1466
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701540175 {#2926
      date: 2023-12-02 19:02:55.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2934 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2936 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2938 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2940 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2942 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2944 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160}
    ]
    -id: 16703
    -titleTs: "'comic':10 'origin':9 'r/linuxmemes':4 'repost':2 'saw':7"
    -bodyTs: "'bros':19 'come':10 'green':38 'linux':3,20 'logo':5,9 'luigi':1,22 'm':35 'm-a':34 'mama':23 'mario':7 'mint':4,21 'mother':12,32 'name':31 'never':28 'rememb':29 's-a':14 'sorri':37 'ubuntu':8,18,39 'why-a':24"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701013878
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://thelemmy.club/post/5307159"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700927478 {#2920
      date: 2023-11-25 16:51:18.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
  +body: """
    > Why does anybody use ubuntu etc when they could use debian?\n
    \n
    Debian is good, but people working on polishing a thing from 9 to 5, 5 days a week can do a lot.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 6
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700988966 {#2116
    date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Octopus1348@thelemmy.club"
    "@cameron_vale@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2044 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2127 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2043 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2215 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2198 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2227 …}
  -id: 165419
  -bodyTs: "'5':25,26 '9':23 'anybodi':3 'could':9 'day':27 'debian':11,12 'etc':6 'good':14 'lot':33 'peopl':16 'polish':19 'thing':21 'ubuntu':5 'use':4,10 'week':29 'work':17"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4910575"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701643033 {#2120
    date: 2023-12-03 23:37:13.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700988966 {#2161
    date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 165419
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
127 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2775 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2931 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2933 …}
    +slug: "A-repost-from-r-linuxmemes-Because-I-saw-the-original-comic"
    +title: "A repost from r/linuxmemes - Because I saw the original comic"
    +url: "https://thelemmy.club/pictrs/image/2be05e7d-01c3-423d-84de-75e91c740f6e.png"
    +body: """
      *Luigi (with Linux Mint logo) and Mario (Ubuntu logo) come in*\n
      \n
      Mother: It’s-a the Ubuntu Bros!\n
      \n
      Linux Mint (Luigi): Mama why-a you never remember my name?\n
      \n
      Mother: I’m-a sorry Green Ubuntu
      """
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 134
    +favouriteCount: 1466
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701540175 {#2926
      date: 2023-12-02 19:02:55.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2934 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2936 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2938 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2940 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2942 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2944 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160}
    ]
    -id: 16703
    -titleTs: "'comic':10 'origin':9 'r/linuxmemes':4 'repost':2 'saw':7"
    -bodyTs: "'bros':19 'come':10 'green':38 'linux':3,20 'logo':5,9 'luigi':1,22 'm':35 'm-a':34 'mama':23 'mario':7 'mint':4,21 'mother':12,32 'name':31 'never':28 'rememb':29 's-a':14 'sorri':37 'ubuntu':8,18,39 'why-a':24"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701013878
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://thelemmy.club/post/5307159"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700927478 {#2920
      date: 2023-11-25 16:51:18.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
  +body: """
    > Why does anybody use ubuntu etc when they could use debian?\n
    \n
    Debian is good, but people working on polishing a thing from 9 to 5, 5 days a week can do a lot.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 6
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700988966 {#2116
    date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Octopus1348@thelemmy.club"
    "@cameron_vale@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2044 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2127 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2043 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2215 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2198 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2227 …}
  -id: 165419
  -bodyTs: "'5':25,26 '9':23 'anybodi':3 'could':9 'day':27 'debian':11,12 'etc':6 'good':14 'lot':33 'peopl':16 'polish':19 'thing':21 'ubuntu':5 'use':4,10 'week':29 'work':17"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4910575"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701643033 {#2120
    date: 2023-12-03 23:37:13.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700988966 {#2161
    date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 165419
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
128 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2163
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2775 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2931 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2933 …}
    +slug: "A-repost-from-r-linuxmemes-Because-I-saw-the-original-comic"
    +title: "A repost from r/linuxmemes - Because I saw the original comic"
    +url: "https://thelemmy.club/pictrs/image/2be05e7d-01c3-423d-84de-75e91c740f6e.png"
    +body: """
      *Luigi (with Linux Mint logo) and Mario (Ubuntu logo) come in*\n
      \n
      Mother: It’s-a the Ubuntu Bros!\n
      \n
      Linux Mint (Luigi): Mama why-a you never remember my name?\n
      \n
      Mother: I’m-a sorry Green Ubuntu
      """
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 134
    +favouriteCount: 1466
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701540175 {#2926
      date: 2023-12-02 19:02:55.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2934 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2936 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2938 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2940 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2942 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2944 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2160}
