as a kid, this was the first movie where i really understood the difference between the books as source material for movies... i was a huge fan of the movie but reading the book added so much depth.
they need not to be appreciated separately, or have any stark differences. they are very complimentary with the movie displaying beautiful visuals while the books adds the entire dimension of the aliens point of view.
suuuure, its been a few years, but basically the aliens have been here for thousands of years. water is fairly irrelevant to them, as its the pressure they are after.
the aliens can manipulate their environment at the molecular level so can easily create oxygen wherever they want. they can trivially read humans minds. they basically dont care about the advance of the human race until one day one of their peeps hits a satellite in space, crashes into the ocean and causes a united states nuclear submarine to crash, killing all crew.
the events of the movie pick up here. the aliens are remorseful about the submarine, while investigating they cause the events in the movie...towards then end a nuclear weapon lands on top of them. they of course already understand that the main character sacrifices himself to save them, whom they know he is unfamiliar with. he (and the memories of all the humans they have scanned) convinces them humans are not all bad.
the aliens realize they can no longer ignore the humans, and so expose themselves, bringing their ship out of the water. I believe in the book they also generate a giant tsunami wave out across the whole earth that halts in mid air right at the shores of the worlds beaches.
this is to get our attention.... we are not alone, or even in charge, anymore.
It was the other way around though- Orson Scott card was hired to write a novelization of the movie. The book isn’t the source material for the film, the film is the source for the book.
I just saw this on IMDB and was like “great…how are the re-imagining it now?” but nope, it doesn’t even look like a re-imagining of it, they just taking the original story and using new actors for 99% of the cast. I think the only two original actors left are Tim and Tina.
This is going to be terrible, but it’s going to get rave review no doubt, just like the stupid Charmed remake, which is somehow still on AFAIK.
Either way, taking a movie and then making it a Broadway musical and then making that musical into a movie, just sounds like a bad game of “telephone”.
I donno, the trailer doesn’t show any of the whit from the source. Just jokes about over eating and getting kicked off train… Where’s the thought provoking stuff and the inner monologue?
youtu.be
Active