Time to ditch #duckduckgo

In the last couple of months I have noticed an increasing trend of supplying me search results that are completely unrelated to the current query and tie back to my location or previous searches. I can say this with a high degree of certainty this is without a doubt beyond the 100th instance this has happened.

My browser is configured against tracking and fingerprinting (in fact all my devices are) which would make it fairly difficult to retain any data unless they are profiling me.

devbo,

great. i finally get off google and now duckduckgo is bad. i hate the internet.

LinkOpensChest_wav,

Try this one: searxng.no-logs.com

lars,

So like… all Searx instances are independent, but I can save my preferences in a reproducible query string? Or like… how’s this a long-term, easy, good move for me? (I know ≈nothing).

LinkOpensChest_wav,

You can do it that way if you grab that URL from the “cookies” section. Otherwise, it can save your preferences in a cookie.

lars,

Thanks!

Do all the Searx instances generate and keep independent indexes of the entire internet, or is it more like Lemmy (where, maybe, each instance is a window into the entirety of the index)?

LinkOpensChest_wav,

Good question! I wish I knew, but unfortunately this is outside the scope of my knowledge. Someone on !privacyguides could probably tell you immediately

solidsnake2085,
@solidsnake2085@lemmy.world avatar

Kagi was my favorite but their pricing model is a little too high still. If it was $5 for 500 searches I would do that but the unlimited for $10 is just a bit too high for me.

some_guy,

I get that not everyone has extra cash to spend. I’m very fortunate to be able to throw $10 at a problem. I don’t begrudge you if you need to save cash (I have no kids to raise, for example). But I think $10 is fair if you search a bunch. Maybe I’m overvaluing it; I have heard great things about Kagi, but I’m still fucking around on Google cause it’s “good enough,” even though it’s in great decline. Fuck it, I’m a hypocrite.

Gooey0210,

I have searx, and i’m feeling like a god of search, better than google, better that bingbinggo, and anything else Although I had a lot of problems with it when I was hosting it on a RPI and docker, now i’m not, and it’s just so much better

glasgitarrewelt,

What was the problem with Docker? I want to host it myself, the docker option seems to be the easiest one.

maynarkh,

I’d guess the RPI part would be the bigger issue.

Gooey0210,

Docker by itself is not a good thing, bad with security, not entirely open source, buggy networking, not very reproducible

The problem with docker was timeout for requests, not sure whose falt it was, but the reverse proxy container was unresponsive pretty often

Also, yeah, RPI was not really fast too, it had 8gb ram, boot from ssd Just right now I have i9 with 64gb ram, and this is stupid fast, and actually for most of the apps the performance bump is like 50%

About docker, really, try to look into nixos, it has a really steep learning curve, but it will worth it, and you will be able to do magic

andruid,

Containers are really awesome, but take a bit more to troubleshoot sometimes. Docker is not the only method to run them either. I prefer podman actually, but K3s is the next logical step for running services in a more powerful setup.

All true FOSS too

Gooey0210, (edited )

Podman is better, but believe my words, try nixos. It’s like a docker-compose file, but for a system, this is really something groundbreaking

You specify all the system and services passwords, usernames, all the stuff, your wallpapers, directories, keys, everything

And all basic configurations are already unified, so to enable some service you just need to add a line in your main config like services.nginx.enable = true; and it just works with all the bells and whistles (kind off, you can add much more. Even more than in containers)

The services are usually not sandboxes, but you can sandbox them, can even run the same containers

Sorry if you’re really not into it, it just nixos feels like a whole new lvl after podman

edit: even like that, I manage all my machines as a fleet with nixos, all from one configuration So I can basically press a button and change all the usernames on all machines and everything will continue working

Instead of adding each machine separately to a vpn, I just press a button and it deploys all the machines with wireguard and connects them all

andruid,

No nix is super cool! I really like the idea that guix and nix in having that system as code from build to deployment. I am not sure yet on how I feel about it for fleet/cluster deployments, k8s schedulers, network patterns like service meshes, ETCD, and operating on labels and cluster state are all super powerful.

I have looked too into using nix to make OCI containers and OCI containers to make flatpaks as well. All where they make sense of course.

canihasaccount,

I paid for Kagi and have been super happy with it. If you don’t mind paying, I highly recommend it. Not having ads or manipulated results is worth it for me.