    ]
    -id: 16703
    -titleTs: "'comic':10 'origin':9 'r/linuxmemes':4 'repost':2 'saw':7"
    -bodyTs: "'bros':19 'come':10 'green':38 'linux':3,20 'logo':5,9 'luigi':1,22 'm':35 'm-a':34 'mama':23 'mario':7 'mint':4,21 'mother':12,32 'name':31 'never':28 'rememb':29 's-a':14 'sorri':37 'ubuntu':8,18,39 'why-a':24"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1701013878
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://thelemmy.club/post/5307159"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700927478 {#2920
      date: 2023-11-25 16:51:18.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#2036 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2162 …}
  +body: """
    > Why does anybody use ubuntu etc when they could use debian?\n
    \n
    Debian is good, but people working on polishing a thing from 9 to 5, 5 days a week can do a lot.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 6
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700988966 {#2116
    date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@Octopus1348@thelemmy.club"
    "@cameron_vale@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2044 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2127 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2043 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2215 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2198 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2227 …}
  -id: 165419
  -bodyTs: "'5':25,26 '9':23 'anybodi':3 'could':9 'day':27 'debian':11,12 'etc':6 'good':14 'lot':33 'peopl':16 'polish':19 'thing':21 'ubuntu':5 'use':4,10 'week':29 'work':17"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4910575"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701643033 {#2120
    date: 2023-12-03 23:37:13.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700988966 {#2161
    date: 2023-11-26 09:56:06.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 165419
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
129 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
130 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2915 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2916 …}
  +slug: "Last-Word-by-J-L-Westover"
  +title: ""Last Word" by J.L Westover"
  +url: "https://telegra.ph/file/3a0eb99f95a669766b027.jpg"
  +body: "- Source: [Tapas](https://m.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(Secret Panel) - [RSS](https://tapas.io/rss/series/3346)"
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 153
  +favouriteCount: 1105
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701016987 {#1996
    date: 2023-11-26 17:43:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2919 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2913 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2910 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2908 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2922 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2924 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: """
        I was kinda worried for a while that since **kids** **these** **days** don’t really have music as a tool to rebel against their parents, and as for shocking via clothing or something like goth or satanism… they’re just recycling 80s and 90s all over again. So how are they gonna do it?\n
        \n
        Not so worried anymore. They always find something. And not just from language. The ways to be fucking idiots are endless and as a really novel thing, **kids** **these** **days** go up to 30 year olds.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 14
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701516525 {#2102
        date: 2023-12-02 12:28:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sag@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2107 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2124 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2118 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2121 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2115 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2123 …}
      -id: 157778
      -bodyTs: "'30':88 '80s':42 '90s':44 'alway':60 'anymor':58 'cloth':31 'day':12,84 'endless':75 'find':61 'fuck':72 'go':85 'gonna':52 'goth':35 'idiot':73 'kid':10,82 'kinda':3 'languag':67 'like':34 'music':17 'novel':80 'old':90 'parent':25 're':39 'realli':15,79 'rebel':22 'recycl':41 'satan':37 'shock':29 'sinc':9 'someth':33,62 'thing':81 'tool':20 'via':30 'way':69 'worri':4,57 'year':89"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4860125"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701336259 {#2109
        date: 2023-11-30 10:24:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700815219 {#2103
        date: 2023-11-24 09:40:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 157778
    }
  ]
  -id: 15926
  -titleTs: "'j.l':4 'last':1 'westov':5 'word':2"
  -bodyTs: "'/episode/3016236)(secret':5 '/rss/series/3346)':10 'm.tapas.io':4 'm.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(secret':3 'panel':6 'rss':7 'sourc':1 'tapa':2 'tapas.io':9 'tapas.io/rss/series/3346)':8"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700834979
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15822355"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700748579 {#2851
    date: 2023-11-23 15:09:39.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
131 DENIED edit 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2915 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2916 …}
  +slug: "Last-Word-by-J-L-Westover"
  +title: ""Last Word" by J.L Westover"
  +url: "https://telegra.ph/file/3a0eb99f95a669766b027.jpg"
  +body: "- Source: [Tapas](https://m.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(Secret Panel) - [RSS](https://tapas.io/rss/series/3346)"
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 153
  +favouriteCount: 1105
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701016987 {#1996
    date: 2023-11-26 17:43:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2919 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2913 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2910 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2908 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2922 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2924 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: """
        I was kinda worried for a while that since **kids** **these** **days** don’t really have music as a tool to rebel against their parents, and as for shocking via clothing or something like goth or satanism… they’re just recycling 80s and 90s all over again. So how are they gonna do it?\n
        \n
