TheGrandNagus

@TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world

This profile is from a federated server and may be incomplete. Browse more on the original instance.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

The only other good term for Enshittification I’ve seen used is Platform Decay. It was even coined by the same person who coined enshittification.

TheGrandNagus,

It really is a slippery slope. When does it end???

It ends when you open vim. There’s no escape.

TheGrandNagus,

Ireland has had issues with BSE too, even recently.

In 2020, Irish beef destined for export to china was found to be infected, and it resulted in a 3 year ban on Irish beef imports. In 2023, another case was found, and exports have been stopped again.

There have been ~2000 cases since 2001. Way down from the 90s, but it still exists

TheGrandNagus,

There’s been a shift away from putting pills in bottles.

IIRC it was pioneered by the NHS (UK), because they found that the mild inconvenience and time of popping out the pills one by one, in comparison to the ease and speed of downing a whole bottle of them, cut down on people attempting suicide by overdose by a surprising amount.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

first of all why would anyone steal pills?

Remember, people in the US often have to pay a shitload for medication.

But even outside of the US, there’s still the issue of people wanting to steal prescription medicine if you can get high on it/sell it to people who want to get high from it.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

This isn’t material design. Material design is very different.

m2.material.io/design/…/product-icons.html

And I don’t really see how a browser icon can look like it’s for Karens lol

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

The antenna thing almost touching the edge on the old one makes it kinda look off-centre, as if it was haphazardly thrown together by someone who doesn’t know what they’re doing.

The new one definitely looks better. To bad the platform itself is still shit.

TheGrandNagus,

I think most actually like it more, it’s just people are a lot more likely to come online and make posts if they dislike something.

TheGrandNagus,

Those icons absolutely do not look normal, there’s some kind of theme being applied to all of them, likely a dark mode before it became a standardised feature, by the looks of it.

TheGrandNagus,

Not only that, but they aren’t standardised, and Gnome really likes adhering to standards and staying away from anything they consider unstandardised or janky.

System trays really are a complete clusterfuck.

Sometimes the icons have colour, sometimes they don’t, sometimes they’re minimalist icons, sometimes they’re not. Sometimes you left click on them to do something, sometimes you need to right click, sometimes it’s both, sometimes they have their own menu UI, sometimes they integrate with the system’s, sometimes you can exit an app via them, sometimes you can’t, sometimes they give you notifications, sometimes they just do it through your standard OS notification system, etc.

They are an inconsistent mess. And we all know how anal Gnome can be about UX consistency.

Gnome in the past has expressed a desire for a standardised, cross-desktop system tray that fixes these issues, but tbh I’m sceptical it’d catch on. Not because other desktops wouldn’t get on board, but rather because app developers will just go “meh, we’ll just stick to what we have” and it won’t gain traction.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

Yes, you can turn them all off…

…if you install 3 different resource-hogging, data-harvesting RGB lighting control programs on your PC and have them run at startup.

I’m not that pissed off about RGB. But it should be off by default.

White by default would be ok in theory, but in reality they all vary in brightness and colour temperature, so that looks jarring too.

E: lmao ok people, simp for the corporations

TheGrandNagus,

The problem is that each part manufacturer wants you to install their shitty RGB control software that is often bizarrely resource-hogging, and sometimes even used for data gathering.

On laptops, some RGB control software can eat your battery away by a fair bit because the CPU never goes into a lower power state.

RBG should A) all conform to a standardised open API, and B) be off by default.

TheGrandNagus,

A washer or dryer is never late. Nor it it early. It finishes precisely when it means to.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

IMO the biggest problem is simply that not enough devices are sold with it.

The amount of people who want to/can be arsed to/even know they can install an OS on their PC is pretty small. And even then, most that can will just stick to what they know (this is obviously part of the mindset issue that you speak of).

If mainstream devices were sold with Linux on them, it would get over that hurdle, and also get over the daunting hurdle of “ok I want to switch to Linux, what’s a good distro?” hurdle, to which people online will say everything from Debian to fucking Arch Linux.

Chromebooks (bastardised though they may be) and the Steam Deck prove that Linux isn’t unviable. People just won’t install it of their own volition.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

Plenty of Linux projects have had a focus on UX.

Back in the day, Ubuntu made huge strides in UX and usability, and they’re still riding the coattails of that success even now that they’ve shifted to the corporate sector.

ElementaryOS came out and was super polished, simple, and beautiful. That’s still kinda true, but their small team has meant that they’re now falling behind the likes of Gnome, who’ve set out to do a similar thing.

The Cinnamon desktop is ugly out of the box, but other aspects of UX have been pretty great - everything is simple, they were pioneers in making everything a GUI option, rather than the last 5% of things having to be done in a config file or via terminal.

And finally, Gnome. Extremely polished, consistent, beautiful, and heavily UX-focused. That applies not only to their own system, but also to their third party app ecosystem. Just look at the apps on Gnome Circle - a Gnome project for showcasing apps that nail the Gnome design guidelines. Tell me they don’t look like they have a focus on UX.