LinkOpensChest_wav,

I’m unhappy that Kagi uses geo-location data to provide certain types of results

Sunroc,

Oh that sucks, can you turn it off or spoof the location?

example,

you can just turn it off, see help.kagi.com/kagi/settings/general.html

LinkOpensChest_wav,

You can easily spoof the location on most search engines by using a VPN, but I’d much prefer my search engine solely respond to deliberate input from the user

thedeadwalking4242,

Kagi!!! It’s cost money but it’s cheap. If you do alot of searches it’s worth it

elias_griffin,

I tried Kagi and canceled after a week. It’s a reformat of DuckDuckGo, a better format for sure, and lack of sponsored links, yet it adds AI too. In the end, it’s the same old curated unhelpful results that leave millions of high value boutique and indie sources of information out. Also, it’s Orion browser is bad.

Basically ask yourself that knowing all the good writers, content creators went to Substack, yet hardly any search engine gives results from there, why?

thedeadwalking4242,

There isn’t going to be a search engine without some type of ai or content agitation tool. Key word search is not enough to make one of these work. Search engines need to sort through millions of web pages, and try to give you the best match for what your looking for via smart algorithms. With Google these algorithms are designed to sell you products and get the most clicks out of you. Kagis profit incentive is to curate good links for your search results. Indie results will always be low on the ranks thats why they are indie. As they get more popular so so their search results. You don’t want your search engine feeding you only new and up and coming shit. You want the most relevant search results. Sometimes it’s going to take some digging to find what your looking for. UNLESS you want to give up mountains of your data to and hope that the company uses it to serve your interest instead of feed you sponsored bullshit.

ejmin, (edited )

Same here. Every time I ditch Google and go to ddg, I just laugh how irrelevant all the results are and I continue feeding Google with personal data and telemetry and whatnot.

It is true that even Google’s results feel much worse than before but it’s still significantly better than ddg.

Gabu,

Not for me – if DDG is trash, Google is actually unusable.

Jorgelino,

Me neither. Even Bing is better than google nowadays.

Also, when it comes to piracy, google basically blocks every relevant result.

steakmeout,

Working fine here. OP are you sure it’s not your network?

DetectiveSanity,

I am running OpenWRT and forcing DNS traffic to Mullvad with a fallback to Quad9, besides this happens across different networks.

clearleaf, (edited )

I’ve never seen the point of this search engine or any commercial alternative to google. It’s all just varying layers of proxy to Google. You might as well just find a searx instance and use that because it’s all the same crap at the end of the day.

Zyansheep,

Huh? I thought duckduckgo maintained its own index?

sar1n,

I’ve also noticed that if you do a search, click a result, then hit back to go back to the results they manipulate the results in some weird way so they’re not the exact same results you got the first time. Infuriating

alansuspect,

Yeah I hate that. Now all results have to be opened in new tabs just in case.

akilou,

Yes! I thought I was losing my mind. I was like “I swear this was the third result but now it’s the 5th? Eh, maybe it was the 5th.”

TwilightKiddy, (edited )

Ducks are learning to gaslight people. Fascinating.

mindbleach,

I’d bet that’s more bug than feature. Like they’re trying to avoid SEO providing any consistent ordering to be gamed.

Still a pain in the ass either way. Vindication for being a complete tab whore.

69420,

This is the new quantum search feature: you changed the results by observing them.

TheFeatureCreature,
@TheFeatureCreature@lemmy.world avatar

Odd. I wonder what is going on here because when I search that exact same query I get accurate results.

I’ve had iffy search results before but never anything that bad.

ItsMeSpez,

I also returned totally accurate results using the exact same query. I would really like to know what is going on here. This is a common complaint with some people using DDG, that the results are poor, but I consistently have as good if not better results than using Google.

angelsomething,

I also don’t get the same results. I also have tracking and fingerprinting disabled everywhere.

Gazumi,

What would we suggest as a realistic alternative? Sears? Startpage? Brave? (I am no expert by the way, just looking for tips)

metacolon,
@metacolon@lemmy.blahaj.zone avatar

I’ve been using metager for some while and really like it. They’re also part of an initiative pushing for a free as in freedom search index, so that’s nice

currycourier,

I just switched to using Kagi recently and I like it a lot so far! Theres a free tier for 100/searches a month you can use to figure out if you like it.

Vexz, (edited )

Me too. I was so reluctant to pay for a search engine at first since there are good alternatives out there I don't have to pay for. But I just at least wanted to try the first 100 free searches and was blown away by how great it is. It has some unique features like prioritizing or blocking specific domains, lenses and custom bangs. I payed the $10 the same day for Pro tier and 5 days later (yesterday) I even upgraded to Ultimate tier with ChatGPT-4 (called Kagi Assistant). I really, really enjoy Kagi so far. Most probably it's gonna be my one and only search engine for the next years to come.