        Not so worried anymore. They always find something. And not just from language. The ways to be fucking idiots are endless and as a really novel thing, **kids** **these** **days** go up to 30 year olds.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 14
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701516525 {#2102
        date: 2023-12-02 12:28:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sag@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2107 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2124 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2118 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2121 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2115 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2123 …}
      -id: 157778
      -bodyTs: "'30':88 '80s':42 '90s':44 'alway':60 'anymor':58 'cloth':31 'day':12,84 'endless':75 'find':61 'fuck':72 'go':85 'gonna':52 'goth':35 'idiot':73 'kid':10,82 'kinda':3 'languag':67 'like':34 'music':17 'novel':80 'old':90 'parent':25 're':39 'realli':15,79 'rebel':22 'recycl':41 'satan':37 'shock':29 'sinc':9 'someth':33,62 'thing':81 'tool':20 'via':30 'way':69 'worri':4,57 'year':89"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4860125"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701336259 {#2109
        date: 2023-11-30 10:24:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700815219 {#2103
        date: 2023-11-24 09:40:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 157778
    }
  ]
  -id: 15926
  -titleTs: "'j.l':4 'last':1 'westov':5 'word':2"
  -bodyTs: "'/episode/3016236)(secret':5 '/rss/series/3346)':10 'm.tapas.io':4 'm.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(secret':3 'panel':6 'rss':7 'sourc':1 'tapa':2 'tapas.io':9 'tapas.io/rss/series/3346)':8"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700834979
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15822355"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700748579 {#2851
    date: 2023-11-23 15:09:39.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
132 DENIED moderate 
Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110
  +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2915 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2916 …}
  +slug: "Last-Word-by-J-L-Westover"
  +title: ""Last Word" by J.L Westover"
  +url: "https://telegra.ph/file/3a0eb99f95a669766b027.jpg"
  +body: "- Source: [Tapas](https://m.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(Secret Panel) - [RSS](https://tapas.io/rss/series/3346)"
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 153
  +favouriteCount: 1105
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701016987 {#1996
    date: 2023-11-26 17:43:07.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2919 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2913 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2910 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2908 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2922 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2924 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110 …2}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: null
      +root: null
      +body: """
        I was kinda worried for a while that since **kids** **these** **days** don’t really have music as a tool to rebel against their parents, and as for shocking via clothing or something like goth or satanism… they’re just recycling 80s and 90s all over again. So how are they gonna do it?\n
        \n
        Not so worried anymore. They always find something. And not just from language. The ways to be fucking idiots are endless and as a really novel thing, **kids** **these** **days** go up to 30 year olds.
        """
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 14
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1701516525 {#2102
        date: 2023-12-02 12:28:45.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@sag@lemm.ee"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2107 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2124 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2118 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2121 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2115 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2123 …}
      -id: 157778
      -bodyTs: "'30':88 '80s':42 '90s':44 'alway':60 'anymor':58 'cloth':31 'day':12,84 'endless':75 'find':61 'fuck':72 'go':85 'gonna':52 'goth':35 'idiot':73 'kid':10,82 'kinda':3 'languag':67 'like':34 'music':17 'novel':80 'old':90 'parent':25 're':39 'realli':15,79 'rebel':22 'recycl':41 'satan':37 'shock':29 'sinc':9 'someth':33,62 'thing':81 'tool':20 'via':30 'way':69 'worri':4,57 'year':89"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4860125"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701336259 {#2109
        date: 2023-11-30 10:24:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700815219 {#2103
        date: 2023-11-24 09:40:19.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 157778
    }
  ]
  -id: 15926
  -titleTs: "'j.l':4 'last':1 'westov':5 'word':2"
  -bodyTs: "'/episode/3016236)(secret':5 '/rss/series/3346)':10 'm.tapas.io':4 'm.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(secret':3 'panel':6 'rss':7 'sourc':1 'tapa':2 'tapas.io':9 'tapas.io/rss/series/3346)':8"
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700834979
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15822355"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700748579 {#2851
    date: 2023-11-23 15:09:39.0 +01:00
  }
  +__isInitialized__: true
   …2
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
133 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
134 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2915 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2916 …}
    +slug: "Last-Word-by-J-L-Westover"
    +title: ""Last Word" by J.L Westover"
    +url: "https://telegra.ph/file/3a0eb99f95a669766b027.jpg"
    +body: "- Source: [Tapas](https://m.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(Secret Panel) - [RSS](https://tapas.io/rss/series/3346)"
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 153
    +favouriteCount: 1105
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701016987 {#1996
      date: 2023-11-26 17:43:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2919 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2913 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2910 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2908 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2922 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2924 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106}
    ]
    -id: 15926
    -titleTs: "'j.l':4 'last':1 'westov':5 'word':2"
    -bodyTs: "'/episode/3016236)(secret':5 '/rss/series/3346)':10 'm.tapas.io':4 'm.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(secret':3 'panel':6 'rss':7 'sourc':1 'tapa':2 'tapas.io':9 'tapas.io/rss/series/3346)':8"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700834979