Honestly, even MacOS struggles to feel as UX-focused as Gnome, and that’s saying something. UX is like, Apple’s entire schtick. Everything from trackpad gestures to UI elements, subtle animations, etc in Gnome is about UX.

Tbh, Gnome is sometimes so focused on UX that it arguably becomes a detriment to their development cycle. They’ll spend months deliberating on things like accent colours, chatting about all the potential ramifications, legibility, how it can inadvertently lead to destructive user actions, and the best way to implement it as a feature, rather than just doing it and moving on to the next feature.

Even KDE Plasma, which is often mocked for being hilariously inconsistent and filled with bizarre clunky UX, has made major strides in the past couple of years, and Plasma 6, releasing very soon, will fix a bunch of fundamental things that currently hold Plasma back from being consistent, and a significant portion of bugs have been fixed - it looks like it won’t be the buggy mess that Plasma 4 and early Plasma 5 was. We’re about to see a major improvement.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

I love how polished everything is in Gnome. I try another DE because of some cool thing, but I keep coming back to Gnome.

There are a couple of minor things that irk me, but man, how good Gnome looks, the consistency, stability, and attention to detail from the devs make it superb to me.

The accessibility options are also great for a Linux distro.

And, and I know people hate this about Gnome, but I love that it’s not just a Windows UX/workflow clone with a start button in the bottom left that opens a small start menu, Taskbar along the bottom with time and system stuff shoved in the corner, minimise/maximise/close buttons on the top right of every app, etc.

They’re ballsy enough to do usability studies and go with what makes sense, not just what we’re most used to, even though it’s opened the devs up to hate and threats.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

It’s mostly C.

And Gnome is far from the only desktop that uses JS, KDE Plasma, for example, also uses a lot of JavaScript.

It’s weird when people bash Gnome for using JS, when practically everybody else uses it a lot too. Shows that they’re just regurgitating “Gnome = bad!!!” nonsense.

We get it, you think disliking Gnome is a quirky, edgy personality trait.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

There’s a lot more to your UX than just the Plasma desktop. And you’re also trying to pass off Gnome’s shell as being Gnome desktop. Pretty disingenuous.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )
  • Proprietary on the server/distribution end
  • Controlled 100% by Canonical
  • Worse performance, particularly in terms of app startup times
  • Snaps are mounted as separate filesystems, so it can make things look cluttered in your file explorer or when you’re listing stuff with lsblk
  • Canonical often forces users to use Snaps even when users have explicitly tried to install with apt. e.g. you run sudo apt install firefox and it installs a Snap
  • It hasn’t gained traction with other distros like Flatpak has, and Canonical’s insistence on backing the “wrong” standard means Linux will continue to be more fragmented than it would be if they also went along with what has become the de facto standard

There are however benefits of snaps. It works for better for terminal programs, and Canonical can even package system stuff like the kernel as a snap - as you can imagine, this might be a very powerful tool when it comes to an immutable version of Ubuntu.

TheGrandNagus,

There’s a misunderstanding here. What we mean is that the Snap system itself is proprietary. The server side is proprietary and there’s no way to add repos other than Canonical’s.

Flatpak is open, and anybody can create/add a remote.

Both can be used to package and distribute proprietary software. But the same could be said of .deb or .rpm

TheGrandNagus,

So? The AMD subreddit is larger than either Nvidia’s or Intel’s (in the case of Intel, by a lot). Both of them have a greater market share than AMD in their respective markets.

Porsche has over double the subs of Toyota, yet Toyota sells 33x the amount of cars.

Subs means zero.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

Debian is one of the distros where flatpaks are most appropriate lol, it’s the best way to not have programs that are really old

Adding weird third party repositories that can cause all kinds of issues probably isn’t the best idea

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

Considering it uses day then month, 24hr clock, and distance in km, I’m guessing the reason why it’s not “human readable in American” is because it’s intended to be “human readable for pretty much everybody else”

The date format isn’t incorrect at all

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

If you like to tinker with your own system, that’s fine with us. However, if you change things like stylesheets and icons, you should be aware that you’re in unsupported territory. Any issues you encounter should be reported to the theme developer, not the app developer.

I don’t know whether you’re shitting on theme developers or GTK app developers with your comment, but they explicitly state that they think theming is fine, they’re just tired of people reporting theme problems as app problems. It’s a completely reasonable take.

If I were an app developer I wouldn’t want to open a bug report, then spend hours and hours investigating a reported issue, only to find out that my app was never the problem in the first place.

TheGrandNagus, (edited )

This article can pretty much be summed up as I don’t like GTK or Gnome so I’m going to just present them being shit as a factual statement. I use Arch and KDE btw.

Gnome 3 released close to 13 years ago and was announced 16 years ago. At some point, people need to stop crying about the UX changes and get the fuck over it.

If you don’t like it, use something else and stop being so entitled.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • localhost
  • All magazines
  • Loading…
    Loading the web debug toolbar…
    Attempt #