Americans - I Need Help Choosing A Bourbon

I’ve got a mate whos a big fan of Bourbon. He’s tried all the standard brands like Buffalo Trace, JD, Jim Beam and Wild Turkey.

I want to get him a bottle for Xmas of something he might not have tried before, something I can say was recommended by Americans as a good bourbon. Doesn’t need to be some weird flavour like Red Stag, just old fashioned American bourbon that maybe flies under the radar in other countries.

redline23,

Some good recommendations in this thread. You should give the following a try.

  • Woodford Reserve Wheated. It’s very smooth and I think it’s the best value for money you can get. This is my personal favorite right now
  • Michters Small Batch. Good and robust flavor
  • Weller. If you can find it, but you probably won’t.
  • Angels Envy is very good and smooth
  • Four Roses Small Batch
  • Penelope Toasted is alright. I enjoyed it, but it wasn’t wow value for the price. It’s a good bourbon though
  • 1792 is good.
  • Rabbit Hole is good
  • Blade and Bow is good
zerbey,

I’ll second Four Roses, it’s delicious stuff.

IMongoose,

Maker’s Mark is pretty popular and they have a few price tiers.

Dkarma,

Don’t get the base bottle! Go 96 trust me!

Tikiporch,

Also a great looking bottle with the red wax.

serpentofnumbers,

Basil Hayden, Woodford Reserve, Knob Creek, Angel’s Envy, Old Grandad, Bulleit are all great choices.

Basil Hayden or Woodford would definitely be my first choice though.

Dkarma, (edited )

These are all my very last choices except the Woodford, knob creek rye or single barrel 120 proof.

The rest of these taste like household cleaner.

Woodford makes a Manhattan bottled that is stellar iirc though.

Venutianxspring, (edited )

Huge fan of Basil Hayden

theluddite, (edited )
@theluddite@lemmy.ml avatar

A +1 for Woodford Reserve and Knob Creek, especially Woodford’s nicer offerings. Those are great choices.

I’m going to disagree on the Basil Hayden and the Bulleit. I wouldn’t recommend them to a bourbon enthusiast (or to anyone really). Bulleit in particular I think doesn’t really offer a lot of the classic bourbon experience that someone who is into bourbon might get excited about. To me, it drinks quite hot and is pretty thin.

korewa,

Knob creek is my go to as well

drphungky, (edited )

Crazy that no one has recommended Costco’s in-house Bourbon. It’s very hard to get unless you know when it’s in stock, because it sells out in like a week, but at some places (DC for example) you don’t even need a membership to buy liquor. It’s a REALLY good Bourbon for the price. It’s a little stronger and sweeter than many bourbons in my estimation, without much bite.

My buddy is a huge Bourbon snob, we did the trail for his bachelor party, and he had a few bourbon bars set up at his wedding. It was one of the five he chose to have at his wedding, and the decision was not made on cost. He’s the one that introduced me to it, and it’s basically all I buy now, unless I’m getting something cheap for bourbon and gingers or some other mixed drink.

zerbey,

It’s a cheap option and often overlooked, but my go to has been Jim Beam Devil’s Cut for years now.

doc,

What's your budget? If your friend is into bourbon then most everything here he's probably tried. To get a unique gift bottle will cost a bit more, depending where you are.

SirToxicAvenger,
Everythingispenguins,

Have you thought about giving him a rye whisky? It is still a very American style of whisky. It might be a neat treat to have something just a little different.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • asklemmy@lemmy.world
  • localhost
  • All magazines
  • Loading…
    Loading the web debug toolbar…
    Attempt #