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15822355"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700748579 {#2851
      date: 2023-11-23 15:09:39.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: """
    I was kinda worried for a while that since **kids** **these** **days** don’t really have music as a tool to rebel against their parents, and as for shocking via clothing or something like goth or satanism… they’re just recycling 80s and 90s all over again. So how are they gonna do it?\n
    \n
    Not so worried anymore. They always find something. And not just from language. The ways to be fucking idiots are endless and as a really novel thing, **kids** **these** **days** go up to 30 year olds.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 14
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701516525 {#2102
    date: 2023-12-02 12:28:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sag@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2107 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2124 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2118 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2121 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2115 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2123 …}
  -id: 157778
  -bodyTs: "'30':88 '80s':42 '90s':44 'alway':60 'anymor':58 'cloth':31 'day':12,84 'endless':75 'find':61 'fuck':72 'go':85 'gonna':52 'goth':35 'idiot':73 'kid':10,82 'kinda':3 'languag':67 'like':34 'music':17 'novel':80 'old':90 'parent':25 're':39 'realli':15,79 'rebel':22 'recycl':41 'satan':37 'shock':29 'sinc':9 'someth':33,62 'thing':81 'tool':20 'via':30 'way':69 'worri':4,57 'year':89"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4860125"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701336259 {#2109
    date: 2023-11-30 10:24:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700815219 {#2103
    date: 2023-11-24 09:40:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 157778
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
135 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2915 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2916 …}
    +slug: "Last-Word-by-J-L-Westover"
    +title: ""Last Word" by J.L Westover"
    +url: "https://telegra.ph/file/3a0eb99f95a669766b027.jpg"
    +body: "- Source: [Tapas](https://m.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(Secret Panel) - [RSS](https://tapas.io/rss/series/3346)"
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 153
    +favouriteCount: 1105
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701016987 {#1996
      date: 2023-11-26 17:43:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2919 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2913 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2910 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2908 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2922 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2924 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106}
    ]
    -id: 15926
    -titleTs: "'j.l':4 'last':1 'westov':5 'word':2"
    -bodyTs: "'/episode/3016236)(secret':5 '/rss/series/3346)':10 'm.tapas.io':4 'm.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(secret':3 'panel':6 'rss':7 'sourc':1 'tapa':2 'tapas.io':9 'tapas.io/rss/series/3346)':8"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700834979
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15822355"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700748579 {#2851
      date: 2023-11-23 15:09:39.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: """
    I was kinda worried for a while that since **kids** **these** **days** don’t really have music as a tool to rebel against their parents, and as for shocking via clothing or something like goth or satanism… they’re just recycling 80s and 90s all over again. So how are they gonna do it?\n
    \n
    Not so worried anymore. They always find something. And not just from language. The ways to be fucking idiots are endless and as a really novel thing, **kids** **these** **days** go up to 30 year olds.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 14
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701516525 {#2102
    date: 2023-12-02 12:28:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sag@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2107 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2124 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2118 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2121 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2115 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2123 …}
  -id: 157778
  -bodyTs: "'30':88 '80s':42 '90s':44 'alway':60 'anymor':58 'cloth':31 'day':12,84 'endless':75 'find':61 'fuck':72 'go':85 'gonna':52 'goth':35 'idiot':73 'kid':10,82 'kinda':3 'languag':67 'like':34 'music':17 'novel':80 'old':90 'parent':25 're':39 'realli':15,79 'rebel':22 'recycl':41 'satan':37 'shock':29 'sinc':9 'someth':33,62 'thing':81 'tool':20 'via':30 'way':69 'worri':4,57 'year':89"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4860125"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701336259 {#2109
    date: 2023-11-30 10:24:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700815219 {#2103
    date: 2023-11-24 09:40:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 157778
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
136 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Entry {#2110
    +user: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\User {#2766 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#2915 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#2916 …}
    +slug: "Last-Word-by-J-L-Westover"
    +title: ""Last Word" by J.L Westover"
    +url: "https://telegra.ph/file/3a0eb99f95a669766b027.jpg"
    +body: "- Source: [Tapas](https://m.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(Secret Panel) - [RSS](https://tapas.io/rss/series/3346)"
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 153
    +favouriteCount: 1105
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1701016987 {#1996
      date: 2023-11-26 17:43:07.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2919 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2913 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2910 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2908 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2922 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2924 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2106}
    ]
    -id: 15926
    -titleTs: "'j.l':4 'last':1 'westov':5 'word':2"
    -bodyTs: "'/episode/3016236)(secret':5 '/rss/series/3346)':10 'm.tapas.io':4 'm.tapas.io/episode/3016236)(secret':3 'panel':6 'rss':7 'sourc':1 'tapa':2 'tapas.io':9 'tapas.io/rss/series/3346)':8"