TheDarkKnight,

Are, are you telling me that I can block Fandom’s wiki results? Because I dream of such a future!

Vexz, (edited )

Yes, you can. You can block any domain you want to appear in your search results. Here's the documentation for this feature.

coughrelief, (edited )
@coughrelief@lemmy.world avatar

Searx sucks for images in my experience, startpage was bought by an advertising company, brave is weird for a multitude of reasons but I don’t know how good their search engine is as I’ve never tried it

However I do think that finding a searx instance that works for you and then using another engine like ddg for images is the way to go… You could add a shortcut like “.ddg garbage truck” for easily searching with for example ddg on firefox

thebardingreen,
@thebardingreen@lemmy.starlightkel.xyz avatar

Brave’s search engine is… fine. I only use it by accident sometimes.

Gooey0210,

How does searx suck for images exactly? 🫠

melooone,

Also a bit confused by this. I thought the point of searxng is to combine your preferred search engines. So couldn’t I just configure ddg for the image results?

Gooey0210,

Maybe their point was that you cannot filter the images, like by color, size, license, etc

But anyway, if I want to show somebody a picture of something it works perfectly As for the results, they are pretty comparable between searx, ddg, and googlag.

I would even say searx wins on this one because 1. It’s easier to navigate and open images 2. The nojs version of the search looks so much better than any other search engine

LWD, (edited )

deleted_by_author

    •
    Liome,
    @Liome@pawb.social avatar

    It does though? Right under the search bar there should be a switch bar to turn on localized search, and a dropdown to pick different location.
    Or is it itself location locked?

    https://pawb.social/pictrs/image/55f269a9-475d-4068-adf9-83739fe38121.png

    Cheradenine,

    Yes like many other search providers you can set to all, or whatever, but ddg will always localize your searches.

    Honytawk,

    I have the opposite problem.

    It is always unlocalized, and even if I set it to Belgium, it still is giving me French and German Sites.

    thanksforallthefish,

    Nope not locked. I have always on vpn (random countries) anti fingerprinting and DDG happily allows the search localisation to my actual or a different country

    LWD, (edited )

    deleted_by_author

    •
    Cheradenine,

    It is not accidental, they localize searches

    detalferous,

    Try kagi.com

    I you have to pay for it, but t’s amazing

    Gallardo994,

    Thanks for mentioning Kagi! I’ve been looking for some Google/DDG replacement but every single one I’ve tried had some sort of dealbreaking drawback for me. Google collects all my data and heavily filters my results, DDG provides dogshit results most of the time I don’t even bother using it, Startpage is awfully slow, and I didn’t even get to understand what Searx is as looking for it led me to some random ugly pages.

    Subbed for 1 year 10 bucks plan. Works super-fast on mobile too. Hell yeah!

    DetectiveSanity,

    I’ll take the trial sometime and see if I should drop the cents

    mtchristo,

    It has been doing this shit for a while. Returning results based on just one key word out of many keywords from my query.

    Lately they have been even ignoring the restrictive +“keyword” syntax and returning whatever shit just so they won’t admit their (or Microsoft’s indexer) is shit

    DetectiveSanity,

    It’s not the fact that there are filler results that bothers me, after all there might not be results for everything we may possibly search.

    It’s the fact that these are links to services which have a tie to my unique identifiers which I deliberately declined access to in all available ways!

    Jaysyn,
    @Jaysyn@kbin.social avatar

    My browser (Firefox) is configured the same way.

    No issues with your search term here. I think you have gremlins.

    kat,

    That is Google, not DuckDuckGo?

    Saizaku,

    I’m on ddg and get no such issues with the same query: https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/pictrs/image/233f5d14-ddbc-49b3-b627-97159ba200af.pnghttps://lemmy.dbzer0.com/pictrs/image/21230449-57ac-41a3-b664-09f8ab504b5e.png

    kglitch, (edited )

    The only time I use ddg is to find conspiracy sites to add to the blocklist I maintain. All the trash rises to the top in that search engine. It's rubbish.

    Pantherina,

    No shit in my experience its also filled with random ad stuff and mainly companies selling you shit

    lemmyingly,

    Tell me more…

    Do you maintain the block list to avoid conspiracies or because these types of websites are riddled with nasties?

    kglitch, (edited )

    Mostly to avoid conspiracies. The intended users are people who want to protect vulnerable family members.

    Another purpose is to demonstrate that the big social networks could get rid of disinformation if they wanted to - "look what 1 person can achieve, in their spare time", kinda thing.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • privacy@lemmy.ml
  • localhost
  • All magazines
    •
    Loading…
    Loading the web debug toolbar…
    Attempt #