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700834979
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://lemm.ee/post/15822355"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700748579 {#2851
      date: 2023-11-23 15:09:39.0 +01:00
    }
    +__isInitialized__: true
     …2
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: null
  +root: null
  +body: """
    I was kinda worried for a while that since **kids** **these** **days** don’t really have music as a tool to rebel against their parents, and as for shocking via clothing or something like goth or satanism… they’re just recycling 80s and 90s all over again. So how are they gonna do it?\n
    \n
    Not so worried anymore. They always find something. And not just from language. The ways to be fucking idiots are endless and as a really novel thing, **kids** **these** **days** go up to 30 year olds.
    """
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 14
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701516525 {#2102
    date: 2023-12-02 12:28:45.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@sag@lemm.ee"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2107 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2124 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2118 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2121 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2115 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2123 …}
  -id: 157778
  -bodyTs: "'30':88 '80s':42 '90s':44 'alway':60 'anymor':58 'cloth':31 'day':12,84 'endless':75 'find':61 'fuck':72 'go':85 'gonna':52 'goth':35 'idiot':73 'kid':10,82 'kinda':3 'languag':67 'like':34 'music':17 'novel':80 'old':90 'parent':25 're':39 'realli':15,79 'rebel':22 'recycl':41 'satan':37 'shock':29 'sinc':9 'someth':33,62 'thing':81 'tool':20 'via':30 'way':69 'worri':4,57 'year':89"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4860125"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701336259 {#2109
    date: 2023-11-30 10:24:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700815219 {#2103
    date: 2023-11-24 09:40:19.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 157778
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
137 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
138 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\Entry {#1435
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1675 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1656 …}
  +slug: "China-s-ties-with-America-are-warming-a-bit"
  +title: "China’s ties with America are warming, a bit"
  +url: "https://www.economist.com/china/2023/10/12/chinas-ties-with-america-are-warming-a-bit"
  +body: null
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 0
  +favouriteCount: 11
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700223377 {#1466
    date: 2023-11-17 13:16:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1661 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1553 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1609 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1549 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1573 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1566 …}
  +children: []
  -id: 13828
  -titleTs: "'america':5 'bit':9 'china':1 'tie':3 'warm':7"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700245877
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5951659"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700223377 {#1638
    date: 2023-11-17 13:16:17.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
139 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\Entry {#1435
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1675 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1656 …}
  +slug: "China-s-ties-with-America-are-warming-a-bit"
  +title: "China’s ties with America are warming, a bit"
  +url: "https://www.economist.com/china/2023/10/12/chinas-ties-with-america-are-warming-a-bit"
  +body: null
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 0
  +favouriteCount: 11
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700223377 {#1466
    date: 2023-11-17 13:16:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1661 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1553 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1609 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1549 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1573 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1566 …}
  +children: []
  -id: 13828
  -titleTs: "'america':5 'bit':9 'china':1 'tie':3 'warm':7"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700245877
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5951659"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700223377 {#1638
    date: 2023-11-17 13:16:17.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
140 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\Entry {#1435
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1675 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1656 …}
  +slug: "China-s-ties-with-America-are-warming-a-bit"
  +title: "China’s ties with America are warming, a bit"
  +url: "https://www.economist.com/china/2023/10/12/chinas-ties-with-america-are-warming-a-bit"
  +body: null
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 0
  +favouriteCount: 11
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700223377 {#1466
    date: 2023-11-17 13:16:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1661 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1553 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1609 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1549 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1573 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1566 …}
  +children: []
  -id: 13828
  -titleTs: "'america':5 'bit':9 'china':1 'tie':3 'warm':7"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700245877
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5951659"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700223377 {#1638
    date: 2023-11-17 13:16:17.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
141 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
142 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\Entry {#1795
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1705 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1711 …}
  +slug: "Lisbon-should-be-Russian-says-Kremlin-propagandist"
  +title: ""Lisbon should be Russian", says Kremlin propagandist"
  +url: "https://www.theportugalnews.com/news/2023-11-28/lisbon-should-be-russian-says-kremlin-propagandist/83689"
  +body: null
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 1
  +favouriteCount: 12
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701567349 {#1691
    date: 2023-12-03 02:35:49.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1616 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1598 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1629 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1626 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1618 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1597 …}
  +children: []
  -id: 18104
  -titleTs: "'kremlin':6 'lisbon':1 'propagandist':7 'russian':4 'say':5"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701274506
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/6384481"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701241006 {#1692
    date: 2023-11-29 07:56:46.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
143 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\Entry {#1795
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1705 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1711 …}
  +slug: "Lisbon-should-be-Russian-says-Kremlin-propagandist"
  +title: ""Lisbon should be Russian", says Kremlin propagandist"
  +url: "https://www.theportugalnews.com/news/2023-11-28/lisbon-should-be-russian-says-kremlin-propagandist/83689"
  +body: null
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 1
  +favouriteCount: 12
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701567349 {#1691
    date: 2023-12-03 02:35:49.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1616 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1598 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1629 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1626 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1618 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1597 …}
  +children: []
  -id: 18104
  -titleTs: "'kremlin':6 'lisbon':1 'propagandist':7 'russian':4 'say':5"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701274506
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/6384481"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701241006 {#1692
    date: 2023-11-29 07:56:46.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
144 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\Entry {#1795
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1651 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1705 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1711 …}
  +slug: "Lisbon-should-be-Russian-says-Kremlin-propagandist"
  +title: ""Lisbon should be Russian", says Kremlin propagandist"
  +url: "https://www.theportugalnews.com/news/2023-11-28/lisbon-should-be-russian-says-kremlin-propagandist/83689"
  +body: null
  +type: "link"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: false
  +commentCount: 1
  +favouriteCount: 12
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1701567349 {#1691
    date: 2023-12-03 02:35:49.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1616 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1598 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1629 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1626 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1618 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1597 …}
  +children: []
  -id: 18104
  -titleTs: "'kremlin':6 'lisbon':1 'propagandist':7 'russian':4 'say':5"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1701274506
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/6384481"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1701241006 {#1692
    date: 2023-11-29 07:56:46.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
145 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
146 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\Entry {#1556
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1557 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1562 …}
  +slug: "I-used-to-think-X"
  +title: "I used to think X"
  +url: "https://sopuli.xyz/pictrs/image/f4a18567-e4a3-40bd-8863-5d49dde6c4cc.png"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 66
  +favouriteCount: 588
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700543811 {#1559
    date: 2023-11-21 06:16:51.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1558 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1604 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1619 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1701 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1687 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1689 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: App\Entity\Entry {#1556}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
      +body: "It’s not easy, but I think people should have a value system that’s independent from how others behave."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 50
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700297357 {#2062
        date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2080 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2089 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2095 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2091 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2090 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2092 …}
      -id: 136388
      -bodyTs: "'behav':20 'easi':4 'independ':16 'other':19 'peopl':8 'system':13 'think':7 'valu':12"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4693027"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700605884 {#2081
        date: 2023-11-21 23:31:24.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700297357 {#2077
        date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 136388
    }
  ]
  -id: 14093
  -titleTs: "'think':4 'use':2 'x':5"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700379703
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5982858"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700293303 {#1525
    date: 2023-11-18 08:41:43.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
147 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\Entry {#1556
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1557 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1562 …}
  +slug: "I-used-to-think-X"
  +title: "I used to think X"
  +url: "https://sopuli.xyz/pictrs/image/f4a18567-e4a3-40bd-8863-5d49dde6c4cc.png"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 66
  +favouriteCount: 588
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700543811 {#1559
    date: 2023-11-21 06:16:51.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1558 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1604 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1619 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1701 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1687 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1689 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: App\Entity\Entry {#1556}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
      +body: "It’s not easy, but I think people should have a value system that’s independent from how others behave."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 50
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700297357 {#2062
        date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2080 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2089 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2095 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2091 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2090 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2092 …}
      -id: 136388
      -bodyTs: "'behav':20 'easi':4 'independ':16 'other':19 'peopl':8 'system':13 'think':7 'valu':12"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4693027"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700605884 {#2081
        date: 2023-11-21 23:31:24.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700297357 {#2077
        date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 136388
    }
  ]
  -id: 14093
  -titleTs: "'think':4 'use':2 'x':5"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700379703
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5982858"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700293303 {#1525
    date: 2023-11-18 08:41:43.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
148 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\Entry {#1556
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1557 …}
  +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1562 …}
  +slug: "I-used-to-think-X"
  +title: "I used to think X"
  +url: "https://sopuli.xyz/pictrs/image/f4a18567-e4a3-40bd-8863-5d49dde6c4cc.png"
  +body: null
  +type: "image"
  +lang: "en"
  +isOc: false
  +hasEmbed: true
  +commentCount: 66
  +favouriteCount: 588
  +score: 0
  +isAdult: false
  +sticky: false
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700543811 {#1559
    date: 2023-11-21 06:16:51.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +adaAmount: 0
  +tags: null
  +mentions: null
  +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1558 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1604 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1619 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1701 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1687 …}
  +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1689 …}
  +children: [
    App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098
      +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
      +entry: App\Entity\Entry {#1556}
      +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
      +image: null
      +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
      +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
      +body: "It’s not easy, but I think people should have a value system that’s independent from how others behave."
      +lang: "en"
      +isAdult: false
      +favouriteCount: 50
      +score: 0
      +lastActive: DateTime @1700297357 {#2062
        date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
      }
      +ip: null
      +tags: null
      +mentions: [
        "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
        "@chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com"
      ]
      +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2080 …}
      +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2089 …}
      +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2095 …}
      +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2091 …}
      +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2090 …}
      +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2092 …}
      -id: 136388
      -bodyTs: "'behav':20 'easi':4 'independ':16 'other':19 'peopl':8 'system':13 'think':7 'valu':12"
      +ranking: 0
      +commentCount: 0
      +upVotes: 0
      +downVotes: 0
      +visibility: "visible             "
      +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4693027"
      +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700605884 {#2081
        date: 2023-11-21 23:31:24.0 +01:00
      }
      +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700297357 {#2077
        date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
      }
      +"title": 136388
    }
  ]
  -id: 14093
  -titleTs: "'think':4 'use':2 'x':5"
  -bodyTs: null
  +cross: false
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +ranking: 1700379703
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5982858"
  +editedAt: null
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700293303 {#1525
    date: 2023-11-18 08:41:43.0 +01:00
  }
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
149 DENIED ROLE_USER 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
150 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: App\Entity\Entry {#1556
    +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1557 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1562 …}
    +slug: "I-used-to-think-X"
    +title: "I used to think X"
    +url: "https://sopuli.xyz/pictrs/image/f4a18567-e4a3-40bd-8863-5d49dde6c4cc.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 66
    +favouriteCount: 588
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700543811 {#1559
      date: 2023-11-21 06:16:51.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1558 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1604 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1619 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1701 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1687 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1689 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098}
    ]
    -id: 14093
    -titleTs: "'think':4 'use':2 'x':5"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700379703
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5982858"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700293303 {#1525
      date: 2023-11-18 08:41:43.0 +01:00
    }
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
  +body: "It’s not easy, but I think people should have a value system that’s independent from how others behave."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 50
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700297357 {#2062
    date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2080 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2089 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2095 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2091 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2090 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2092 …}
  -id: 136388
  -bodyTs: "'behav':20 'easi':4 'independ':16 'other':19 'peopl':8 'system':13 'think':7 'valu':12"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4693027"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700605884 {#2081
    date: 2023-11-21 23:31:24.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700297357 {#2077
    date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 136388
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
151 DENIED edit 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: App\Entity\Entry {#1556
    +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1557 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1562 …}
    +slug: "I-used-to-think-X"
    +title: "I used to think X"
    +url: "https://sopuli.xyz/pictrs/image/f4a18567-e4a3-40bd-8863-5d49dde6c4cc.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 66
    +favouriteCount: 588
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700543811 {#1559
      date: 2023-11-21 06:16:51.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1558 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1604 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1619 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1701 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1687 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1689 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098}
    ]
    -id: 14093
    -titleTs: "'think':4 'use':2 'x':5"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700379703
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5982858"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700293303 {#1525
      date: 2023-11-18 08:41:43.0 +01:00
    }
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
  +body: "It’s not easy, but I think people should have a value system that’s independent from how others behave."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 50
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700297357 {#2062
    date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2080 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2089 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2095 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2091 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2090 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2092 …}
  -id: 136388
  -bodyTs: "'behav':20 'easi':4 'independ':16 'other':19 'peopl':8 'system':13 'think':7 'valu':12"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4693027"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700605884 {#2081
    date: 2023-11-21 23:31:24.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700297357 {#2077
    date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 136388
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
152 DENIED moderate 
App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098
  +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
  +entry: App\Entity\Entry {#1556
    +user: App\Entity\User {#260 …}
    +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
    +image: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Image {#1557 …}
    +domain: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Domain {#1562 …}
    +slug: "I-used-to-think-X"
    +title: "I used to think X"
    +url: "https://sopuli.xyz/pictrs/image/f4a18567-e4a3-40bd-8863-5d49dde6c4cc.png"
    +body: null
    +type: "image"
    +lang: "en"
    +isOc: false
    +hasEmbed: true
    +commentCount: 66
    +favouriteCount: 588
    +score: 0
    +isAdult: false
    +sticky: false
    +lastActive: DateTime @1700543811 {#1559
      date: 2023-11-21 06:16:51.0 +01:00
    }
    +ip: null
    +adaAmount: 0
    +tags: null
    +mentions: null
    +comments: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1558 …}
    +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1604 …}
    +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1619 …}
    +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1701 …}
    +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1687 …}
    +badges: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#1689 …}
    +children: [
      App\Entity\EntryComment {#2098}
    ]
    -id: 14093
    -titleTs: "'think':4 'use':2 'x':5"
    -bodyTs: null
    +cross: false
    +upVotes: 0
    +downVotes: 0
    +ranking: 1700379703
    +visibility: "visible             "
    +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/post/5982858"
    +editedAt: null
    +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700293303 {#1525
      date: 2023-11-18 08:41:43.0 +01:00
    }
  }
  +magazine: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\Magazine {#1555 …}
  +image: null
  +parent: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
  +root: Proxies\__CG__\App\Entity\EntryComment {#2063 …}
  +body: "It’s not easy, but I think people should have a value system that’s independent from how others behave."
  +lang: "en"
  +isAdult: false
  +favouriteCount: 50
  +score: 0
  +lastActive: DateTime @1700297357 {#2062
    date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +ip: null
  +tags: null
  +mentions: [
    "@fosforus@sopuli.xyz"
    "@chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com"
  ]
  +children: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2080 …}
  +nested: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2089 …}
  +votes: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2095 …}
  +reports: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2091 …}
  +favourites: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2090 …}
  +notifications: Doctrine\ORM\PersistentCollection {#2092 …}
  -id: 136388
  -bodyTs: "'behav':20 'easi':4 'independ':16 'other':19 'peopl':8 'system':13 'think':7 'valu':12"
  +ranking: 0
  +commentCount: 0
  +upVotes: 0
  +downVotes: 0
  +visibility: "visible             "
  +apId: "https://sopuli.xyz/comment/4693027"
  +editedAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700605884 {#2081
    date: 2023-11-21 23:31:24.0 +01:00
  }
  +createdAt: DateTimeImmutable @1700297357 {#2077
    date: 2023-11-18 09:49:17.0 +01:00
  }
  +"title": 136388
}
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
153 DENIED ROLE_ADMIN 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details
154 DENIED ROLE_MODERATOR 
null
 
"Scheb\TwoFactorBundle\Security\Authorization\Voter\TwoFactorInProgressVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"Symfony\Component\Security\Core\Authorization\Voter\RoleHierarchyVoter"
 ACCESS DENIED 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\EntryVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MagazineVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageThreadVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\MessageVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\NotificationVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\OAuth2UserConsentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostCommentVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\PostVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN 
"App\Security\Voter\UserVoter"
 ACCESS ABSTAIN
Show voter details